Quirks of finance
Quirks of finance
Author
Discussion

P15TON

Original Poster:

499 posts

267 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
I am considering returning to 911 ownership & have been gathering data to help my decision. My first requirement is that it has to be new, as my experience of used ownership was not great. My second requirement (due to the reality of life) is that I will need to buy it on finance, probably a PCP.
Having spoken to a couple of finance specialists it seems to me that there isn't going to be a fat lot of real cost difference to me in buying a new 997 turbo over a C2S or C4S if I shop around for the finance.
So my question is, is it worth buying anything less than a turbo....?

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
I'm intrigued to hear how they managed to hide the £30K price difference.

Henry 145

267 posts

231 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
Same here - do they have massive balloons?

Marki

15,763 posts

301 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
Henry 145 said:
Same here - do they have massive balloons?
Sorry is this the Nigela thread ,, i seem lost biggrin

Deutscher

1,430 posts

250 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
P15TON said:
Having spoken to a couple of finance specialists it seems to me that there isn't going to be a fat lot of real cost difference to me in buying a new 997 turbo over a C2S or C4S if I shop around for the finance.

I'd have a damn good look at those figures if I was you.

garyjones1962

402 posts

242 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
Deutscher said:
I'd have a damn good look at those figures if I was you.
Yep - it is the Nigella thread biggrin

P15TON

Original Poster:

499 posts

267 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
I have been told that due to 'rock solid residuals' the 997 Turbo is very cheap to finance. Other cars I looked at (M6, CLS63AMG) didn't come up anything like as well, despite being much cheaper cars. Also other 911 models weren't 'much' cheaper to my pocket (ie the real cost) than the Turbo.
I have been offered (based on £25000 deposit) £599 p/ month for 36 months, based on 10K pa on a new 997 Turbo.
Residual is £72K after three years.
What are you're thoughts? (particularly Nigella's....)
Is it going to end up in a major negative equity situation?

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
So in 3 years time you'll have paid out £46.5K and you'll still owe £72K on it, even though it'll probably be worth more like £55-60K. Sounds like a great deal - not

P15TON

Original Poster:

499 posts

267 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
No finance deal is a GREAT deal.....

Deutscher

1,430 posts

250 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
I thought it was Turbo vs C2 vs C4S?

ineedagallardo

1,601 posts

263 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
When i recently inquired about finance on a 997 turbo the figures based on 95k car were more like,

40-50k balloon with payment around £1100 per month over 48 months,

Id like to know who quoted the £599 figure?

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
True, that's why it's a bad idea to heavily finance a very expensive and rapidly depreciating asset. But it's your money, so if you think the Turbo will end up costing the same as a C2S then go for it and you can let us know how it worked out in 3 years time.

Erik997

1,289 posts

239 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
Financing a depreciating asset never makes true mathematical sense.

Also, be very careful about balloons and the crap that finance companies say about residuals, etc. In the end they don't care about residual values. In three years they'll want a cheque from you to cover the balloon - how you get them the money is up to you (sell the car, pay cash, etc) - if your car is worth a fiver then they'll take your house instead...!

Be careful what you sign up.

P15TON

Original Poster:

499 posts

267 months

Tuesday 16th October 2007
quotequote all
Deutscher said:
I thought it was Turbo vs C2 vs C4S?
Yes, you're right. Quoted £660 monthly payment for a C2S Tip with 25K down over 3 years (this is from a different source.)

When I got the 997 turbo quote, it seemed like a lot of car for the sameish money.




anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 17th October 2007
quotequote all
P15TON said:
Yes, you're right. Quoted £660 monthly payment for a C2S Tip with 25K down over 3 years (this is from a different source.)

When I got the 997 turbo quote, it seemed like a lot of car for the sameish money.
The difference will be the size of the final lump sum you will owe on the car. If you're happy paying out £46.5K to effectively hire a 911 Turbo for 3 years then that's fine. But make sure the final payment is at least less than the value of the car, otherwise it will be even more costly. £72K is not a realistic residual on a 3 year old car costing £100K new. £50K would be closer to the mark. So your finance deal will effectively cost you £68.5K and all you'll have to show for it are memories.

Don't fall for the low monthly payment scam. It's the oldest finance trick in the book. Total cost is the only thing that matters in the end. Of course buying any new car will lead to a substantial financial loss, even with zero finance, but this deal you've been quoted is madness.

JohnV

72 posts

233 months

Wednesday 17th October 2007
quotequote all
Only way to consider a PCP is to work out a 'realistic' value for the car in three years and then deduct the amount that you are putting down as your deposit. I.E. if your new car is £100k, the 3 year value is £60k and you put a £25k deposit down then the maximum ballon that you should consider is £60k - £25k = £35k. Try this and see how your monthly repayments come up to a more realistic level. Anything higher and the term 'balloon' takes on a slight different and more personal meaning. You might even want to drop off a couple more thousand to give yourself a bit of extra protection.

PCP can help to reduce your monthly cost but if you end up losing your deposit, along with all your repayments then it can be a very expensive lesson to learn. Also make sure to understand what happens if you want to break early - finance houses realise that idiots like us want to change more frequently than 3 years and have all sort of penalities, some of the ways they calculate their repayments can also hurt you if you break early as you may have been paying a lot of the interest for the first period of the loan, rather than reducing the capital.

I think the best help people here can give you is if they can let you know the realistic 3 year values (trade and retail) for a C2S, specc'd up to say £73k new and a Turbo £100k. You might find that a finance house tells you the car will be worth x amount and then you take it to a dealer and they give you the 'trade' price. Voila, you've just lost another £6/7k.

Good luck.


P15TON

Original Poster:

499 posts

267 months

Wednesday 17th October 2007
quotequote all
Thanks for the input guys.
Ho hum, back to real world then.....
....I know my place
997 C2S it is!

Stirlings.co.uk

324 posts

254 months

Wednesday 17th October 2007
quotequote all
[quote=P15TON]I am considering returning to 911 ownership & have been gathering data to help my decision. My first requirement is that it has to be new, as my experience of used ownership was not great. My second requirement (due to the reality of life) is that I will need to buy it on finance, probably a PCP.



Look at the savings on buying a low mileage used car,
I ve got 2 5000 mile cars, an 18 month old car £15,000 off the new price and a 2.5 yr old car £18,000 off new,

both just serviced both with Porsche warranties,

If its being financed you can still have a balloon pcp type deal, 2 year servicing intervals, extend the porsche warranty for £895 a year, why buy new?

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 17th October 2007
quotequote all
Buying brand new only really makes sense on a car like this if you intend to keep it for 10+ years. On a 911 you could expect a residual of around £15K in 10 years time. So if you paid £70K new, it would effectively cost £5.5K per year + finance & running costs. Which is not too painful and you go from owning a state of the art Porsche to a clssic Porsche in the process!

But buying new and selling in a couple of years is simply burning money. For example in 3 years time you'd be lucky to get £35K back on a £70K car, so it's costing you something like £12K per year. But this loss can be reduced massively by buying a 1 year old car to take full advantage of the high initial depreciation. As you mentioned in your first post, there are pitfalls with buying used, but it should be easy to find a mint 1 year old car with virtually zero risk.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 17th October 2007
quotequote all
the car will depreciate, financed or not. its borrowing 75k at nearly 10% thats dumb