Advice on a 996
Author
Discussion

mansoor999

Original Poster:

50 posts

229 months

Thursday 18th October 2007
quotequote all
Hi all,

I need advice. Within the next month, i want to be a 911 owner but i have questions.

I'm pretty set on the 996 but there are a few things that i'm not sure on.

1. Does the Carrera 2 come in a cabriolet model?
2. Are the hoods on all the convertables power?
3. How heavy is a hard top?
4. I'm hearing bad info on reliability and build compared to older models. Is it as bad as what people say or is it just a small number of people with load voices?
5. Are the Carrera 4's much slower than the Carrera 2's?
6. Are the Carrera 2's that much more fun to drive?

If any of you guys are happy to chat over the phone with advice, let me know and i'll send my number.

Hope someone can help and thanks in advance

Mansoor

Jon_Bentley

202 posts

235 months

Thursday 18th October 2007
quotequote all
Cant speak with total authority, but ive owned my first porsche since April of this year. Its a 2000 996 C2 and its been fantastic.
its a tip, hardtop, so cant answer many of the questions youve asked, but its been well looked after and came with a complete pedigree which seems to be one of the most important elements in making your purcahse i.e. 6 owners, 54K miles and 8 service stamps in the book with evidence that its never gone without what it needed!

there is a lot of debate about dealers and running costs etc, but every car and circumstance is different, all i can suggest is that when you find a car you like the look of and get a good feel about, bring it to this forum and get the necessary support and questions to go back and get answered by the dealer to make sure your getting what you should be

Jon

(see profile for mine - its great!)

Fidgits

17,202 posts

260 months

Thursday 18th October 2007
quotequote all
Hi and welcome to Pistonheads.

1. Yes
2. Think so.
3. Couldn't tell you

4. (important so sensible answer) No its not as bad as people say. You need to remember the 996 offended the 'purists' so they werent going to like it anyway. Also, the 996 was made in significantly higher numbers than any 911 previously, so the number of 'breakdowns' is proportional.

The major issue is the RMS - but then the 993 suffers from the same thing. Its just a seal at the back of the engine, which sometimes can leak a little oil. As long as you keep an eye on the oil level (the 996's have a digital check at startup which is very helpful) then you'll be fine - it wont suddenly empty the engine instantly.

Worst case, its a cheap part to replace - but the labour is heavy - its always worth getting it changed when you have the clutch done, as it ends up pretty much free.

The other option is to get an OPC warranty, its pricey at 950 for a year, but has a certain peace of mind to it.

There also have been reports of a intermediate shaft bearing failing (or something) but this is very rare - and the sort of thing you only hear about with the advent of Internet forums, where one bloke, somewhere, had this happen, so suddenly its a 'known' problem.

Porsches are a very reliable car - especially for one with 300bhp!

As for build quality, i had no issues on my 98 C2.

5 & 6 Slower, hard to say. But they are heavier, with a smaller boot, and you certainly lose something in the driving sensation - its always worth trying both to see which you prefer, but for me the C2 just felt more agile, and just more fun.

I'd be happy to chat to you on the phone if you want, but you'll find a wealth of information in this forum, and probably in the post after about 12 hours.

The key thing to look for is the service history - and as is said, condition is key. Forget the letter on the plate and the number on the mileometer - you want a car thats been driven regular (but warmed up properly) serviced regular (every 12mo or 12k) and generally looked after.

RobDickinson

31,343 posts

285 months

Thursday 18th October 2007
quotequote all
I've driven a 996 C2S trip , found the back end well planted (mind you it was borrowed so I wasnt pushing it on corners), 'boot' substantial too. Also easy to drive slowly, very civilised, not sure I'd think about 4wd on one at all.

OrangeBob55

206 posts

230 months

Thursday 18th October 2007
quotequote all
mansoor999 said:
Hi all,

I need advice. Within the next month, i want to be a 911 owner but i have questions.

I'm pretty set on the 996 but there are a few things that i'm not sure on.

1. Does the Carrera 2 come in a cabriolet model?
2. Are the hoods on all the convertables power?
3. How heavy is a hard top?
4. I'm hearing bad info on reliability and build compared to older models. Is it as bad as what people say or is it just a small number of people with load voices?
5. Are the Carrera 4's much slower than the Carrera 2's?
6. Are the Carrera 2's that much more fun to drive?

If any of you guys are happy to chat over the phone with advice, let me know and i'll send my number.

Hope someone can help and thanks in advance

Mansoor
1. Yes!
2. Yes
3. 'bloody heavy' - It takes 2 people to fit/remove. (Also needs 2 people to lift/carry around, unless you are strong, and have long arms!).
4. See answers above - Best to have checked over by an expert if you do not have expertise yourself.
5. No. Slightly different driving styles for each though (when driving on the limit).
6. Subjective. Depends if you generally like RWD or 4WD 'characteristics' - Again, you would only really notice any difference when driving on the limit.

Don1

16,885 posts

239 months

Thursday 18th October 2007
quotequote all
1. Does the Carrera 2 come in a cabriolet model? Yes
2. Are the hoods on all the convertables power? Yes
3. How heavy is a hard top? Light, but slightly bulky if you are doing it yourself. Call it about 20lbs.
4. I'm hearing bad info on reliability and build compared to older models. Is it as bad as what people say or is it just a small number of people with load voices? I haven't had any issues, except one (engine out) issue with the oil converters. Covered under warrenty, no questions.
5. Are the Carrera 4's much slower than the Carrera 2's? Not much at all.
6. Are the Carrera 2's that much more fun to drive? Not really...

HTH

thegoose

8,077 posts

241 months

Thursday 18th October 2007
quotequote all
I think you can get a hardtop hoist to attach to a garage roof, so that you can clip it on, undo the hardtop then winch it off out of the way. You can then do this on your own of course.

The cars are reliable so the risk of engine failure is small. However, the repair cost is high (£5k - £10k) and no inspection can predict if yours is likely to "let go" suddenly (short of taking the engine apart to inspect it before purchase). An OPC warranty in good insurance against this at just £895 per year. Treat the decision as with any insurance - you pay your premium and they take the risk or you pay nothing and take the risk yourself.

Wanta996(Gotta)

5,622 posts

238 months

Thursday 18th October 2007
quotequote all
1. Does the Carrera 2 come in a cabriolet model?
Answer - Yes

2. Are the hoods on all the convertables power?
Answer - Yes

3. How heavy is a hard top?
Answer - 33kg

4. I'm hearing bad info on reliability and build compared to older models. Is it as bad as what people say or is it just a small number of people with load voices?
Answer - There are problems but on par with other performance cars i guess,OPC warranty at £895 is essential which i guess sums it up.Overall i would say its good,not great but good.

5. Are the Carrera 4's much slower than the Carrera 2's?
0.2 seconds to 60mph and i think extra weight loses you 2mph top speed, NOTE that convertible will be even slower due to extra weight and slightly effects handling.

6. Are the Carrera 2's that much more fun to drive?
Answer - Yes compared to C4 but also depends what you think is fun. Only GT3's are fun in my eyes,all other varients of 996/997's are boring cars to drive under 80mph - They become alive over 100mph.

hussar10a

449 posts

245 months

Thursday 18th October 2007
quotequote all
thegoose said:
The cars are reliable so the risk of engine failure is small. However, the repair cost is high (£5k - £10k) and no inspection can predict if yours is likely to "let go" suddenly (short of taking the engine apart to inspect it before purchase). An OPC warranty in good insurance against this at just £895 per year. Treat the decision as with any insurance - you pay your premium and they take the risk or you pay nothing and take the risk yourself.
My engine went at 24000 miles, and through an oversight I was completely out of warranty. Rest assured if it's the intermediate shaft that fails and destroys the motor then the Porsche Assist collection AND replacement brand new engine are completely FOC with no quibbles.

Don1

16,885 posts

239 months

Thursday 18th October 2007
quotequote all
In that case is the turbo's hardtop lighter than the normal one? I know I'm not the smallest man in the the world, but it seemed a lot lighter than 30-odd kilos!

johnfm

13,752 posts

281 months

Thursday 18th October 2007
quotequote all
hussar10a said:
thegoose said:
The cars are reliable so the risk of engine failure is small. However, the repair cost is high (£5k - £10k) and no inspection can predict if yours is likely to "let go" suddenly (short of taking the engine apart to inspect it before purchase). An OPC warranty in good insurance against this at just £895 per year. Treat the decision as with any insurance - you pay your premium and they take the risk or you pay nothing and take the risk yourself.
My engine went at 24000 miles, and through an oversight I was completely out of warranty. Rest assured if it's the intermediate shaft that fails and destroys the motor then the Porsche Assist collection AND replacement brand new engine are completely FOC with no quibbles.
You got a free replacement outside the warranty period?

hussar10a

449 posts

245 months

Thursday 18th October 2007
quotequote all
Yes - although in truth my warranty had expired a month earlier due to some sort of mailing software glitch at the OPC, received 5 notices of service required, four of which after I had had it serviced - but no warranty reminder. OPC held up their hands on that.

Intermediate shaft failure is a well documented, albeit rare-ish fault and Porsche will replace the engine FOC regardless of the warranty position.

Bear in mind however that mine is a 2004 with 24000 miles - I honestly have no idea how one would stand with a much older/higher milage vehicle - but from my conversations with Mid Sussex they seemed to suggest that ANY ISF will be replaced.

There are copious threads on this subject here, including my original one when the engine went crunch and IIRC no-one had the slightest problem getting a new engine for free.

mansoor999

Original Poster:

50 posts

229 months

Thursday 18th October 2007
quotequote all
Top guys (and girls) for all the responses. Very interesting and its cleared up one of the major issues i had and that is whether to go specifically for the C2 cab or the C4 cab. As it goes, i dont mind but will have a much better idea after a few test drives.

Will keep you posted on what comes!!

Thanks

fastfreddy

8,577 posts

268 months

Thursday 18th October 2007
quotequote all
hussar10a said:
Intermediate shaft failure is a well documented, albeit rare-ish fault and Porsche will replace the engine FOC regardless of the warranty position.

Bear in mind however that mine is a 2004 with 24000 miles - I honestly have no idea how one would stand with a much older/higher milage vehicle - but from my conversations with Mid Sussex they seemed to suggest that ANY ISF will be replaced.

There are copious threads on this subject here, including my original one when the engine went crunch and IIRC no-one had the slightest problem getting a new engine for free.
Total bollox. If you have engine or gearbox related problems with your 996 and you don't have a warranty, it is very unlikely that the dealer or Porsche will foot the bill. They may make a contribution if the car is relatively new, low mileage, or you are a long term Porsche customer, but otherwise you will be looking at a big bill. The intermediate shaft was a bad bit of design, along with a few other aspects of that engine but Porsche will never admit that and so they will often just shrug their shoulders, say "we've never seen that happen before" and add up the cost of a shiney new engine (+labour) for you to pay once you've got up off the floor.

Edited by fastfreddy on Friday 19th October 09:22

All2Chewy

263 posts

229 months

Friday 19th October 2007
quotequote all
With regards to reliability, I now have 117,000 miles on my Year 2000 C2 and no issues. Bought with over 100,000 miles and first new clutch done at 110,000 as the previous 1 owner used it for motorway commuting, so warmed up and never ragged. Well worn in and now it gets driven like it should, no issues at all. The point of this rambling is to know the history of the car, if then engine is going to go "pop" my opinion is that it will do it before you get to 45,000 miles mark. By on condition, service history and if possible find out how it was driven previously. Something with high mileage and good service history is in some ways going to be a more reliable car, also will cost you less.

Hammerwerfer

3,234 posts

271 months

Friday 19th October 2007
quotequote all
Are you set on a cab? Do you wish to do any track days? If so, a coupe is better suited.

Tiptronic to be avoided at all costs of course.


Lurking Lawyer

4,535 posts

256 months

Friday 19th October 2007
quotequote all
mansoor999 said:
4. I'm hearing bad info on reliability and build compared to older models. Is it as bad as what people say or is it just a small number of people with load voices?
Do a search for posts on 996 engine failures by a forum member called hartech (Baz Hartech owns and runs a well-known and very well-respected independent Porsche service/maintenance business) and read for yourself a bit about the problems with the 996 engine, the frequency with which they arise and the potential downsides.

The short version, as you have already read above, is that you'd be foolish to buy one without the safety net of an OPC warranty.

Davel

8,982 posts

289 months

Friday 19th October 2007
quotequote all
Can't add much to what has been said already.

I've just bought a manual C4S, Oct 02 Model and I'm very impressed with the performance and handling.

The 4WD is useful in poor weather conditions but a 2WS is also fine, provided you drive accordingly.

If you buy one with a sunroof, you have the best of both worlds regarding a hard top and a cabriolet.

Either choice, the grin factor is huge.

Enjoy!

mansoor999

Original Poster:

50 posts

229 months

Friday 19th October 2007
quotequote all
As it goes, i am set on a cab cos i think they look fantastic. Dont get me wrong, i think the coupes do too but i think i should get a good deal in the winter on a cab and if its got a hard top, then thats great.

I've come to the conclusion that it doesn't really matter whether i get a c2 or a c4 as i'll only realise the fine differences if i really push the car. I'm not going to be taking it to track days even though i do generally drive cars like they should be driven!!

The one i get will most probably be a 99/00 model on my budget but i'm trying to get black/blue with teh hyde leather and obviously full service history. Also going to get a warrantee no doubt.

Will keep you all updated!!

The Griffalo

72,863 posts

270 months

Friday 19th October 2007
quotequote all
Do you need the rear seats? If not a 986S is a far better convertible than the 996.