Boxter engine
Author
Discussion

bazzza1

Original Poster:

13 posts

234 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
Can anyone tell me when the cylinder liner problem that occurred on some early boxters was put right and how?. How can I tell which Boxters had this problem and which didn't?

Ordinary Bloke

4,559 posts

229 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
If there's oil and water coming out of the bottom, it isn't fixed!

bazzza1

Original Poster:

13 posts

234 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
If the only reply you can give is an idiotic one, don't bother.

Ordinary Bloke

4,559 posts

229 months

Thursday 1st November 2007
quotequote all
OK, just kidding.

There are thousands of opinions on the internet, regarding the reliability of the watercooled Porsche engines. The cracking cylinders and RMS seals may have been 'overblown' wink to some extent but many many people on PH and other forums have had failures.

Looking at Autofarm's website http://www.autofarm.co.uk/engines/water_cooled you can see what kind of thing can happen. As the engines are still being built in approximately the same way, and still suffering failures, I think it's fairly obvious that a watercooled Porsche is a bit of a risk.

For it's BHP level, maybe it's no worse than a Ferrari or whatever, but it seems a Japanese car might be a safer bet if you have limited funds.

Personally, I'm now looking at aircooled Porsche's.

The idea that I could buy a £10-15K car and it could go 'pop' and leave me with a £10K bill to fix it is too scary, even at Halloween. So I prefer to look at cars where a replacement engine or rebuild are <£4K.

Anyway, where's your sense of humour?

Koln-RS

4,130 posts

243 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
I think the slipped liner problem affected a small number of early 2.5s.

Couple of points: I think the stories of porsche engine woes are a bit exaggerated, and the figures quoted are for a new factory supplied/OPC fitted engine. They can be rebuilt and upgraded by specialists for less than half that figure. But, if in doubt, extend the warranty.

GreigM

6,740 posts

280 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
Koln-RS said:
I think the slipped liner problem affected a small number of early 2.5s.
It wasn't early 2.5s - either 98 or 99 IIRC (do a search on www.renntech.org for full details).

There's no way to tell if a car has the sleeved liner problem - if it had and went bad it would have had a new engine by now and it wouldn't be a worry. On the other hand if the car has decent mileage then you would hope that would indicate the engine is reliable - I did read a buyers guide for Boxsters recently which suggested that you should avoid low mileage cars as the reliability of that engine is unproven.

Mikeoupe

303 posts

252 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
Is this link of any help?
http://www.hartech.org/buyers.html

Vr6-er

2,248 posts

271 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
You might argue that if its held on so far, its not likely to go??? Or is that b0llocks????

TISPKJ

3,780 posts

238 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
Guys for what it is worth my 2p worth.

Had 3 new boxsters on the trot, 2.7 3.2 and facelifted 3.2, dont use for work and all were no problem although miles never got above 10k ish.

Swapped into a 98 996 with 42k miles which did about 100 miles before needing the rocker cover gaskets replacing as was dripping oil on the manifolds at the same time under warranty they spotted the rear seal (RMS) leaking replaced and kept the car for 2 years without issue.

Swapped into a mk1 GT3 because a) I wanted one and b)I got fed up with watching 996's go into freefall price wise, when trying to px the 996 which was a perfect car one of the most respected and knowledgable independants in the country who had a GT3 for sale said they would not take the car in px as it was a case of when it will come back under warranty not if, worse thing is they tell me that problems are not mileage related, they have seen them go pop at 8000 miles and 108,000 miles.

Swapped into a depreation free 993 for a while ........

Boxster and 996 are both great cars but just be prepared for a potential big bill even at half the cost of an OPC bill.

Regards

Ordinary Bloke

4,559 posts

229 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
Thanks, I'm sure the cylinder failures, slipping cylinders and RMS stuff has been hyped to some extent, but I think everyone agrees that there is (or has been) an issue. Those with OPC warranty or huge bank balances are inconvenienced. As my budget is not going to stretch to a <10 year old car (meaning I can't get the OPC warranty) my choices are a Hartech warrranty, which looks good but is too far away, or an aircooled.

bazzza1

Original Poster:

13 posts

234 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
Ordinary Bloke. Lost my sense of humour when I bought a Boxter. I only get it back again every time i drive it.
Thanks for those comments folks. It seems that the problem will remain until Porsche redesign the engine. I guess their first step would be to admit that they have a responsibility. The Hartech website is very useful for gaining an understanding of the problem. Couldn't see anything on the Renntech site; maybe I was looking in the wrong place.
As for "if it hasn't happened yet it should be ok", I'm not too sure about that; my car is a low mileage (45k) 99 2.5.
I'm starting to think that an extended warranty is the way to go but the cost seems huge. However, if the engine does let go the cost of the warrant fades into insignificance.
Thanks for all your comments.

Edited by bazzza1 on Friday 2nd November 17:07

Mikeoupe

303 posts

252 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
Forgive me if I've missed a post or something but do you have a problem with your car?

bazzza1

Original Poster:

13 posts

234 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
No problem with the car..yet......
Just worried about it.

Mikeoupe

303 posts

252 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
If it's running smoothly, you're servicing it regularly, not hammering it when it's cold and you're enjoying it .... stop worrying!

bazzza1

Original Poster:

13 posts

234 months

Friday 2nd November 2007
quotequote all
Thanks Mike, you are right of course, but it's hard not to be concerned about the possibility of a £7000-£8000 bill. I think insurance is probably the answer for peace of mind.