Think I've found my 911 - but its not black :(
Think I've found my 911 - but its not black :(
Author
Discussion

petrolhead76

Original Poster:

1,597 posts

247 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
Think I've found my 911 (being advertised locally) - its a C4 in absolutely mint condition, with a GT3 kit and a loving owner. Its got all the usual stuff you look for.

Its even cheaper than I expected - but its silver (with black interior) and not the basalt black I was looking for. I've always wanted a black porsche but this one looks so good and is mint - its even got the alloys I particularly like.

Now the dilema - do I go for this or not? Has anyone ever done a compromise like this with a car and then regretted it ? Is there anything anyone can tell me about black which can put me off ?!!

C2look

3,858 posts

256 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
Black will be a lot harder to 'keep clean' compared to silver. You will be forever washing it and will also really emphsise any swirl marks in the paint.

Lurking Lawyer

4,535 posts

256 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
Only you know how much of a "must have" it is to get the car in black! Will you always regret not holding out for a black one, even if the silver one ticks all the other boxes, is in good condition and reasonably prices....?

When I started looking for a 993, I had preferred colours but to a large extent was open-minded about what I'd go for, given that manual Targas seemed (at least at the time) to be rarer than hens' teeth. Buying one in good nick that wasn't going to cost an arm, leg and kidney to run was more an issue for me.

There are probably more 996s on the market though, so you can perhaps afford to be a bit more choosy, knowing that a black one that fits the bill will come up eventually - it's a popular colour so it shouldn't be too long before there's a used one for sale.

Davey S2

13,394 posts

285 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
You need to appreciate that if you are buying a second hand car its 99% certain that you arent going to get your perfect spec.

I would buy on condition not colour. Silver wont be too hard to sell on in the future.

Testarossa

1,050 posts

252 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
I so wanted a black 911, but every one I saw, even cared for examples just did not have the gleam I associated with mint black 911s.

I bought a silver one, because it looks shiny clean or dirty, but it never looks drop dead like a black one (when clean!)

But I'll live with it.

If you can wait, get a black one, if you can't, well just remember the wrong black one will cost you more than a full respray!

996C2

2,649 posts

241 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
petrolhead76 said:
I've always wanted a black porsche
There's your answer, don't buy it, every time you see a black 911 you'll regret buying it.


Koln-RS

4,131 posts

243 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
Personal choice but, IMO, flat black is a difficult colour to maintain. Most look scruffy close up.

Silver is much easier, suits Porsches, and should still be popular at re-sale.


Vr6-er

2,248 posts

271 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
You'd be amazed at how few were any colour other than silver on earlier 996's, you may have a long wait.

Make sure you look closely, the metallic black predecessor to Basalt Black could look very dark brown in certain lights and you may not like it. It stopped me buying it.

nbetts

1,455 posts

260 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
Be careful what you wish for... From being a small boy I always dreamt of owning a black 911 - Anyway in 2006 I bought a brand new 997 Carrera S - It looked fantastic.

For about 4 hours.....

I found myself flicking every mark, fingerprint, birdcrap off the car. It was a monster to keep clean and was very very unforgiving colour.

But man... those first 4 hours...

Silver, whilst being common... always looks sharp and does not hide the lines like a black car and is very forgiving for marks, dirt etc etc.

Maybe this is a blessing in disguise.

Li Moo Bai

847 posts

236 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
How about you buy it and trade it in for a black one later if needs be?

stubbsy996

785 posts

244 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
I would personally go for the silver - I did when I bought mine smile
Had two silver cars now. You wash em fairly reularly they always look clean.
Had a black car once - never again. Horrendous to keep clean, show every mark, streak, dust etc!

tracer.smart

658 posts

242 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
996C2 said:
petrolhead76 said:
I've always wanted a black porsche
There's your answer, don't buy it, every time you see a black 911 you'll regret buying it.
Totally agree. There are some things just not worth the compromise.

woogie

3,313 posts

283 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
Basalt Black rules, it must do I have one wink

PetrolHead what county do you live in ?

Edited by woogie on Thursday 25th October 13:30



Black looks amazing when clean but rubbish when dirty, Silver looks good when clean and still not bad when it's dirty . If you are gonna clean it once a week then get Black if it's a once a month job then get Silver IMO.

Edited by woogie on Thursday 25th October 13:33

petrolhead76

Original Poster:

1,597 posts

247 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
woogie said:
Basalt Black rules, it must do I have one wink

PetrolHead what county do you live in ?

Edited by woogie on Thursday 25th October 13:30
Still pondering....might go to a porsche showroom and see both at their best...live in the Midlands (near birmingham).

Lurking Lawyer

4,535 posts

256 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
OPC Solihull or Sutton Coldfield should be within easy reach then.

I used to live a couple of miles up the road from OPC Solihull and regularly pass it en route to my favourite country road stretch - there was always a preponderance of eye candy there to drool over as I went past....

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
petrolhead76 said:
Still pondering....might go to a porsche showroom and see both at their best...live in the Midlands (near birmingham).
Sounds like you want a black car more than you want a 911 FFS!

Koln-RS

4,131 posts

243 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
petrolhead76 said:
Still pondering....might go to a porsche showroom and see both at their best...live in the Midlands (near birmingham).
But they all look good in the showroom. In fact, black is often described as 'a showroom colour'.

Walk around central London, you'll see enough Porsches in black and silver to help you decide.

petrolhead76

Original Poster:

1,597 posts

247 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
Just come back from Shirleys Porsche Garage in meridan - difficult to decide between the two. Black looked awesome, but I could see some marks on it which would get on my nerves. The silver ones just looked mint.

Aggi

141 posts

270 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
If you are like most men then after a few days you'll have realised that the "compromise" was actually the best choice anyway! Ive got a silver one and it looks great even when dirty (which it rarely is!!)
As Henry (over familar dont know the bloke) says buy on condition not (age) colour!


woogie

3,313 posts

283 months

Thursday 25th October 2007
quotequote all
petrolhead76 said:
Just come back from Shirleys Porsche Garage in meridan - difficult to decide between the two. Black looked awesome, but I could see some marks on it which would get on my nerves. The silver ones just looked mint.
You can polish swirls out , you need to take them both for a drive, Black ones are faster apparently.