You've all put me off 911s
You've all put me off 911s
Author
Discussion

Clevers

1,171 posts

232 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
petrolhead76 said:
I GIVE UP.

RMS, Engines Blowing Up, 0000s pounds of work on well sourced OPC cars within weeks of taking it off the forecourt!

TBH I wish I never found this forum - I feel paralysed by fear to even now go and purchase what was my dream car !

The recent thread on engine / rms has completey blown my confidence in thse cars and the warranties - i.e. RSJ has put forward they would replace the engine (and I regarded them as a high quality outfit), but a linked thread clearly states that RSJ are a PITA when it came to a claim (butcher boy) which then makes me wonder how much other independents & porsche will squirm out of trying to sort problems for me.

F**K it,I'm going to buy a BMW M5. I'll always love the porsche but I'm not stupid enough for the heart to rule the head...if it did I would have gone ferrari.

BMW ? Do you sell vacuum cleaners ?


Edited by petrolhead76 on Saturday 27th October 21:14

IMI A

9,997 posts

232 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
hmmm yeah an M5 - bastion of reliability!!!laugh

Ordinary Bloke

4,559 posts

229 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
That's where I've arrived. Watercooled is out, as I'm not a city type where £85 sounds like good value. £10-15K is my limit, maybe £20K if I can persuade her it's an investment, but that means no OPC warranty, and that means £10K bill if the worst happens.

Maybe it's 1 in 5 chance, maybe 1 in 20, maybe 1 in 100, but there are a lot of cars out there where it's 1 in a few thousand chance and £3-5K to put it right. B0llocks, I may end up with a TVR at this rate.

Year 11, is there anyway to insure against 996 engine calamity?

Clevers

1,171 posts

232 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
Sorry you have been put off 911 ownership, but frankly, I have just had the nightmare of having a broken engine (self inflicted not reliability), but I can honestly say that every time I get in the 911 it makes my day.

In the evening, I open the garage door and flick the light on just to look at her. Can't imagine I would ever feel the same way about an M5, great cars though they are.

Don't go to your deathbed saying "I wish I'd had a 911"

guyvert1

2,167 posts

273 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
petrolhead76 said:
I GIVE UP.

RMS, Engines Blowing Up, 0000s pounds of work on well sourced OPC cars within weeks of taking it off the forecourt!

TBH I wish I never found this forum - I feel paralysed by fear to even now go and purchase what was my dream car !

The recent thread on engine / rms has completey blown my confidence in thse cars and the warranties - i.e. RSJ has put forward they would replace the engine (and I regarded them as a high quality outfit), but a linked thread clearly states that RSJ are a PITA when it came to a claim (butcher boy) which then makes me wonder how much other independents & porsche will squirm out of trying to sort problems for me.

F**K it,I'm going to buy a BMW M5. I'll always love the porsche but I'm not stupid enough for the heart to rule the head...if it did I would have gone ferrari.


Edited by petrolhead76 on Saturday 27th October 21:14
FFS every manufacturer has issues, you just happen to be listening to a small percentage of one. Ask around, porsche's are pretty bloody reliable, not least stunningly capable.. Stop typing on your keyboard, go out and try a few and if you've got the balls, make a good decision and buy one, they aren't one of the most profitable makers of cars because they're shite!!!

Ordinary Bloke

4,559 posts

229 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
Oh god yes, I would never get a BMW as a fun car. But 996 and Boxster (don't car if anyone wants to have a go at the latter, I like 'em) are off my list unless I inherit big-time. Odds of big bills appear too high.

Do you happen to know if I could do my own work on a 964/993? My vague understanding is that you need plenty of special tools, there's no room to get at anything so you have to dismantle half the internals to change a spark plug etc.

That's when a front-mounted engine makes a lot of sense, easy DIY.

(If I had a 911 in my garage, I'd be out there every 2 minutes to admire it)!

Ballcock

3,855 posts

250 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
I recommend spending some readies on a big comfy couch ...




....In front of a psychologist!!

You're getting hot under the collar and moist of pit from listening to an internet forum where , honestly , folk are only going to post if their car is giving them a pain in de arse.

TAKE IT EASY!!

  • The 996 is probably more reliable than any M5
  • The Porsche warranty is far and away a better product than the BMW one
  • If you read the RSJ thread properly you'd see that the dealer got done by the courts , not the other way around ,IIRC RSJ was always willing to replace the engine with another second hand engine .. The buyer would only accept a new engine , that's why it ended in court.
Best thing you could do?

Get yourself down to rsj , buy one of their '02 996's .. get them to have it checked and put on an OPC warranty.

Now , take 2 Valium and don't call me in the morning hehe


Ordinary Bloke

4,559 posts

229 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
If you're answering me... won't work, as the type of 911 I can afford is going to be 10.001 years old. And I'm scared of the engine going POP!

Ballcock

3,855 posts

250 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
Ordinary Bloke said:
If you're answering me... won't work, as the type of 911 I can afford is going to be 10.001 years old. And I'm scared of the engine going POP!
Nah , It was a bit of tongue in cheek to the OP ..


Clevers

1,171 posts

232 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
Ballcock said:
Ordinary Bloke said:
If you're answering me... won't work, as the type of 911 I can afford is going to be 10.001 years old. And I'm scared of the engine going POP!
Nah , It was a bit of tongue in cheek to the OP ..
So am I....but on my death bed I won't be saying "I wish I had worked more"

Crimp a Length!

5,697 posts

254 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
Buy a 993/964/930 then if worried about 996 engines.
Or spend more on a 996 and get the one with the blowers.

Ballcock

3,855 posts

250 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
Ordinary Bloke said:
Do you happen to know if I could do my own work on a 964/993? My vague understanding is that you need plenty of special tools, there's no room to get at anything so you have to dismantle half the internals to change a spark plug etc.
Someone pointed this site out to me last night .. It's great find , and might answer the question on whether you can do some of your own work on a 993 ... http://p-car.com/diy/diy.html
thumbup

Ordinary Bloke

4,559 posts

229 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
Ballcock said:
Someone pointed this site out to me last night .. It's great find , and might answer the question on whether you can do some of your own work on a 993 ... http://p-car.com/diy/diy.html
thumbup
Coolio, exactly the sort of thing I need. Please everyone say bad things about 993's on this forum as I need the price to drop a little... Ta!

Edited by Ordinary Bloke on Saturday 27th October 21:46

[AJ]

3,079 posts

229 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
For some reason when I drive past M5 drivers and they always look at me with wantant eyes. I really hope it's my 997 they're checking out!

Chauch

520 posts

243 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
I have to say I am in exactly the same boat. I was really looking forward to at last getting into a 996 although am now nervous of it.

Most of the 996s I have been considering will now just fall out of the OPC warranty criteria and I am now concerend about the resiudal values long term as most of the threads on here I read talk down the reliability.


Are there any decent options at sensible money from other warranty companies to replace the OPC offered one?

bull996

1,442 posts

240 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
See Hartech for an ongoing warranty/servicing scheme. Circa £50 per month.

ineedagallardo

1,601 posts

263 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
To be fair the op has a point.

With both of my e46 M3's i never had any problems having work done under warranty,

Even with items that shouldnt have been covered, I got them done with a bit of moaning.

This however has not been the case with my Porsche.

If anything ever goes wrong its always down to either wear and tear, User abuse, not covered by extended warranty or some other shoddy excuse.

Even well docemented problems that were clearly down to manufacturer defects from the offset are not covered, and even a call to PGB never seems to sort it out,


The're basicly like we're not covering you and we're big old Porsche who can't be messed with so off!

To name but a few;

Corrosion on 996 gt3 rs alloys - not covered

Corrosion on 996 door sills due to factory fitted stainless kick panels - not covered.

Generation 1 pccb's with an origional claim of lasting over 100000 miles be it road or track - not covered.


To say this has tarnished my view of the brand and its after care program is an understatment.

However i prefer there cars over Bmw's and decide to stick with the Porsche brand even if it does mean me having to stick my hand in my pocket for things that with a bmw i probably wouldnt have to.


Don't take this as moaning i just feel Porsche's piss take attitude with aftersales and warranty is a shambles,

If my Gt2 didnt put a smile on my face like it does every time i turn the key i would have sold it a long time ago.





Edited by ineedagallardo on Saturday 27th October 22:37

wildoliver

9,325 posts

247 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
Porsche's are reliable period.

Some have issues, but a minor proportion of the total build. Costs are vastly over inflated. Rms? Yeah major problem, you might even get a spot of oil on your garage floor!

As to the guy who thinks you need to take half the engine out to change 964 plugs.......It is a horrible job, nowhere near as easy as on a mini......did you really think it would be? But it is doable with ordinary tools. I have genuine porsche plug spanners and used a draper socket out of choice as it allowed me to do it with exhaust system in situ. Time to change all 12, circa 40 mins start to finish.

Stop living your lives on the internet and get a car bought and enjoyed.

9hellheaven

1,595 posts

240 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
Oh for sure this is like ooh should I or shouldnt I? Will it or Wont it? What if but or maybe?..I dont mean to offend but some people take an age farting about doing anything in this life. It took my mate eight bloody years to get his arse over to Daytona for bike week with me last year.
Listen guys providing you are not trying to do the tasty car thing on a total shoe string budget, just go for it. Of all the cars with this pedigree what else offer what Porsche do? All things considered Porsche is the way to go.
If it doesnt sit comfy with you as individuals, well again without being rude by a Ford!
Life is short...JUST DO IT!

Ordinary Bloke

4,559 posts

229 months

Saturday 27th October 2007
quotequote all
9hellheaven said:
Oh for sure this is like ooh should I or shouldnt I? Will it or Wont it? What if but or maybe?..I dont mean to offend but some people take an age farting about doing anything in this life. It took my mate eight bloody years to get his arse over to Daytona for bike week with me last year.
Listen guys providing you are not trying to do the tasty car thing on a total shoe string budget, just go for it. Of all the cars with this pedigree what else offer what Porsche do? All things considered Porsche is the way to go.
If it doesnt sit comfy with you as individuals, well again without being rude by a Ford!
Life is short...JUST DO IT!
Your shoestring may be slightly more 18ct gold than my sad piece of string.

Or to put it another way, without wanting to start a very boring thread, if you had £15K to spend, and £3K/year to run it, would you buy a watercooled or aircooled Porsche?