Views in the C4S
Author
Discussion

mansoor999

Original Poster:

50 posts

229 months

Tuesday 30th October 2007
quotequote all
Hi Guys,

I was looking originally at a C2 but i've managed to up my budget to get a C4S (2003). Can anyone give me view on that? Is it the one i should go for or can i get better for the same money ~£40k?

Any common issues you can point out?

Thanks

DucatiGary

7,765 posts

256 months

Tuesday 30th October 2007
quotequote all
the rear wheel drive 911 is what porsche meant you to experience, the real experience of having that engine hanging out the back and you thinking "surely this thing wont handle right" everytime you enter a corner at speed.

thing I found with the 4wd cars is the amount of extra weight up front made the turn in a bit less responsive.

if you want the bling, and to be able to tell people what car you have got, get a C4s, if you want to enjoy the drive and can appreciate the finer things in life, get a c2.

or a gt3

or even better, a gt2.

hth

levron73

211 posts

247 months

Tuesday 30th October 2007
quotequote all
Mate of mine has just negotiated a 997 C2 MY54, good spec with 24k miles and still under warranty for £41k!!!!!! Bargin IMO

Wanta996(Gotta)

5,622 posts

238 months

Tuesday 30th October 2007
quotequote all
Agree to an extent with Ducatti:

C4S looks good,best looking 996 in my opinion and comes with the Turbo brakes and Turbo-Look alloys,Sports suspension as standard and is maybe "just" worth £40K for a low mileage 2004 model. Standard 996C2/C4s are not a 40k car anymore,i wouldnt pay over 35k for one now.

C4S is boring/conservative to drive at everyday speeds(no sense of occasion unless you are start truck by the Porsche badge that is) - I find it similar to a fast 3 series and when you go over the limit is when it comes alive,4WD makes it perfect for our british weather and more importantly in the winter time.

Handling is ok,feels impossible to lose the back to be honest but thats why its not liked in some quarters,too easy to drive quickly. I have heard its because of the 4WD and extra weight though the 4WD TT for some does not seem to get criticised in the same way although after driving one at a track day,i personally thought it felt like a faster version of my C4S.

So to sum up - If you have £40k+ then a 2001 996TT & an early 2004 997 C2 may just be in your budget(facelift GT3's are at £45k at the mo). There is also a 996 Anniversary model with 345bhp thats maybe an option but do not pay £40k for any other 996 bar a C4S and even that is maybe just overpriced.

Issue - Radiators are known to be easily damaged(both of mine have been replaced),expenisve TT Brake Pads & Disks.

Edited by Wanta996(Gotta) on Tuesday 30th October 14:52


Edited by Wanta996(Gotta) on Tuesday 30th October 14:55

flow99

1,339 posts

239 months

Tuesday 30th October 2007
quotequote all
If you can stretch to 40K, would definately scrape together a few extra quid and get a 997, much better car than the 996 C4S.

Wanta996(Gotta)

5,622 posts

238 months

Tuesday 30th October 2007
quotequote all
Not many 997's at 40-42k to be honest unless high mileage or Cat D's. Found highish milegae 997 on clssifieds - http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/226981.htm

Problem with the standard C2 is your brain will start telling you scrape another few £k and get the C2S.

clorenzen

3,847 posts

266 months

Tuesday 30th October 2007
quotequote all
Less is more!. Go for a late facelift Carrera 2 in the best condition you can find and then negotiate hard. You can't do much wrongh with that. The C4S is slower, heavier and has a smaller luggage compartment in the front.


Geneve

4,020 posts

250 months

Tuesday 30th October 2007
quotequote all
I had a C4S on loan from Porsche for several weeks in the winter of 2004.

They are nice enough, and some people like the chunky, unspoilered looks. But, IMO, there are better water-cooled 911s of this era for similar money.

As suggested above, a 996 C2 is a purer example of the original 911 theme, and a 996GT3 lick is the purest - and the enthusiasts' choice. For everyday use, a 997 isn't much more money.

If you really want toys, bells and whistles then consider a 996TT.

Having said that, there is nothing wrong with the C4S, if you find a really good one at the right price. As with any 996, make sure it has a PSE.

Davel

8,982 posts

289 months

Tuesday 30th October 2007
quotequote all
I bought an Oct '02 C4S a few weeks ago.

I went for the 4WD because I use my car everyday and thought it would be a safer bet in the bad weather.

I love the looks and style of the car.

I drove to Scotland and back a couple of weeks back and did about 600 miles in 2 days and I loved the trip and the handling of the car generally. The performance didn't disappoint at all.

I don't drive my cars to the extreme though and so the C4S suits me just fine.

I did choose a manual gearbox rather than tipronic and suspect that the tipronic is better for town driving.

Anyway, I'm delighted with mine....

mansoor999

Original Poster:

50 posts

229 months

Tuesday 30th October 2007
quotequote all
I'm looking at exactly the same car except it will be a 52 2003.

I've come up with the same reasons and thats the styling and look and also the fact that i wont be pushing it too much anyway!!!

Dreammeister

115 posts

235 months

Tuesday 30th October 2007
quotequote all
Exactly the same reasons for me - not everyone wants to track their car or push it to the extreme...

Wanta996(Gotta)

5,622 posts

238 months

Tuesday 30th October 2007
quotequote all
Its a perfect car for day to day driving in all weathers and does look brilliant. If you are not planning to push it or take it on track than its perfect, comments about it being slower are true but its maybe tenths of a second slower than a C2. Front luggage is almost halfed but you can still fit a Quinny Zapp push chair in there so its ok.

P.S. Do not pay £40k for a 2002 model unless its fully specced or has a very low mileage. £40k should get you into a 2004 model fully specced with all extras, Sat Nav,Parking Sensors,Sports Exhaust etc.

Adam B

29,763 posts

285 months

Tuesday 30th October 2007
quotequote all
C4S is great looking but you pay a premium thats not worth it v C2 or too close to the much better TT IMHO

if you can find another like this it would be a much better bet

levron73 said:
Mate of mine has just negotiated a 997 C2 MY54, good spec with 24k miles and still under warranty for £41k!!!!!! Bargin IMO

mansoor999

Original Poster:

50 posts

229 months

Tuesday 30th October 2007
quotequote all
I'm looking to pay about £34k for a 2003 '52'. Its got fairly high mileage but includes the warrantee and has just had the clutch replaced. Very nice condition and full psh

nemeton

214 posts

234 months

Tuesday 30th October 2007
quotequote all
ive just gone from a c4s to a gt3.

everyone keeps barking on about the extra weight of the 4 but they omit to mention that the 2wd versions lift off the ground when you put your foot down. the additional weight in the c4 prevents this. also, the fun never stops in the rain & on drenched roads in a 4.

if i sold my gt3, i would go back to the c4s over the c2s any day, especially in the winter.

don't believe all the hype, most of the 2wd people on here have got there head up there arse when it comes to driving a 4wd 911.

test drive both in the wet & dry & see for your self.

sidicks

25,218 posts

252 months

Tuesday 30th October 2007
quotequote all
nemeton said:
ive just gone from a c4s to a gt3.

everyone keeps barking on about the extra weight of the 4 but they omit to mention that the 2wd versions lift off the ground when you put your foot down. the additional weight in the c4 prevents this. also, the fun never stops in the rain & on drenched roads in a 4.

if i sold my gt3, i would go back to the c4s over the c2s any day, especially in the winter.

don't believe all the hype, most of the 2wd people on here have got there head up there arse when it comes to driving a 4wd 911.

test drive both in the wet & dry & see for your self.
I couldn't agree more !!

Just because the car has 4WD, it doesn't mean you can't 'press on' in the car and it's still very much fun to drive. What it does mean is that in poor weather, you don't have to wind on half- a-turn of opposite lock every time you put your foot down exiting a corner.......

In normal conditions, and most driving scenarios, I doubt there would be mroe than a fag paper between a C2S and a C4S. Even on track, it would be more about the driver than the car.

The front boot is probably 20% smaller than the 2-wheel drive version, but in my opinion that's a small price to pay! The C4S (996) also looks awesome too !

Test drive both and see for yourself!

Sidicks
911 C4S (997)



headlesshorseman

619 posts

237 months

Tuesday 30th October 2007
quotequote all
ive read some rubbish in my time but this thread is full of crap,drive as many 2 and 4 wheel drives pick the one you like the best dont listen to the drivel posted

flow99

1,339 posts

239 months

Tuesday 30th October 2007
quotequote all
mansoor999 said:
I'm looking to pay about £34k for a 2003 '52'. Its got fairly high mileage but includes the warrantee and has just had the clutch replaced. Very nice condition and full psh
your original post suggested £40K budget, which brings in the 996TT or 997, but at £34K, you simply need to try some, and see what you prefer.

Grant3

3,710 posts

286 months

Tuesday 30th October 2007
quotequote all
Whilst I can understand & partially agree with some of the comments about C2 vs C4 it isn't that straight forward, with the C4s (as appose to the standard C4)you get........

The 030 10mm lowered sports chassis as standard (which IMO opinion makes it better than a C2 without, although not as good as one with wink!!)

A wider track & tyres.

The uprated Turbo braking system 330mm all round.

PSM is standard fit to go with the 4WD for better all weather performance.

Those fabulous wide-body Turbo looks & lots of other free goodies that are extra on the C2!

Although 125Kg heavier than the standard C2, it was faster around Nb ring than the C2 of the same time due to better brakes & greater grip/traction..& thats in the dry! It is also great to drive, not just to look at!

So test drive C4S a "floaty" C2 on standard suspension & a 997S & decide how dented you want your bank balance to be!

mansoor999

Original Poster:

50 posts

229 months

Tuesday 30th October 2007
quotequote all
flow99 said:
mansoor999 said:
I'm looking to pay about £34k for a 2003 '52'. Its got fairly high mileage but includes the warrantee and has just had the clutch replaced. Very nice condition and full psh


your original post suggested £40K budget, which brings in the 996TT or 997, but at £34K, you simply need to try some, and see what you prefer.


Yep, i figured i'll lower the budget. Need to be sensible but cant wait