I am a swaggering petrolhead because George Monbiot says so.
I am a swaggering petrolhead because George Monbiot says so.
Author
Discussion

runner911

Original Poster:

633 posts

274 months

Saturday 17th November 2007
quotequote all
From the motoring section of todays (17/11/07) Telegraph.

...Speed kills...

Following our publication last week of part of a chapter from a new book on the dangers of scare stories by Christopher Booker and Richard North, all-purpose ecomentalist George Monbiot this week accused the authors of "intellectual dishonesty" and of "ignoring inconvenient facts".


Here, then, are some more facts, which Mr Monbiot may or may not regard as inconvenient. Based on its first survey of the causes of accidents (in 2005), the Department for Transport (DfT) has revealed that exceeding the speed limit is a factor in only two per cent of injury crashes involving drivers over the age of 25. For younger drivers, aged 17-25, the percentage is six per cent, and for the youngest, aged 17-19, it is eight per cent. Travelling too fast for the conditions, rather than exceeding the legal speed limit, is a factor in five, 11 and 14 per cent of crashes respectively. For full details see section 2.5 of the memorandum at www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/
cmselect/cmtran/355/7032102.htm

This is not the first time the DfT has disproved its own assertion (over many years) that speeding causes a third of all road accidents; in September last year it was forced to publish figures showing that only five per cent of road accidents involve a vehicle exceeding the speed limit.

While fully supporting law enforcement, many concerned citizens have therefore wondered whether the most effective way to reduce accidents is to replace police traffic patrols with speed cameras. However, such questions do not disturb the intellectual certainty of Mr Monbiot. According to his article in Tuesday’s Guardian, critics of official policy, including road safety experts and serving police officers, are nothing more than “swaggering petrolheads”.

wildoliver

9,325 posts

247 months

Sunday 18th November 2007
quotequote all
Me too.

Proud of it too.

UK952

769 posts

290 months

Sunday 18th November 2007
quotequote all
Monbiot just hates cars and drivers - didnt he move to wales recently though and have to buy one?