Opinions on Cayman
Opinions on Cayman
Author
Discussion

996 sps

Original Poster:

6,165 posts

247 months

Sunday 14th October 2007
quotequote all
In the market for an M3 or Cayman, know a fair bit about the M3 but the whole warranty/recall issues are putting me off, see a Cayman tonight on the motorway and never really read a lot or heard a lot about them.

Any useful opinions would be much appreciated.

Oh have took a boxster for a test drive, i'm 6ft 3 and found room very small, is this the same for the Cayman?

Cheers

housemaster

2,079 posts

258 months

Sunday 14th October 2007
quotequote all
Cayman is a great car, my father has gone to a new Cayman S from his M3 and said he would not go back. Not quite as quick in a straight line, thought really not much in it, but better in virtually every other area, bar 2 missing seats and a sligtly bigger boot on the M3.

Cayman on its own is to low on power for my liking.

Edited by housemaster on Sunday 14th October 23:57

milleman

147 posts

276 months

Monday 15th October 2007
quotequote all
Went from a 3.6 996 to a Cayman S and I love it.

More neutral handling than the 996 and its almost as quick in a straight line.

Never tried an M3 so cannot comment on that one, the only thing is to try one and see what you think.

Be carefull with the options list if your buying new though, the price soon goes up!


shoestring7

6,196 posts

277 months

Monday 15th October 2007
quotequote all
996 sps said:
Oh have took a boxster for a test drive, i'm 6ft 3 and found room very small, is this the same for the Cayman?
If it was a 987, yes. But the Cayman has about 20mm more legroom than a early model Boxster.

As for options, make sure you try one with 19"s before you decide to buy. The big wheels look great but screw up the ride. I've known owners return their car because they (or their spines) can't live with the ride on 19's. However if you can find one with PASM (active suspension) this is much less of a problem.

SS7

Vr6-er

2,248 posts

271 months

Monday 15th October 2007
quotequote all
shoestring7 said:
996 sps said:
Oh have took a boxster for a test drive, i'm 6ft 3 and found room very small, is this the same for the Cayman?
If it was a 987, yes. But the Cayman has about 20mm more legroom than a early model Boxster.

As for options, make sure you try one with 19"s before you decide to buy. The big wheels look great but screw up the ride. I've known owners return their car because they (or their spines) can't live with the ride on 19's. However if you can find one with PASM (active suspension) this is much less of a problem.

SS7
I'm a boxster owner who borrowed a Cayman and remember it having great headroom. I am a short-arse though.

I'm on my second with 19's (2.7 initially and now 3.4) and have never thought it harsh. My wifes A4 on 18's is appalling though and my yardstick.

milleman

147 posts

276 months

Monday 15th October 2007
quotequote all
If I was re-ordering mine again the only thing I would think hard about would be the wheels, went for 19" which do look great but do have an effect on the ride quality.

I'm 6'2" and the headrooms fine, even with sports seats (very comfortable).

shoestring7

6,196 posts

277 months

Monday 15th October 2007
quotequote all
Vr6-er said:
shoestring7 said:
996 sps said:
Oh have took a boxster for a test drive, i'm 6ft 3 and found room very small, is this the same for the Cayman?
If it was a 987, yes. But the Cayman has about 20mm more legroom than a early model Boxster.

As for options, make sure you try one with 19"s before you decide to buy. The big wheels look great but screw up the ride. I've known owners return their car because they (or their spines) can't live with the ride on 19's. However if you can find one with PASM (active suspension) this is much less of a problem.

SS7
I'm a boxster owner who borrowed a Cayman and remember it having great headroom. I am a short-arse though.

I'm on my second with 19's (2.7 initially and now 3.4) and have never thought it harsh. My wifes A4 on 18's is appalling though and my yardstick.
Boxster & Cayman suspension has slightly different settings, mainly to account for differents in stiffness. However some drivers think the ride is acceptable on 19"s. The most important thing is to be aware, and try cars on both.

As said before, PASM makes a major difference and is IMHO a 'must-have' option on Caymans.

SS7

pattyg

1,385 posts

258 months

Monday 15th October 2007
quotequote all
Never driven a Caymen but when the delivery driver handed my BMW over I quizzed him on the best car he'd ever driven as he was covered in Lambo and Maserati badges.

Now this guy had driven EVEYTHING but guess what?, the Caymen got the nod (somehow)

CharlesW

266 posts

279 months

Monday 15th October 2007
quotequote all
I'll second what SS7 says. PASM is a must have. I have 19" wheels and PASM. This set up is very compliant and the ride is superb. Plus, the 19" wheels give you sharper turn in.

Edited by CharlesW on Monday 15th October 20:30

Kirk

49 posts

240 months

Monday 15th October 2007
quotequote all
Tried a Cayman after my M3. Depends on what you like. The M is more lively, faster and more fun. Cayman has better steering, feedback and balance. Bit inert though. I actually ended up with a Z4M coupe. I would add it to your list.

Olf

11,978 posts

249 months

Monday 15th October 2007
quotequote all
Kirk said:
Tried a Cayman after my M3. Depends on what you like. The M is more lively, faster and more fun. Cayman has better steering, feedback and balance. Bit inert though. I actually ended up with a Z4M coupe. I would add it to your list.
At current prices you'd be crazy not to consider the Z4MC

911wise

1,887 posts

240 months

Monday 15th October 2007
quotequote all
Olf said:
Kirk said:
Tried a Cayman after my M3. Depends on what you like. The M is more lively, faster and more fun. Cayman has better steering, feedback and balance. Bit inert though. I actually ended up with a Z4M coupe. I would add it to your list.
At current prices you'd be crazy not to consider the Z4MC
Agreed. Bang for bucks and all that. Bit rarer too.

Edited by 911wise on Monday 15th October 21:07

jackwood

2,970 posts

239 months

Monday 15th October 2007
quotequote all
I also recommend PASM with 19s. Actually, in retrospect, I would recommend 18s and standard suspension for a great day-to-day car. Other options really depend on what you want the car for. You can go for a Sports spec or a comfort spec. Seem to be a lot more comfort spec (BOSE, full leather, Nav, Climate, phone prep, etc) cars available used than sports spec cars (PASM, Sport Chrono, Sport seats, Sports wheel etc)

51mes

1,557 posts

231 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
Bought a base spec Gaurds cayman, 18" cayman S wheels, Sound pack, leather and a few nice bits of red trim. Lovely perfectly balanced car went up over cat& fiddle run on saturday laoded up with the wife heading for a little hotel for the weekend.

Crappy (non porsche) Satnav took us on a little single track detour up over the tops off the main road to longnor - coped really well with the very uneven surfaces - surprised a few walkers, sheep and the odd cow.

plenty of room - my 6' 2" stepfather gets in mine ok. I'm only 5' 10"...

I almost went for the 3.4 but the 2.7 met my needs/wallet better, comapred to an M3 I'd go for the 3.4 though.

loving porsche ownership and the car to bits....

Simes.

pete.g

1,531 posts

237 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
I'm 6'2" and the wrong side of 17st and I have no bother with my S.

18" wheels and standard suspension are fine if you don't intend to track it.

Best car I've ever driven.

noumenon

1,282 posts

235 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all

Drive both, buy the one you like most.

IMHO:
Cayman - purpose built sports car.
M3 - tarted up cooking saloon based coupe.

Don't forget the Cayman is 200kgs lighter. If it's not as fast in a straight line and round corners, I'll eat my hat. If you manage to use all that performance on UK roads, I'll send you letters (c/o HMPS). Your choice should have nothing to do with perceived performance, both have plenty.

As for the Cayman being the poor relation of the 911. That's what the marketers want you to think. That's why they charge a huge premium for the 911 and Porsche are the most profitable car company in the world.

K Man S

175 posts

241 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
911wise said:
Olf said:
Kirk said:
Tried a Cayman after my M3. Depends on what you like. The M is more lively, faster and more fun. Cayman has better steering, feedback and balance. Bit inert though. I actually ended up with a Z4M coupe. I would add it to your list.
At current prices you'd be crazy not to consider the Z4MC
Agreed. Bang for bucks and all that. Bit rarer too.

Edited by 911wise on Monday 15th October 21:07
Having come from a Z4M, i agree it's a great car and you get a reasonable spec for your money at £36k (ex demo) BUT it's not a porsche and the build quality doesn't compare. Performance wise, straight line, there's very little in it particularly with short shift and Sport Sychro. Even 30 upwards acceleration, the CS can compete. Round a track, the CS comes into it's own. The Z4M has a little too much power for the chassis and brakes IMHO, and the standard conti's really to put the Z to shame with most owners changing to PS2s as soon as they can. That said the engine is sublime and faultless but let down by the gear box which is no patch on the CSs. Believe me when i say this is all from personal experience and i'm still (for my sins) a member of the Z club with circa 10 friends with Z4MRs & Cs and regularly meet up on track days weekends away etc...

The CS is a great car and it terms of all round performance it's a great balance. OK, it'd be nice to have a few more bhp and a bit more torque (which you can remidy) but i do question how often you actually need it and whether (like the Z) it would be wasted through lack of traction and the CSs relatively poor standard brakes.

Comparing the M3 and the CS is a rather difficult one as they are 2 different beasts. I have to admit, if i wanted a 4 seater (or 2+2) performance car then i'd probably be looking at a Porsche rather than a BMW cool .

Olf

11,978 posts

249 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
K Man S said:
911wise said:
Olf said:
Kirk said:
Tried a Cayman after my M3. Depends on what you like. The M is more lively, faster and more fun. Cayman has better steering, feedback and balance. Bit inert though. I actually ended up with a Z4M coupe. I would add it to your list.
At current prices you'd be crazy not to consider the Z4MC
Agreed. Bang for bucks and all that. Bit rarer too.

Edited by 911wise on Monday 15th October 21:07
Having come from a Z4M, i agree it's a great car and you get a reasonable spec for your money at £36k (ex demo) BUT it's not a porsche and the build quality doesn't compare. Performance wise, straight line, there's very little in it particularly with short shift and Sport Sychro. Even 30 upwards acceleration, the CS can compete. Round a track, the CS comes into it's own. The Z4M has a little too much power for the chassis and brakes IMHO, and the standard conti's really to put the Z to shame with most owners changing to PS2s as soon as they can. That said the engine is sublime and faultless but let down by the gear box which is no patch on the CSs. Believe me when i say this is all from personal experience and i'm still (for my sins) a member of the Z club with circa 10 friends with Z4MRs & Cs and regularly meet up on track days weekends away etc...

The CS is a great car and it terms of all round performance it's a great balance. OK, it'd be nice to have a few more bhp and a bit more torque (which you can remidy) but i do question how often you actually need it and whether (like the Z) it would be wasted through lack of traction and the CSs relatively poor standard brakes.

Comparing the M3 and the CS is a rather difficult one as they are 2 different beasts. I have to admit, if i wanted a 4 seater (or 2+2) performance car then i'd probably be looking at a Porsche rather than a BMW cool .
Not wanting to be a bore but you can get yourself an ex-bmw HQ Z4MC with ~3k on the clock with prof satnav for under 30k now.

K Man S

175 posts

241 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
Olf said:
K Man S said:
911wise said:
Olf said:
Kirk said:
Tried a Cayman after my M3. Depends on what you like. The M is more lively, faster and more fun. Cayman has better steering, feedback and balance. Bit inert though. I actually ended up with a Z4M coupe. I would add it to your list.
At current prices you'd be crazy not to consider the Z4MC
Agreed. Bang for bucks and all that. Bit rarer too.

Edited by 911wise on Monday 15th October 21:07
Having come from a Z4M, i agree it's a great car and you get a reasonable spec for your money at £36k (ex demo) BUT it's not a porsche and the build quality doesn't compare. Performance wise, straight line, there's very little in it particularly with short shift and Sport Sychro. Even 30 upwards acceleration, the CS can compete. Round a track, the CS comes into it's own. The Z4M has a little too much power for the chassis and brakes IMHO, and the standard conti's really to put the Z to shame with most owners changing to PS2s as soon as they can. That said the engine is sublime and faultless but let down by the gear box which is no patch on the CSs. Believe me when i say this is all from personal experience and i'm still (for my sins) a member of the Z club with circa 10 friends with Z4MRs & Cs and regularly meet up on track days weekends away etc...

The CS is a great car and it terms of all round performance it's a great balance. OK, it'd be nice to have a few more bhp and a bit more torque (which you can remidy) but i do question how often you actually need it and whether (like the Z) it would be wasted through lack of traction and the CSs relatively poor standard brakes.

Comparing the M3 and the CS is a rather difficult one as they are 2 different beasts. I have to admit, if i wanted a 4 seater (or 2+2) performance car then i'd probably be looking at a Porsche rather than a BMW cool .
Not wanting to be a bore but you can get yourself an ex-bmw HQ Z4MC with ~3k on the clock with prof satnav for under 30k now.
Just satnav and that mileage - i very much doubt it. Have you got a link? You're talking £32k-£38k depending on spec.

Thorny

1,076 posts

241 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
K Man S said:
Olf said:
K Man S said:
911wise said:
Olf said:
Kirk said:
Tried a Cayman after my M3. Depends on what you like. The M is more lively, faster and more fun. Cayman has better steering, feedback and balance. Bit inert though. I actually ended up with a Z4M coupe. I would add it to your list.
At current prices you'd be crazy not to consider the Z4MC
Agreed. Bang for bucks and all that. Bit rarer too.

Edited by 911wise on Monday 15th October 21:07
Having come from a Z4M, i agree it's a great car and you get a reasonable spec for your money at £36k (ex demo) BUT it's not a porsche and the build quality doesn't compare. Performance wise, straight line, there's very little in it particularly with short shift and Sport Sychro. Even 30 upwards acceleration, the CS can compete. Round a track, the CS comes into it's own. The Z4M has a little too much power for the chassis and brakes IMHO, and the standard conti's really to put the Z to shame with most owners changing to PS2s as soon as they can. That said the engine is sublime and faultless but let down by the gear box which is no patch on the CSs. Believe me when i say this is all from personal experience and i'm still (for my sins) a member of the Z club with circa 10 friends with Z4MRs & Cs and regularly meet up on track days weekends away etc...

The CS is a great car and it terms of all round performance it's a great balance. OK, it'd be nice to have a few more bhp and a bit more torque (which you can remidy) but i do question how often you actually need it and whether (like the Z) it would be wasted through lack of traction and the CSs relatively poor standard brakes.

Comparing the M3 and the CS is a rather difficult one as they are 2 different beasts. I have to admit, if i wanted a 4 seater (or 2+2) performance car then i'd probably be looking at a Porsche rather than a BMW cool .
Not wanting to be a bore but you can get yourself an ex-bmw HQ Z4MC with ~3k on the clock with prof satnav for under 30k now.
Just satnav and that mileage - i very much doubt it. Have you got a link? You're talking £32k-£38k depending on spec.
http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&t=447335

http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/gassing/topic.asp?h=0...

http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/gassing/topic.asp?h=0...



Edited by Thorny on Tuesday 16th October 14:30