993 diagnosis
Author
Discussion

James Shunt

Original Poster:

14 posts

257 months

Monday 22nd October 2007
quotequote all
Boo hoo. The football, rugby and F1 were all rubbish so I decided to get the 993 out last night to cheer myself up with a quick drive. Oh dear.

Selecting gears in recent weeks has been hard when the car is cold and I have noticed occasional clutch slip since the end of summer. Not that worrying, though selecting gears needed a firmer than usual shove for the first five minutes last time I used the car.

Yesterday I started the car, and it would not let me select any gear - I could almost get the stick into a gear but not quite. Even a very firm push was fruitless. Repeated clutch presses and allowing the car to warm up for a couple of mins made no difference.

A search showed a 964 thread suggesting something similar turned out to be a clutch pin - please let it be that simple/easy - but I am afraid it might be a more serious gearbox/clutch problem or replacement.

Any experience of this out there before I ask my indie about it... and how many beers should I expect to forego to pay for fixing it?

Gulp (but no gulps of beer, in this case).

Thanks

James

wildoliver

9,325 posts

247 months

Monday 22nd October 2007
quotequote all
Well if your clutch were slipping then I wouldn't expect it to also be hard to engage gears, the two are opposite problems if you follow......

However both could be caused by a problem with the clutch actuation system, now that could well be the clutch pin that is sticking, not allowing the clutch to fully operate, or release giving both of those problems, and the fact it clears as the engine heats up does tie in quite well.

To remedy the problem the pin will have to be drawn out of the gearbox casing with its brushes, cleaned off, the pins greased (and no doubt the bearings all put back together) and refitted.

I'm sure it is possible to do with the engine in situ by dropping the front box mount and trying to wriggle around the engine and box, but with the best will in the world it will probably be easier and maybe cheaper to drop the power unit.

If you drop the power unit you may as well do the clutch at the same time as the big job is getting the engine out.

clubsport

7,420 posts

289 months

Monday 22nd October 2007
quotequote all
964 clutch "roll pin" is down at the pedal end,,symptoms are normally a hanging pedal, as in will not return..if the pedal has a reasonable feel and rebounds it is less likely to be the pin or slave cylinder.....if the clutch has many 000k miles maybe it is due for replacement?..a clutch is to a certain extent a consumable?
I assume the oil level and type of oil a used is up to standard?

James Shunt

Original Poster:

14 posts

257 months

Monday 22nd October 2007
quotequote all
Thanks chaps.

The oil is fine and I checked the level last time I took it out (though it was too dark and I was too stroppy to double-check the level last night). The pedal works as usual, yes.

The service history I got with the car has no clutch work and goes back 25k miles so it could be in need of replacement... which is what I was worried about!

Perhaps the clutch slipping is a minor, unrelated thing but it seems too much of a coincidence.

Lurking Lawyer

4,535 posts

256 months

Monday 22nd October 2007
quotequote all
Mike from Sports & Classic (who posts on here from time to time) recently quoted me £875 (presumably plus VAT) for a replacement 993 clutch, so that will give you some idea of the number of beers you'll have to forego if a new clutch is required....

wildoliver

9,325 posts

247 months

Monday 22nd October 2007
quotequote all
The pin i was referring to is the actuating arm swivel pin.

But I'd certainly check your pedal, master and slave before dropping the lump.

Oliver

lanan

814 posts

259 months

Monday 22nd October 2007
quotequote all
James, try to engage a gear without the engine running, that takes the clutch out of the equation atleast. If you can get a gear, start the engine, with the clutch down, with a clear space ahead, just incase you lurch forwards into a wall, that will hopefully give a few more clues.
Graham

James Shunt

Original Poster:

14 posts

257 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Good suggestions. I'll certainly try the gearbox when the car isn't running and if it goes into gear, the 'rolling start'.

It may have to wait until at least Sunday as I'm out tonight and away from tomorrow but I'll report back with some conclusions.

Thanks

James

gary11

4,163 posts

232 months

Friday 26th October 2007
quotequote all
hi mate you need a clutch dont keep trying to force it into gear you will bugger up the syncros!
spoken from experiance !!!

James Shunt

Original Poster:

14 posts

257 months

Monday 5th November 2007
quotequote all
It's not good news. No miracle repair. I tried selecting gears without the engine on and it was fine. As soon as you start the car, you can't select anything... except this frown face.

I thought about starting it in gear but I bottled it - it might cause more damage and could leave the car stranded across the pavement where I can't move it. Ditto re forcing it into gear, Garry - it didn't seem a wise move.

My indy tells me that if the clutch pedal was to the floor it could be a simple hydraulic problem. As the pedal is normal, it is almost certainly the clutch. Estimated cost is £850 plus labour - it would be more for a C4.

Thankfully I took the better option for my RAC membership so I can get it trucked there without paying loads. Will report back with costs, differences noticed, feedback etc. for the time being, if your clutch starts to slip, then your gearbox gets sticky, beware...

James

wildoliver

9,325 posts

247 months

Monday 5th November 2007
quotequote all
I must say if the clutch is slipping AND gearbox is hard to engage I would really be surprised if it is a clutch problem, really sounds hydraulic/actuating system.

gary11

4,163 posts

232 months

Monday 5th November 2007
quotequote all
when the presure plate is shot and the friction plate/flywheel, the clutch will not clear you get a similar effect if you try to engage a gear with the pedal not fully depressed,porsche clutches vary a lot on the pedal when worn some bite at the top some go heavy some feel like they are not dissengaging properly,may be hydraulic try a power bleed first,good luck
gary

gary11

4,163 posts

232 months

Monday 5th November 2007
quotequote all
sorry just noticed you said clutch slipped before,it will require replacement,get a n o.e one from eurocarparts (basildon/london),I recently put one in one of my stock cars much cheaper!!

Grebo911

48 posts

230 months

Tuesday 6th November 2007
quotequote all
BTW a clutch kit for a 993 is about £350 plus vat - so don't know where your getting £850 plus labour - would have thought that was about full wack including fitting and vat.

James Shunt

Original Poster:

14 posts

257 months

Tuesday 6th November 2007
quotequote all
Well spotted Grebo - my concentration was obviously shot by the disappointment of an impending and large financial outlay - it should read £850 plus VAT for a fitted clutch.

Will ask my indy about other possibilities before the work gets done.

Thanks for your help, chaps.

James

James Shunt

Original Poster:

14 posts

257 months

Tuesday 13th November 2007
quotequote all
An update on this - good news and bad news!

The good news is that the RAC came out to have a look and (I assumed) bring a truck along to take it to my indy. The guy thought the clutch pedal was slightly lower than it should be - I tried it and agreed, though it didn't seem drastically different. Perhaps I hadn't noticed it changing over time. It wasn't spongy. He fiddled around with the pedal mechanism, tightened a couple of bits and hey presto - a working clutch! It is still slipping a little but pulls away from rest in 4th no problem, so it's got quite a bit of life left in it. Not being able to get into any gear was purely because the pedal mechanism had come awry.

The bad news is I felt a bit stoopid and had to cancel my booking at my indy.

Still, at least I don't have to spend that £1k yet and can afford a beer or two.

James

James Shunt

Original Poster:

14 posts

257 months

Tuesday 13th November 2007
quotequote all
... and I forgot to take WildOliver's advice to check the pedal. Duh.

wildoliver

9,325 posts

247 months

Tuesday 13th November 2007
quotequote all
I think someone else suggested it before me actually.

It's good news anyway, I found on mine the point the clutch started slipping wasn't setting off it was changing gear at full throttle it would start to slip, if it isn't doing that then this tiny slip might still be due to clutch operating mechanism being out of adjustment/sticky.