how would a boxster, cayman and 968CS compare on a track???
how would a boxster, cayman and 968CS compare on a track???
Author
Discussion

nickb55

Original Poster:

276 posts

240 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
assuming quickest versions of the first two, any opinions/experience of how the 3 would compare?? I've driven most of the porsche range at one time or another, incl 911 supercup (well, "driven" is a bit of an overstatement!), but never boxster or cayman.

Davey S2

13,394 posts

285 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
Depends on the track I would say.

Cayman S would be quicker than Boxter S.

If they were both standard cars on a bigger track I would say Cayman S.

Shorter tighter track I would say 968


noumenon

1,282 posts

235 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all

Best driver would be quickest. SEOT.

K Man S

175 posts

241 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
nickb55 said:
assuming quickest versions of the first two, any opinions/experience of how the 3 would compare?? I've driven most of the porsche range at one time or another, incl 911 supercup (well, "driven" is a bit of an overstatement!), but never boxster or cayman.
Given the CS's infamy of being one Porsches best handling cars, i suspect the 968 wouldn't come close.

shoestring7

6,196 posts

277 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
Cayman S, without any doubt.

However the Boxster and 968CS drivers would be having just as much fun and would be faster than most GT3's.*

SS7
  • That's a joke, ok?

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
noumenon said:
Best driver would be quickest. SEOT.
Indeed. Given the same driver I would expect

CaymanS, BoxS, 968CS. I reckon it would be very marginal between the first two -given they now have the exact same bhp and , bizarrely, the Cayman ain't much lighter.

K Man S

175 posts

241 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
Don said:
noumenon said:
Best driver would be quickest. SEOT.
Indeed. Given the same driver I would expect

CaymanS, BoxS, 968CS. I reckon it would be very marginal between the first two -given they now have the exact same bhp and , bizarrely, the Cayman ain't much lighter.
Not as bizarre as the Z4M coupe being heavier than the Z4M roadster lol. Sorry off thread - carry on ...

willdew

2,138 posts

295 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
K Man S said:
Don said:
noumenon said:
Best driver would be quickest. SEOT.
Indeed. Given the same driver I would expect

CaymanS, BoxS, 968CS. I reckon it would be very marginal between the first two -given they now have the exact same bhp and , bizarrely, the Cayman ain't much lighter.
Not as bizarre as the Z4M coupe being heavier than the Z4M roadster lol. Sorry off thread - carry on ...
10kgs heavier, but twice as stiff, so I don't think the extra weight is "wasted". I think it's a consequence of the reverse engineering to make a car designed as a convertible into a coupe. How does the Boxster and Cayman compare?

http://www.pistonheads.com/doc.asp?c=100&i=155...

Pistonheads Z4M Coupe review said:
"Scoring 14,500Nm/degree in BMW’s torsional stiffness test, the M Roadster is pretty stiff for an open car, and despite its wide 225/45 and 255/40 rubber on 8.0J and 9.0J x 18-inch alloys rubber, scuttle shake on poor roads in minimal. Even so, it does not come close to the Coupé’s impressive 32,000 Nm/degree, which is more than double the Roadster’s rigidity."
Edited by willdew on Monday 29th October 15:38

richad027

115 posts

256 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
I've driven a 968cs and Boxster s (3.2 987) on track, the 968 is significantly quicker than the boxster S but largely due to the CS's sticky track day tyres, more agressive set up and better brakes. If you upgraded the tyres, setup and brakes then the boxster would be slightly quicker. Never driven a cayman but would expect it to be the quickest with the right tyres setup and brakes.


Richard.


K Man S

175 posts

241 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
willdew said:
K Man S said:
Don said:
noumenon said:
Best driver would be quickest. SEOT.
Indeed. Given the same driver I would expect

CaymanS, BoxS, 968CS. I reckon it would be very marginal between the first two -given they now have the exact same bhp and , bizarrely, the Cayman ain't much lighter.
Not as bizarre as the Z4M coupe being heavier than the Z4M roadster lol. Sorry off thread - carry on ...
10kgs heavier, but twice as stiff, so I don't think the extra weight is "wasted". I think it's a consequence of the reverse engineering to make a car designed as a convertible into a coupe. How does the Boxster and Cayman compare?

http://www.pistonheads.com/doc.asp?c=100&i=155...

Pistonheads Z4M Coupe review said:
"Scoring 14,500Nm/degree in BMW’s torsional stiffness test, the M Roadster is pretty stiff for an open car, and despite its wide 225/45 and 255/40 rubber on 8.0J and 9.0J x 18-inch alloys rubber, scuttle shake on poor roads in minimal. Even so, it does not come close to the Coupé’s impressive 32,000 Nm/degree, which is more than double the Roadster’s rigidity."
Edited by willdew on Monday 29th October 15:38
What i was saying is that it's rare for a roadster to be lighter than it's coupe brother but you're right, it was because the platform for the coupe was borrowed from the roadster rather than the other way round. I wonder then why this principle didn't apply/occur with the boxster and cayman.

By the way, 31,500 Nm/degree - CS; 10,000 Nm/degree - BS.

dark_helmet

303 posts

244 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
Come to Oulton Park tomorrow for the PCGB trackday. I have an older Boxster S with a few tweaks and I am sure there will be a 968 or two in attendance. I know a couple of Caymans will be there too.

I am still in the intermediate or beginner category but when my car is driven by more experienced people they certainly can perform well above most peoples expectations. At the MSV Porsche day in August, I was pretty even with a couple of the 968's there, but a couple of them were running much quicker.

Just my opinion but the older 986 Boxster S is a bit of a performance bargain at the moment, the prices are in the 14's for what is still a very fast and great handling car. I was going to change it but have decided to keep it and make it a bit more track focused.




nickb55

Original Poster:

276 posts

240 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
Unfortunately cant make it, but intend to do more track days next year. I like your website, good pics... and the mini looks a lot of fun!

cheers

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
richad027 said:
I've driven a 968cs and Boxster s (3.2 987) on track, the 968 is significantly quicker than the boxster S but largely due to the CS's sticky track day tyres, more agressive set up and better brakes. If you upgraded the tyres, setup and brakes then the boxster would be slightly quicker. Never driven a cayman but would expect it to be the quickest with the right tyres setup and brakes.


Richard.
Shove sticky tyres on anything and the lap times will tumble. All three are fast cars. If we assume they are all shod with Michelin Pilot Sport Cup tyres...

Is the CS a *lot* lighter than the Box? Power very similar IIRC. BoxS has the uprated braking system...

nickb55

Original Poster:

276 posts

240 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
CS is 1320 kg, i think that's about 100kg lighter ?

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
nickb55 said:
CS is 1320 kg, i think that's about 100kg lighter ?
yes

1,430 kg - Unladen weight of a Boxster S 987. I think the 986 is lighter but could be wrong. I thought it was high 1300s.

Surprisingly lardy. yes

My Chimaera (the other sports car) hehe is less than 1200kg. Handling nowhere near as good, though...

nickb55

Original Poster:

276 posts

240 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
[quote=Don
My Chimaera (the other sports car) hehe is less than 1200kg. Handling nowhere near as good, though...
[/quote]

yes... an interesting power to weight ratio!

dark_helmet

303 posts

244 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
My 2001 986 is supposed to be 1295kg to 1375kg in the user manual, I guess it depends on options etc. I put a Motordrive seat in yesterday and couldnt believe the weight of the standard one smile



Edited by dark_helmet on Monday 29th October 16:59

richad027

115 posts

256 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
Very true sticky tyres, set up and brakes make a big difference to any car, but I think its fair to say that its rare to a cayman setup for the track (I haven't seen one yet but its a very good piece of kit in standard form) , you do see some older boxsters that have been modified and very good they are too, but most 968cs are setup for track use, you even see some using slicks.

All three are really good fast cars on track, its just a case of how little money you want to spend.

Richard.


richad027

115 posts

256 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
One thing worth pointing out about Boxsters/Caymans is that when psm has been turned off the psm is reactivated by causing the abs to kick in, this can be really really annoying on track.

Richard.


Geneve

4,020 posts

250 months

Monday 29th October 2007
quotequote all
The Cayman/Boxsters should be quicker than a 968CS, all else being equal.

I did quite a few track days, and a couple of Porsche driving days, in 968'S's and they are terrific fun. With the roof down, where permitted, the spacial awareness is a huge bonus.