maintenance/parts costs on boxster engine?
maintenance/parts costs on boxster engine?
Author
Discussion

Davi

Original Poster:

17,153 posts

251 months

Wednesday 14th November 2007
quotequote all
just doing some research, and I keep reading about a couple of specific problems with the Boxster engines including RMS seals and intermediate shaft, resulting in 6k upwards repair bills.

I'm assuming that these bills are largely made up of labour costs - would I be correct on that assumption? Are engine parts generally very expensive or fairly in line with any other performance engine? Any specific "oh crap" type parts that I should be investigating further? (relating specifically to the engine - it wouldn't be in a Boxster)



Edited by Davi on Wednesday 14th November 21:10

hartech

1,929 posts

248 months

Thursday 15th November 2007
quotequote all
There are similar parts prices for parts inside the engines compared with tradditional air cooled 911's and 924/944/968's - but some additional problems that can add to overall costs.

The above engines developed from smaller ones over several decades (911 from 2 litre, 2.2, 2.4, 2.7, 3, 3.2, 3.6 and the 944/968 from 2 litre, 2.5, 2.7, and 3 litre with 8 and 16 valves and turbo's etc - gradually improving the output while maintaining the reliability. This enabled minor weak spots to be improved in the next generation while capacity and output were also increased

When Porsche introduced the new water cooled engines engines they were a whole new design but had to carry on (or improve on) the performance levels of the cars they replaced - minimise weight AND had to lower production costs to prevent Porsche going bust.

As a result there are probably a few areas that are not quite as good as the older engines technically that they needed to improve - but there are also some considerable improvements.

For example - the Lokasil cylinder lining is potentially excellent and cost effective but they possibly simply made the wall thickness a little thin on the 3.4 and 3.6. The crank carrier with hard cast in supports for shells (as used in Japanese engines successfully) are great potentially but the overhang at the clutch end lets down the idea, etc.etc.

When they re-designed some of these weak spots they altered the compatibility of some new designs so that in the event of a failure - you sometimes have to replace more parts than just those that failed - and oversized shells and pistons etc are not made available.

Finally they are a little more difficult to assemble - putting pressure on the viability of rebuilds.

However - all engine/gearbox problems can be resolved and costs reflect the fault and how far the customer wants the rebuild to go - just to repair the fault - or at the same time to also replace (or recondition) other "old but OK parts" at the same time to end up with a better engine - and if they want good used parts or new parts to replace say a cracked cylinder head (for example).

There are also some modifications that can lessen the incidence of future failure (like strengthening the cylinders liners to prevent future cracking) that are not essential but beneficial if the customer can afford to include that improvement.

Finally - if the car was on our Lifetime Maintenance Plan - in most cases the customer would only pay for the parts.

We have received engines that others had condemned that had very minor faults and could have been repaired relatively cheaply (from around £1K) - typical full rebuilds just to correct the fault usually cost around £3-£4K and a full recondition with weak spots eliminated - more like £6K (all + Vat). This is relatively similar to the previous engines.

The vast majority of these new engines are running well after well over 100K (there are not many failures) but eventually I suppose - like most older Porsches - they will need a rebuild at similar costs.

You could of course just fit a used engine - but just one word of warning - some used engines we have seen come already damaged inside - even when the owner promised they were OK - and engines left lying around can develop cylinder wall corrosion internally that cannpt be fixed - so there is a risk using that solution - although if the source is reliable - it is another viable option.

So overall - not a bad situation - similar to previous Porsche experiences - perhaps a little more risky - but then they are brilliant cars.

Baz


Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Thursday 15th November 2007
quotequote all
If you are considering running a Boxster you should consider either hartech's plan or an official Porsche warranty.

Whilst not inexpensive at least you can budget.

thegoose

8,077 posts

241 months

Thursday 15th November 2007
quotequote all
Don said:
If you are considering running a Boxster you should consider either hartech's plan or an official Porsche warranty.

Whilst not inexpensive at least you can budget.
He did say the engine wouldn't be in a Boxster, so I'm guessing the plan or warranty won't apply.

Davi

Original Poster:

17,153 posts

251 months

Thursday 15th November 2007
quotequote all
Many thanks Hartech, some very useful info in there.

Don, as per thegoose above, the engine wouldn't actually be in a Boxster and would most likely end up being modified, so warranties etc aren't really a consideration for me. All future work would be carried out by myself so the main concern was the balance of labour v's parts costs and if there are any serious nasties to watch out for.

thegoose

8,077 posts

241 months

Thursday 15th November 2007
quotequote all
I am intrigued to know what you're thinking of building with this motor in it though.

Well?......

Davi

Original Poster:

17,153 posts

251 months

Thursday 15th November 2007
quotequote all
There is a small (unfinished) render of it in my profile. It's a design project I've been working on for quite some time now (years) - originally was going to have a RS4 V6 in it, then after discussions on here that turned into a 4.2 V8 from the later S series, then chatting to Andygtt about some issues with the hub components he clued me up to the joys of Boxster hubs.

Having been a long term fan of the boxer config I then started thinking - if I'm going with boxster hub and brake assemblies all round, why continue with a large v8 when I could return to the original ethos for the project using a boxster engine and box - almost a ready made solution with low weight and more importantly lower C of G.

If the project then works and I don't create a total pig of a vehicle I can consider spending some serious money on one of the more powerful Porsche engines.

See - all logical (when you are slightly insane silly )

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Thursday 15th November 2007
quotequote all
Davi said:
Many thanks Hartech, some very useful info in there.

Don, as per thegoose above, the engine wouldn't actually be in a Boxster and would most likely end up being modified, so warranties etc aren't really a consideration for me. All future work would be carried out by myself so the main concern was the balance of labour v's parts costs and if there are any serious nasties to watch out for.
That'll teach me to skim read...sounds like an interesting project!