944 S2 or 2.5 Boxster?
944 S2 or 2.5 Boxster?
Author
Discussion

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Wednesday 31st October 2007
quotequote all
I'm looking for a 944S2 at the moment.
I reckon about 5.5 - 6k should get a reasonably good one, but finding a good one is difficult, so you have to wonder is it worth spending some more money and going for an early 2.5 Boxster, which there seems to be plenty of around?
What do you think? Anyone had both who can comment?

willdew

2,138 posts

295 months

Wednesday 31st October 2007
quotequote all
Are you specifically discounting the 968 from your options list? Would seem an obvious car to consider if you want a "newer", better cared for 944 S2, and could find a bit more money...

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Wednesday 31st October 2007
quotequote all
I have considered a 968, lovely cars, I wouldn't be up for the standard model though, it would have to be the Sport (another subject completely), and whether those would come up for £10k max is debatable. They are fairly thin on the ground too though.

Its just that Boxsters are plentyful (I think) at the moment, so possibly worth considering.

Penguinracer

1,776 posts

237 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
These things are very subjective. A 968, 944 S2 or 944 turbo is now seen as an old school alternative to a cheap 911 whereas the Boxster while a fine car is more prosaic.
Personally I'm fond of the rarer more unusual cars & as they age the 944 & 968 cars are starting to fall into this category. The 944 & 968 are still rated by the experts as among the finest handling cars about & with refreshed suspension & brakes there's no reason by they can't keep most cars honest for handling. What you get with the 944 turbo is tuneability & the potential for big horsepower if you want to go down that route. It you don't want to modify the car I'd plumb for a 968 over a Boxster - rarer, more character & definitely a thoroughbred old school Porsche with superb build quality.

Nurburgsingh

5,563 posts

269 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
sjwright944 said:
I have considered a 968, lovely cars, I wouldn't be up for the standard model though, it would have to be the Sport (another subject completely), and whether those would come up for £10k max is debatable. They are fairly thin on the ground too though.

Its just that Boxsters are plentyful (I think) at the moment, so possibly worth considering.
There isnt a big difference in the coupe and the sport... the engine is the same, the shocks are probably knackered aon whichever one you buy due to the age of the car...
The 944/68's are a lt more practicle than a boxster and you dont look like a hairdresser when you drive them! :lol:

nick_968

560 posts

269 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
The difference between a sport and a coupe is negligable, wheels, steering wheel, lowered spings (same suspension), and very similar in weight. So many coupes have the good bits off a sport and better soundproofing and leather interiors that they often make a better buy.

nickb55

276 posts

240 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
hmm... buy a boxster for a fashion statement, a cayman for those who can't afford a 911 ....and a 968 if you're a driving God whistle

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Monday 5th November 2007
quotequote all
I'm more into GT cars than roadsters, but without wanting to bring up the old 'is a 968 worth twice a 944 S2 debate', its not so much the difference in performance between the 968 coupe and the sport, but coupes still seem to be alot more expensive than 944 S2s.


willdew

2,138 posts

295 months

Monday 5th November 2007
quotequote all
sjwright944 said:
I'm more into GT cars than roadsters, but without wanting to bring up the old 'is a 968 worth twice a 944 S2 debate', its not so much the difference in performance between the 968 coupe and the sport, but coupes still seem to be alot more expensive than 944 S2s.
And I think that's fair enough. A 968 isn't twice as good as a 944 S2. However, neither is a Boxster. With early Boxsters and 968s at about the same price, it's down to what you're going to use it for, and what you prefer.

The 968 is only ever going to appeal to a very narrow demographic of enthusiast. It's a lot less flash than a Boxster, which to some might make it feel less special. However, as one of the best handling cars of all time, it's rarity, it's cult following, and the knowing nods you get from other genuine class defining sports cars (NSX, Intergerale, GT3 wink )makes it a very special car indeed.

Harry Flashman

21,987 posts

273 months

Monday 5th November 2007
quotequote all
Boxter is a great car - don't be fooled by the "hairdresser" comments. I reckon it is a better car than the 968 in every way but two - build quality and rarity. To be honest with you, a good Boxter handles just as well as a 968 (CS model excepted).

That said, I wanted rarity and a car that really stands out; and my 968 cab fits the bill perfectly - it really is the best looking convertible Porsche have ever built. That said, if I needed to drive it every day, I would have bought a Boxter for the mod cons.

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Thursday 8th November 2007
quotequote all
I think you've convinced me to rethink the 968.
I'm off to look for some.