$4.5 million settlement in Porsche CGT crash
$4.5 million settlement in Porsche CGT crash
Author
Discussion

RDMcG

Original Poster:

20,920 posts

238 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
http://www.sportscarmarket.com/content/carrera

OK..any bets here?...Will the 997 GT3RS be the last Porsche road car without stability control?...My guess is yes.

LukeBird

17,170 posts

240 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
I'm sorry, but that was a ridiculous court case!
I remember reading it before and wondering how far it would go...
Obviously feel sorry for the widow and any other dependents, but I don't agree with it!

timmo

1,788 posts

265 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
The 997 RS has all sorts of PSM and traction control devices
look how they gobble up the rear pads !!!

I think the 996 RS was the last one without any sort of electronic driver aids


Conian

8,030 posts

232 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Oh FFS he jumped into a high powered car, how is that Porsche's fault?
Did the owner need to tell anyone 'hey mate this car is fast, be careful'?

Yeah tha track wasn't great. only now they have less money to put it right.
Grrrrrrrrrrr blame mentalitly.

You watch she'll be driving a Ferrari soon with her millions of $$$'s

Loach

3,357 posts

247 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
To answer your PSM question, when the technology is there and proven, though it pains me to say it, I can see no valid reason that the Porsche legal and marketing department won't make it standard fit on everything. It's happening anyway, but incidents like the above just help remove any doubt that it will happen. We're already there, though - no?

As for the case, whilst the initial reaction is to go mental at a numpty CGT owner, there seems to be more to this - reflected in the fact that Porsche, the trackday organisers and the track operators were held jointly liable. It's just a shame that the ramifications of these cases eventually percolate down to spoil things somewhat for the rest of us. It's a pity the CGT guy just didn't take things a bit easier - these trackdays are not races, and whilst the Ferrari may have pulled out in front of him, and whilst there should have perhaps been lights at the entry to the track, it seems he was on the ragged edge and perhaps beyond his abilities.

Edited by Loach on Tuesday 23 October 16:03

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
banghead

Kurgen

1,447 posts

265 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Interesting as to % of payout..



The contributions to the settlement were about 49% from the estate of the driver, 41% from the track owners and the event organizers, 8% from Porsche, and 2% from the driver of the Ferrari that was claimed to have triggered the crash.

Bodo

12,626 posts

297 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Anyone noticed the disclaimer at the end of the article?

JOHN DRANEAS is an attorney and a car collector in Oregon. His comments are general in nature and are not intended to substitute for consultation with an attorney.

If I collected indications that we are living in a society, where the lowest common denominator rules, this would be one. nuts and indeed banghead

PhilLL

1,123 posts

231 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
I think they case against the track looks justifiable enough, given the repositioning of the concrete wall, but he still signed a release form to participate in the trackday.

I fail to see why Porsche should be held acountable for not providing PSM on such a machine though.

"Most people, especially those with children on the streets and highways, would fear a vehicle like the Carrera GT, with its tricky handling characteristics, 600-plus horsepower, and unskilled, unqualified drivers. When a 'race car for the streets' is sold to anyone with enough money, regardless of his ability to drive it, and it doesn’t even incorporate modern electronic safety devices that correct driver errors, then maybe the manufacturer should accept some responsibility for the foreseeable deaths that will result."

What next? Being held accountable for having RWD and over 200bhp because the average driver can't handle it? How about taking responsibility for some of your own actions?

JK75

318 posts

267 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Have to agree. The Porsche liabililty is silly and I do wonder where will this go next....However:

The track and the CGT owner were to blame and justifiable punished IMO... The owner was warned by both an inspector (who the track officials also ignored) and his mechanics not to take the car out... He ignored them all and did not inform his passenger....

RANT ON - I would be censored livid, if some one I knew got into a car and then found out that the car was deemed unsafe and the driver and track officials knew it... regradless whether they got round safely or not, I would censoredcensored em.... - RANT OFF


anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
PhilLL said:
I think they case against the track looks justifiable enough,
completely disagree.
you could argue EVERY track could be safer, so you set a very bad precident. i think it would only be justifiable if the circuit somehow tricked drivers into thinking it was safer than it was. ultimately its the driver who should assess what risk they want to take not the track.

as for this particular cgt having a handling 'problem', i'm not sure what their case was... that this particular car was bad or that ALL cgt's were bad? the fact that both driver and porsche got hit would suggest both!

fvcking lawyers

Edited by fbrs on Tuesday 23 October 18:35

DanH

12,287 posts

291 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
JK75 said:
The owner was warned by both an inspector (who the track officials also ignored) and his mechanics not to take the car out... He ignored them all and did not inform his passenger....
He was warned that the CGT was inherently tail happy. Well thats how the car is, what is he meant to do? (apart potentially from ensuring his skill matched his aspirations and purchasing power).

From what I've heard though, the car isn't tail happy at all unless you do something pretty silly. You could say that of 911s too.

Koln-RS

4,129 posts

243 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
There are countless examples of absurd US legal conclusions. No wonder the compensation culture is so rife over there.

softinthehead

1,550 posts

270 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Conian said:
Oh FFS he jumped into a high powered car, how is that Porsche's fault?
Did the owner need to tell anyone 'hey mate this car is fast, be careful'?

Yeah tha track wasn't great. only now they have less money to put it right.
Grrrrrrrrrrr blame mentalitly.

You watch she'll be driving a Ferrari soon with her millions of $$$'s
people who are bereaved often need to seek some form of formal justification or explanation, and in the US the only way to get any admission of fault is to sue. reading the court report about the track, the driver and the course organisers I think she may well have had some valid points. The 8% against Porsche is odd, since Porsche have never claimed the CGT is anything other than it is.
Before you pass judgement on the woman, spare a thought- she may even have loved the guy.

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Does PSM remain engaged all the time - I assume you'd turn it off on a track anyway?

Of course, next thing there'll be a suit for allowing PSM to be disabled.

ChrisW.

8,166 posts

286 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
And on many cars PSM cannot be truly disabled.

Surely track days, for normal drivers, are about learning the limits of both car and driver -- and learning how to control the car as these limits are approached.

If the car is driving, what is the point ?

Better to ride a roller coaster ? !!!

bosscerbera

8,188 posts

274 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
A grim precedent.

Cars are inanimate objects until the driver takes charge. What the hell happened to taking responsibility for one's actions?

m12_nathan

5,138 posts

290 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
An utter joke. It is a 600bhp car with no PSM, how hard is it to realise that it needs some respect.

graeme36s

7,230 posts

248 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
Many very valid points posted. God only knows where the potential ramifications of this could filter down to. I understand why the passengers widow wanted to look for some financial redress at the loss of her husband. In the US as we all know it is potentially easy money and I do feel sorry for her.
But lets face it for those of us that participate on track days we all know the risks we take. Perhaps as indicated from the percentages, the circuit was not so proffesionaly run as track days are over here. I can't think off hand of any circuits that prefer concrete barriers over armco protection.
The PSM is another issue.
I personally have no wish for such a device. I agree for many it is a life saver and in truth would prefer my mrs to be driving a car with the added electronic devices that would help her survive if she gets into trouble. But I believe in having the right to choose. For us all to be slung into a world of nanny state electronic do gooder's is absolute bo**cks.

flattotheboards

6,689 posts

237 months

Tuesday 23rd October 2007
quotequote all
m12_nathan said:
An utter joke. It is a 600bhp car with no PSM, how hard is it to realise that it needs some respect.
exactly its hardly porsches fault is it.