Boxster vs 911
Author
Discussion

bher

Original Poster:

786 posts

301 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
I hope I do not start a too political topic but coming from the Lotus community I am thinking about a Porsche as an everyday car.
My questions are quite easy.
Why is the boxster carrying such a bad image (small porsche, women's car,...)? I see it as a flat 6 mid mounted with almost 300 bhp in the S version..
I agree that the 911 is a more beautifull car but I red also that the weight was quite high and except on highways the power was not that easy to manage.
So far I tried a 996/4 conv and felt it awesome on speedways but heavy on b road (coming from my elise) I do not want to start a topic elise vs porsche I see good points in both and certainly want to avoid any arrogant remarks.

Thanks.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
I'd rather have a Boxster than a 911 pram for sure. Only jealous peasants and status conscious 911 trophy car owners slag the Boxster off. Everyone else thinks it's a great sportscar.

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
uktrailmonster said:
Only jealous peasants and status conscious 911 trophy car owners slag the Boxster off. Everyone else thinks it's a great sportscar.
yes

Box is about the best roadster money can buy. But

  • You have to want a roadster
  • You have to not mind that the 911 will always have a more powerful engine
  • It helps to want a mid-engined car. i.e. in the right place. hehe
If you want a 911 you simply MUST buy a 911. Buying a Boxster is just not the same thing. I bought two Boxsters in a row because

  • 911: Been there, done that. Proper old one with none of the namby-pamby electronic driver aids.
  • I wanted a roadster. Some of us like messing up our hair - rather than being hairdressers...
If you don't want/need the roof to come off don't buy a Boxster: its what it is for.

Silver993tt

9,064 posts

270 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
If you're coming from an Elsie then maybe a Cayman would be more suitable with regards handling, rigidity etc.

rude-boy

22,227 posts

264 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
Boxsters were the first of the water cooled revolution. This upset a lot of the airheads. The early cars (2.5 like mine) were and are considered underpowered. Well as underpowered as any 200bhp+ car can be, although the chassis could easily cope with 200bhp more. They are also convertibles and as such will always attract the hairdresser comments usually reserved for MX5’s, MGF’s and the ilk. Oh and they offered an entry to Porsche ownership for less money than before so you can see why this upset a few.

The bottom line is that anyone who truly loves cars would have a dig about hairdressers, jumped up beetles and Audi rejects (924) but would then get to the real business of debating if the engine should be in front or behind the centreline of the rear axel and mid corner speed Vs traction from the centre apex.

The ones who really get hot under the collar are those how buy their Porch because Adrian has a Fezza and that’s just so last year darling. And let’s face it who gives a shit about their opinion anyway other than themselves.

IMO there is only one car made by Porsche which I don’t really think they should be making but when you see how much profit they make on every Cayenne sold I don’t care, so long as they keep making GT3’s, GT2’s CGT’s and so on

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
Silver993tt said:
If you're coming from an Elsie then maybe a Cayman would be more suitable with regards handling, rigidity etc.
Aye but the "Elsie" is a roadster too. Cayman more comparable to an Exige in the Lotus range.

Box is surprisingly rigid - it was designed from the ground up to be roofless (like the Elise). There's an argument that the Cayman, since its chassis is based on the Boxster, isn't as light as it could/should be given the extra rigidity of the roof.

All the same clearly a coupe *will* be more rigid. yes

All depends on what the OP wants. If the roof must come off the Box is a great choice. If the roof doesn't have to come off? Maybe not. If the OP actually wants a 911 a Box would be a very poor choice indeed...because it's not remotely like one!

rude-boy

22,227 posts

264 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
Don said:
If you don't want/need the roof to come off don't buy a Boxster: its what it is for.
Funnyt thing i have noticed is that when the sun is shining it is the boxster owners that are usually the first to drop the top, even before the Tiv owners*, and they are the last ones to think about putting it back up again when it goes out.






* I susupect this is only due to 1) the length of time to take the lid off them and 2) the lack of a heating system that can decide if it wants you deep fried or frozen

bher

Original Poster:

786 posts

301 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
Just to improve the topic.

My elise is so much track oriented that I even do not take it for week-end or parties with my wife.
I am now thinking at something more comfy. Convertible is a must and I am thinking at a boxster or a targa (prices are different but you get something else)
I even wonder which boxster (nl vs S) to take as the goal is not to trash every gear (I have the elise for this) but to enjoy week-end trips, rallies and journeys

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
bher said:
Just to improve the topic.

My elise is so much track oriented that I even do not take it for week-end or parties with my wife.
I am now thinking at something more comfy. Convertible is a must and I am thinking at a boxster or a targa (prices are different but you get something else)
I even wonder which boxster (nl vs S) to take as the goal is not to trash every gear (I have the elise for this) but to enjoy week-end trips, rallies and journeys
The Boxster is a great touring car. Two weeks touring for two...easy. The roof isn't stored in the luggage compartment so you can pack BOTH (front and rear) full of stuff. You will need squashy bags: do not consider Porsche's expensive luggage!

Since you are keeping the Elise for track work (good choice - I loved the Elise on track) you could well consider a non-S car...particularly a 987.

The major upgrades of the S are

  • some more power (approx 40bhp depending)
  • six speed gear box
  • bigger brakes - drilled discs
These differences are worth it if you track the car (I do) as being brake-fade free for a longer session is good. Out on the road? The non-S may be quick enough!

Its good you are keeping the Elise for the track. Very sensible. A Box eats tyres, brakes and discs on track. I know because I've done it. The Elise should be significantly cheaper to run as a track toy.

Vr6-er

2,248 posts

271 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
911 is only significantly better by reputation. Boxster 3.4 or Cayman 3.4 are two of the best cars money can buy.

Whtever you do dont buy a 4wd.

RT

919 posts

276 months

Wednesday 24th October 2007
quotequote all
There is only one answer. Drive both back to back and properly.

I would suggest you try a 911 C2, a C2 cab, a Boxster and a Boxster S - back to back if you can.

It will be clear which one you want.

I agree that the entire range are great - for whatever reason I won't even begin to try and understand I hated driving the Boxsters and loved the C2 - which is what I have.

I genuinely think they are all great cars - but they are all very different cars.

bher

Original Poster:

786 posts

301 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies.

The other good point with the 911 are the 2 rear seats (I have 3 children).

I do not like so much the line of the convertible. I was thinking at the targa (original, beautifull and keeping its value(?)) Why avoid a 4 wd? bad handling?

I could also go for a regular 997 C2 BUT this is quite basic (Great car but I like to buy something a bit different) and I wonder if a second hand is not a better value due to the number on the market?


Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
bher said:
Thanks for the replies.

The other good point with the 911 are the 2 rear seats (I have 3 children).

I do not like so much the line of the convertible. I was thinking at the targa (original, beautifull and keeping its value(?)) Why avoid a 4 wd? bad handling?

I could also go for a regular 997 C2 BUT this is quite basic (Great car but I like to buy something a bit different) and I wonder if a second hand is not a better value due to the number on the market?
Personally I would happily have a 4WD. But it will handle quite differently to the RWD cars.

If you need rear seats the Box is no good to you.

If you want *value* and lower depreciation buy second hand. You can obtain an extended warranty for £900 a year from Porsche that covers anything major going wrong.

Once again - personally I wouldn't go for the Targa. Neither one thing nor the other. But some love it.

You really must go and sit in them and, if possible, drive them and see for yourself what you want.

Dr S

5,162 posts

257 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
As always, it depends on what you want:

  • the mid-engined feel of the Elise but more geared towards regular road use and able to also cope with longer trips - go for the Boxster S which is an amazing car and best value in all the Porsche ragen
  • something entirely different - then go for the 911 (RWD) as the rear engined layout will provide you with a very unique driving experience
Enjoy

Vanya

2,058 posts

275 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
bher said:
The other good point with the 911 are the 2 rear seats (I have 3 children).
If you need to accommodate 3 children then the 911 won't work for you either...

scratchchin

I suppose you could stack them! biggrin

Dr S

5,162 posts

257 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
Wurls said:
The Boxster that was created by Porsche as an overtly commercial exercise to tap the status conscious "mass" market and drive down costs in sharing the production platform with the early 996. I've nothing against the car but I think its clear from Porsches recovery in the 90's that they needed "a trophy car for the masses" to survive. This is why IMO the Boxster has an "image" problem.
Well, the 911 is considered an "icon" and therefore the true "trophy" car in the Porsche range. People who want to show off definitively prefer a 911 over a Boxster.

It was also the Boxster that was launched BEFORE the 996. So you should call the latter a "marketing exercise" which basically extracted a massive premium (which links back to the "trophy" argument) for a car which was basically a Boxster with the (bigger) engine in the wrong place.

I love my 997S but I also know that the Boxster S is much better value for money.

Ranger 6

7,736 posts

280 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
bher said:
The other good point with the 911 are the 2 rear seats (I have 3 children).
I've got two children and it was that reason I bought a 911. We can all go out in it, that's a big difference for us. The alternative would have been a much newer Boxster and less flexibility.

I don't rag it or track it so the ultimate in dynamics would be lost on me.
But the occasional hoon does happen.....

bher

Original Poster:

786 posts

301 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
Vanya said:
bher said:
The other good point with the 911 are the 2 rear seats (I have 3 children).
If you need to accommodate 3 children then the 911 won't work for you either...

scratchchin

I suppose you could stack them! biggrin
My elise has only 2 seats and this is another reason why I do not use it that much outside the track. While moving to Porsche I try to find something which will ticks almost all the boxes (sport, convertible, 4 seats, best handling, design, originality,... and cheap biglaugh)cloud9

pete.g

1,531 posts

237 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
I've driven a Targa and a 987 Boxster S (3.4) back to back - the Targa is much more of a cruiser than the Boxster - I found it too soft for my tastes. The 4wd adds a lot of weight and the ride is quite floaty. The 987 was set up to be as sporting as possible - PASM, 19"s, short shift, sport chrono - it was unbelievably good. When I come to change my Cayman S I'd definitely consider a car like this - the price difference between the two would allow me to spec the Boxster to a much higher level.

Vr6-er

2,248 posts

271 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
Wurls said:
The Boxster that was created by Porsche as an overtly commercial exercise to tap the status conscious "mass" market and drive down costs in sharing the production platform with the early 996. I've nothing against the car but I think its clear from Porsches recovery in the 90's that they needed "a trophy car for the masses" to survive. This is why IMO the Boxster has an "image" problem.
Ignore this, its irrelevant twaddle. The Boxster has won numerous awards for its ability. IMNSHO its one of the best VFM cars on the plant and from a pedigree manufacturer.

The Boxster does share many components with the 99X series.
The Boxster was created to ensure Porsche's survival.
At launch the masses couldn't afford it, £37k for a well specced 2.5 wasn't cheap in 1996. At £35k today it is very cost effective. I dont think that Porsche were expecting the level of success they have achieved.


Wurls, why dont you really tell the masses or is that peasants what you really think of us? That is such an elitist opinion.

Edited by Vr6-er on Thursday 25th October 12:06