FIFTH GEAR or TOP GEAR
Discussion
For me its fifth gear which is a little more like the old style Top gear and is about consumer car buying and ownership.
Now adays Top gear seem to be more about three half wits consisting of a Porsche lover a Porsche hater and a guy whos seen as the idiot of the trio.
Parts of the show are enjoyable ie the celebrity around the track but most of the time the things done in the cars are reckless and have no connection to how a car owner would use the car.
Now adays Top gear seem to be more about three half wits consisting of a Porsche lover a Porsche hater and a guy whos seen as the idiot of the trio.
Parts of the show are enjoyable ie the celebrity around the track but most of the time the things done in the cars are reckless and have no connection to how a car owner would use the car.
Top gear for me all the way.
I find all Fifth Gear do is copy TG in a boring, sensible sort of way. I like the humour and banter of TG even if half their stuff is nothing to do with everyday motoring, but it's thoroughly entertaining!
I guess that's why there is still a slot for Fifth Gear to be made.
I find all Fifth Gear do is copy TG in a boring, sensible sort of way. I like the humour and banter of TG even if half their stuff is nothing to do with everyday motoring, but it's thoroughly entertaining!
I guess that's why there is still a slot for Fifth Gear to be made.
See, now I would say VBH is one reason TO watch 5th Gear 
Also, i like the fact that it is based in the Ace Cafe. No audience to pander to for cheap laughs.
Personally, Top Gear is too much family entertainment now and not enough about real cars on real roads, with the odd exception, like last week's "best road in Europe", which I missed ... and haven't been able to find the repeat
So Miss Butler Henderson, keep it up for the boys

Also, i like the fact that it is based in the Ace Cafe. No audience to pander to for cheap laughs.
Personally, Top Gear is too much family entertainment now and not enough about real cars on real roads, with the odd exception, like last week's "best road in Europe", which I missed ... and haven't been able to find the repeat

So Miss Butler Henderson, keep it up for the boys

TG I've always loved but its too stale now. Yes its vaguely entertaining, but its more about the presenters egos and tomfoolery. Too many fake adventures which have clearly been well rehearsed and scripted from the start.
Bits of it are still interesting, the odd car review and stig putting them thru their paces, but the rest of it I'll happily fast fwd past.
Bits of it are still interesting, the odd car review and stig putting them thru their paces, but the rest of it I'll happily fast fwd past.
Top Gear all the way........although I do find 'Star in a Reasonably Priced Car' the most boring bit of the whole show and drags on for too long normally.
on 5th - VBH shrieks too much, bloke who seriously needs a haicut is annoying, Tiff can be OK, and the other bloke is fine most of the time but only gets a small amount of airtime.
on 5th - VBH shrieks too much, bloke who seriously needs a haicut is annoying, Tiff can be OK, and the other bloke is fine most of the time but only gets a small amount of airtime.
For me both programmes are the same. Egos showing off the pointless things they have learned to do with powerful cars.
Once these programmes were useful insights into the pros and cons of all types of car. Now? Well, what is the point?
e.g. Who would make a choice because the R8 is 2 seconds quicker round a contrived test track in the wet, or because the 911 is a nose faster over a quarter of a mile? Anyone who says 'me' should get a life.
If I had to choose it would be TG because I believe those 3 at least have an inkling as to how meaningless they are. Unfortunately I think that VBH, JP and all take themselves ever so slightly seriously.
Once these programmes were useful insights into the pros and cons of all types of car. Now? Well, what is the point?
e.g. Who would make a choice because the R8 is 2 seconds quicker round a contrived test track in the wet, or because the 911 is a nose faster over a quarter of a mile? Anyone who says 'me' should get a life.
If I had to choose it would be TG because I believe those 3 at least have an inkling as to how meaningless they are. Unfortunately I think that VBH, JP and all take themselves ever so slightly seriously.
burriana said:
See, now I would say VBH is one reason TO watch 5th Gear 
Also, i like the fact that it is based in the Ace Cafe. No audience to pander to for cheap laughs.
Personally, Top Gear is too much family entertainment now and not enough about real cars on real roads, with the odd exception, like last week's "best road in Europe", which I missed ... and haven't been able to find the repeat
So Miss Butler Henderson, keep it up for the boys
et voila:
Also, i like the fact that it is based in the Ace Cafe. No audience to pander to for cheap laughs.
Personally, Top Gear is too much family entertainment now and not enough about real cars on real roads, with the odd exception, like last week's "best road in Europe", which I missed ... and haven't been able to find the repeat

So Miss Butler Henderson, keep it up for the boys

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KO74b7If5MU&mod...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3CKLy40RBPw&mod...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eEiHQIi0pTk&mod...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r00mijzkQeI&mod...
http://www.mininova.org/tor/928581
This is the Top Gear episode that has the european roads on it. If you need a client download 'Azureus'
This is the Top Gear episode that has the european roads on it. If you need a client download 'Azureus'

Gassing Station | Porsche General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



