Mixing tyre brands?
Mixing tyre brands?
Author
Discussion

AxelS

Original Poster:

173 posts

256 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
Need a new set of rears - but Conti apparently does not provide their regular winter tyre with the required N1 rating this season. Which is the lesser of two evils:
- mix of brands, using Conti up front and somethin else (i.e. Michelin) with proper N1 rating for rears
- sticking with Contis but foregoing the N1 rating?

Cheers

Axel

Diesel130

1,549 posts

243 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
Go for the N1 rears in different brand. If you prang it with non N-rated tyres your insurers (in theory) could dispute a claim due to using incorrectly rated tyres. Better still, buy a set on Michelins for winter and revert back to summer contis next season.

cableguy

2,287 posts

240 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
Don't mix Tyre Brands is my advice.

Different manufacturers compounds, tread patterns and grip levels can have a massive impact on how the car handles, especially in the wet.

C.


noumenon

1,282 posts

235 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all

I don't believe you wouldn't be insured if you didn't have N rated tyres. These are porsche approved and imho nothing to do with capability. It is the speed, load rating and so on that really matter. I'm not suggesting you put cheap tyres on your car, but any decent tyre would be fine. Obviously, all the handling characteristics are dependent on good rubber, so don't skimp.

Think of it this way, there are slight differences in petrol. If Porsche recommended Optimax, would you only ever use that? Would you use anything other than Porsche screen wash? What about bulbs?

melv

4,708 posts

296 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
In a word -don't!

Can lead to some unusual handling.....eek

nick_968

560 posts

269 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
The insurance thing is an old wives tale but better not to mix and match brands if you can help it. Its not the end of the word but some combos can have adverse results.

noumenon

1,282 posts

235 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all

I'm not advocating mix and match. However, on previous cars I've always had different front and rear sets. The only time I ever had a problem was at Silverstone GP after a lot of rain. Almost new Eagle F1's on the front, just legal Profiler G's on the rear. In those wet conditions the rear was, shall we say, easily unhinged. Very entertaining, but not something I'd do on the road.

So to keep a well balanced car in the wet, keep the tread levels similar too.

AxelS

Original Poster:

173 posts

256 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
Thanks for the collective feedback - will seek out some Contis then.

Diesel130 said:
Better still, buy a set on Michelins for winter and revert back to summer contis next season.
Unfortunately it's not that easy since the rears wear out earlier so I'd be wasting a couple of milimeters of usable tread on the front tyres if swapping the entire set.

chris_w

2,571 posts

290 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
noumenon said:
I'm not advocating mix and match. However, on previous cars I've always had different front and rear sets. The only time I ever had a problem was at Silverstone GP after a lot of rain. Almost new Eagle F1's on the front, just legal Profiler G's on the rear. In those wet conditions the rear was, shall we say, easily unhinged. Very entertaining, but not something I'd do on the road.

So to keep a well balanced car in the wet, keep the tread levels similar too.
I'd agree, obviously the same tyre all round is the ideal but (imho) you shouldn't be pushing that hard on the road where the marginal differences between the tyres become apparent. I'm quite happily running different front and rears though I don't use my car for track work.

Tread depth is another matter of course and I had a good lesson in that from my Elise...

lightweight

1,165 posts

279 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
If you run any special geomitry be very careful, i have just changed from Pilot sport N2 to the newer Pilot sport N3 and the newer tyres outer tread bloc is Squarer and solid as such it rubs my inner wheelarch on full lock. car is in at Parr today having the geo tweeked to fix this.
Always run N rated tyres on 911 they develop these for our odd weight dist so why compromise.

AxelS

Original Poster:

173 posts

256 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
lightweight said:
Always run N rated tyres on 911 they develop these for our odd weight dist so why compromise.
Alas, I'm but in hairdresser territory so don't suffer from that specific peculiarity.

lightweight

1,165 posts

279 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
AxelS said:
lightweight said:
Always run N rated tyres on 911 they develop these for our odd weight dist so why compromise.
Alas, I'm but in hairdresser territory so don't suffer from that specific peculiarity.
Axel dont diss the boxter its like an ex girlfrend i once had fairly sporty but you dont love it for that you love it because it was made to get its top off and have fun in

noumenon

1,282 posts

235 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all

Interesting analogy.

So if the boxtster is the fit oversexed blonde hairdresser everyone wants to jump on, does that make the 911 the insatiable older mistress that you've learned to live with despite the fact she occasionally will spin found and smack you with a rolling pin? So while the hairdresser needs good shoes to look nice, the mistress needs those stilettos or else she's going to hurt you (and who knows, she might anyway).

lightweight

1,165 posts

279 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
noumenon said:
Interesting analogy.

So if the boxtster is the fit oversexed blonde hairdresser everyone wants to jump on, does that make the 911 the insatiable older mistress that you've learned to live with despite the fact she occasionally will spin found and smack you with a rolling pin? So while the hairdresser needs good shoes to look nice, the mistress needs those stilettos or else she's going to hurt you (and who knows, she might anyway).
At the moment the GT3 feels like the mistres that wants to pull my wallet out of my trousers and releve me of cash for "essental mantinence" and she is high mantinance but then she looks good and goes like a banshee