Speeding
Author
Discussion

runner911

Original Poster:

631 posts

274 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
Good Morning Folks ! Any comments on this in todays Gruniad ?
TC


Sarah Knapton
Friday November 9, 2007
The Guardian


Two speeding offences could be sufficient to get a driver banned from the roads, under a government proposal to double penalty points.
The Department of Transport is considering graduating the fixed points system so motorists who go vastly above the speed limit face tougher punishments. Those caught at 45mph or above in a 30mph limit are likely to receive six fixed penalty points and a £100 fine instead of the present three points and a £60 fine.


Article continues

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

A spokesman for the department said last night: "Before the end of the year we will be consulting on proposals in the Road Safety Act to graduate the fixed penalty points for speeding offences.
"The purpose is to recognise the differences in degrees of excessive speeding by motorists and for the punishment to take better account of the level of offending."

Under the proposal, the higher penalty would apply to drivers caught at 57mph or above on a 40mph road and 94mph or above on a 70mph road.

The Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents said that drivers "grossly above the speed limit" should get a tougher penalty. "It is not getting at the ordinary motorist. It is getting at those who flagrantly break the speed limit," said a spokesman.

The department is also to drop an earlier proposal for a lower fixed penalty of two points and a £40 fine, for driving only a few miles an hour over the limit.

thegoose

8,077 posts

241 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
I can understand the principal but a bit concerned about the bit below. The subject hit the press months ago, saying there would be a scale from 2 points upwards, thereby sounding fairer and probably getting a reasonable reaction from the motoring public. However, it now turns out they only want to move the range of penalties in one direction. This was probably the original plan and it's very sneaky how they earlier suggested it was going to broaden the range in both directions to garner a better public reaction.

runner911 said:
The department is also to drop an earlier proposal for a lower fixed penalty of two points and a £40 fine, for driving only a few miles an hour over the limit.

shoestring7

6,196 posts

277 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
thegoose said:
I can understand the principal but a bit concerned about the bit below. The subject hit the press months ago, saying there would be a scale from 2 points upwards, thereby sounding fairer and probably getting a reasonable reaction from the motoring public. However, it now turns out they only want to move the range of penalties in one direction. This was probably the original plan and it's very sneaky how they earlier suggested it was going to broaden the range in both directions to garner a better public reaction.

runner911 said:
The department is also to drop an earlier proposal for a lower fixed penalty of two points and a £40 fine, for driving only a few miles an hour over the limit.
Wow, you mean to tell me we've elected a cynical bunch of self-serving, lying, trough feeders completely out of touch with the real world!!!!?

Well I never.

SS7

sidicks

25,218 posts

252 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
runner911 said:
Good Morning Folks ! Any comments on this in todays Gruniad ?
TC


Sarah Knapton
Friday November 9, 2007
The Guardian


Two speeding offences could be sufficient to get a driver banned from the roads, under a government proposal to double penalty points.
The Department of Transport is considering graduating the fixed points system so motorists who go vastly above the speed limit face tougher punishments. Those caught at 45mph or above in a 30mph limit are likely to receive six fixed penalty points and a £100 fine instead of the present three points and a £60 fine.


Article continues







A spokesman for the department said last night: "Before the end of the year we will be consulting on proposals in the Road Safety Act to graduate the fixed penalty points for speeding offences.
"The purpose is to recognise the differences in degrees of excessive speeding by motorists and for the punishment to take better account of the level of offending."

Under the proposal, the higher penalty would apply to drivers caught at 57mph or above on a 40mph road and 94mph or above on a 70mph road.

The Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents said that drivers "grossly above the speed limit" should get a tougher penalty. "It is not getting at the ordinary motorist. It is getting at those who flagrantly break the speed limit," said a spokesman.
Seems perfectly reasonable

runner911 said:
The department is also to drop an earlier proposal for a lower fixed penalty of two points and a £40 fine, for driving only a few miles an hour over the limit.
Seem perfectly unreasonable

Sidicks

Edited by sidicks on Friday 9th November 09:26

DSM2

3,624 posts

231 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
I would have no objection to the changes as far as losing your licence for two excessive speeding convictions, as detailed, goes.

The biggest issue here is what will eventually be imposed on us? Politicians and authorities as individuals or as a whole are rarely, if ever, trustworthy and if they are announcing this for 'public consultation' then the only thing to be counted on is that soemthing vastly different will result at the end of the day.



Edited by DSM2 on Friday 9th November 10:34

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
I agree with the increased penalties for speeding in 30 mph zones. Not sure about the rest though

Chemical Ali

951 posts

248 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
The problem with motoring, or the roads to be specific, is not speeding but poor driving. Speeding exacerbates the concequences, but is rarely the cause.

When I first started driving there were many more cops on the road and I was always wary, not just of my speed, but that my lights all worked and that I wasn't overtaking or undertaking dangerously. Nowadays, I see loads of middle lane hogging on the motorways, undertaking by frustrated drivers and reckless manouvers, me included in some of those.

The roads are not policed anymore, they are taxed.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
Chemical Ali said:
The problem with motoring, or the roads to be specific, is not speeding but poor driving. Speeding exacerbates the concequences, but is rarely the cause.
Except in built up areas where accidents often involve pedestrians etc. That's the only place I really object to speeding and agree with the current limit (30 mph).

Silver993tt

9,064 posts

270 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
With regards to children getting hurt, how often do you see them waiting at a crossing for the green light to cross? I hardly ever see it. On the continent, especially in Germany, Austria etc nearly everybody including kids to adults will wait at the right place and cross at the right time. You also rarely see cars speeding through built up areas in those countries. There really isn't enough emphasis on pedestrian responsibility in the UK.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
Silver993tt said:
With regards to children getting hurt, how often do you see them waiting at a crossing for the green light to cross? I hardly ever see it. On the continent, especially in Germany, Austria etc nearly everybody including kids to adults will wait at the right place and cross at the right time. You also rarely see cars speeding through built up areas in those countries. There really isn't enough emphasis on pedestrian responsibility in the UK.
You are fecking joking right? which continent are you talking about exactly?

Silver993tt

9,064 posts

270 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
uktrailmonster said:
Silver993tt said:
With regards to children getting hurt, how often do you see them waiting at a crossing for the green light to cross? I hardly ever see it. On the continent, especially in Germany, Austria etc nearly everybody including kids to adults will wait at the right place and cross at the right time. You also rarely see cars speeding through built up areas in those countries. There really isn't enough emphasis on pedestrian responsibility in the UK.
You are fecking joking right? which continent are you talking about exactly?
I lived in Austria for 5 years and have now been in Germany for 5 years and my comments definetly apply to those which have a combined population significantly larger than the UK.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
Silver993tt said:
I lived in Austria for 5 years and have now been in Germany for 5 years and my comments definetly apply to those which have a combined population significantly larger than the UK.
Ok, I'd agree with those countries. But it certainly does not apply to France, Italy, Spain or Eastern Europe.

Crimp a Length!

5,697 posts

254 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all


The roads are not policed anymore, they are taxed.
[/quote]

Bang on!
we are basically mobile cash machines/holes in the wall.

[AJ]

3,079 posts

229 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
It's all a load of blx.

Sorry, I don't want to waste my time with a more intellectual response!

DucatiGary

7,765 posts

256 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
that copper that got caught doing 90 in a 60 in wales last month is up in front of the beak on november the 21st November.

with 2 previous convictions for speeding, i think it would be only fair if he was the first to be given this new initiative and banned from driving for a few years, make an example out of him!

in reality we all know it is one rule for them who supposedly fight for these laws to be in place and another for us.

so, he will get off scot free, nothing will happen, where if it was you or I, our staff will be without jobs if we cant drive to build new business.

do they care?

nope, they just want a quick notch up the corporate ladder that is the oppertunistic police force in todays united kingdom.

SidewaysSid

523 posts

289 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
If it was a more considered approach I think we would have less of an argument.

Most motorway regulars cruise the fast lane at between 80 - 90mph, when they are devoid of lane hoggers, and the traffic flows fairly well. I would like to see variable speed limits so that appropriate speed could be achieved. At rush hour a 60 or 70 mph limit on motorways but through the night and quieter times maybe 100mph. Electronic signs exist that already do this on sections of the M25 so why not spend out on these rather than more so called safety cameras.

There are times when 30mph or even 20mph is too fast, such as at kicking out time at the local junior/primary school. But at 3:00 o'clock in the morning that same road may well be safe for cars travelling at 40 - 50mph

Through towns and villages again the limits should correspond to appropriate speed and if these areas were vigourously enforced I wouldn't feel so bad about it and would think most of us would adhere to this type of policy.

It might also be a good idea to ramp up the education of children/pedestrians to explain that even if hit at 20mph by a car/lorry/van it might not kill them but they are always better off not trying out the theory!

Driving standards in this country do seem to be very poor but what incentive is there to improve other than for personal pride in ones ability to drive. Insurance discounts, that's a joke, I've never heard of this actually happening in the real world.

bcnrml

2,107 posts

241 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
uktrailmonster said:
Silver993tt said:
I lived in Austria for 5 years and have now been in Germany for 5 years and my comments definetly apply to those which have a combined population significantly larger than the UK.
Ok, I'd agree with those countries. But it certainly does not apply to France, Italy, Spain or Eastern Europe.
I live in Spain (Barcelona actually). My experience is that kids and other pedestrians are better as pedestrians than they are in Blighty where cars and roads are concerned.

Never have I seen a kid chase a ball (or anything else) into the street. Never have I seen a kid run into the street with its parent (or nanny) chasing it). I've seen loads in the UK (almost weekly).

In Barcelona, I've seen loads of speeding cars and mopeds/motorbikes (including lots of pork, one a GT3 I was driven in last week, but that's another story), but the standard of wariness and sense of personal responsibility demonstrated by pedestrians is comparatively impressive. It isn't as good as in Germany (where I've also visited a bit), but 'tis better than my experience of Blighty!

Before anyone states that road fatality stats here are worse than in the UK, those stats confirm that by far the highest risks are for roads outside urban areas, and not motorways (i.e. Blighty's equivalent of A and B roads).

And BTW, I'm not condoning speeding........

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
bcnrml said:
In Barcelona, I've seen loads of speeding cars and mopeds/motorbikes (including lots of pork, one a GT3 I was driven in last week, but that's another story), but the standard of wariness and sense of personal responsibility demonstrated by pedestrians is comparatively impressive. It isn't as good as in Germany (where I've also visited a bit), but 'tis better than my experience of Blighty!
I think pedestrian awareness in those places may be Darwinian evolution in action!

Police State

4,383 posts

251 months

Friday 9th November 2007
quotequote all
uktrailmonster said:
bcnrml said:
In Barcelona, I've seen loads of speeding cars and mopeds/motorbikes (including lots of pork, one a GT3 I was driven in last week, but that's another story), but the standard of wariness and sense of personal responsibility demonstrated by pedestrians is comparatively impressive. It isn't as good as in Germany (where I've also visited a bit), but 'tis better than my experience of Blighty!
I think pedestrian awareness in those places may be Darwinian evolution in action!
I'd suggest it's a lack of combined ignorance and arrogance, something the British in growing numbers excel at instilling in their children, such that they grow up to become the moronic adults that walk out in front of your car and stare at you in belligerent defiance. Should you toot your horn or gesture at the idiot(s), you get the usual response; no need for me to supply further details; you know the rest...


anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 10th November 2007
quotequote all
Well even if kids in Europe are all model citizens, it doesn't change the fact that speeding in residential areas should warrant very hefty penalties.