Porsche Turbo - RSJ Sports Cars
Porsche Turbo - RSJ Sports Cars
Author
Discussion

Julian Gowing

Original Poster:

3 posts

228 months

Monday 19th November 2007
quotequote all
I recently bought a used 2002 996 Turbo from Joel at RSJ. When I bought the car Joel recommended I buy the Porsche warranty, which included a 111 point check by a main Porsche dealer. The cost was £250 for the check and £900 for the warranty, the car was check by Porsche Hatfield and given a clean bill of health. When I collected the car the clutch slipped (engine out new clutch £2,500 +) I called Porsche Hatfield and they confirmed that the check did not show the slipping clutch and it was not covered under warranty (£1,150 well spent I thought!!) Joel agreed to take the Turbo back and fit a new clutch including all new parts and labour Free of Charge, my thanks to Joel for supporting my claim.
I think Porsche Hatfield should have found the slipping clutch, all you had to do was accelerate hard and it slipped, what do you think?

Chipchap

2,639 posts

228 months

Monday 19th November 2007
quotequote all
I think that OPC 111 point checks are not what they could be. They are supposed to unearth any issues present or likely to manifest themselves during the extended warranty period, so as to minimise or negate the risk. Evidently the OPC who carried the check were not overly thorough.

The more important fact here is that Joel fronted up for a new clutch, well done Joel. Friction surfaces are not normally covered by any warranty but the OPC should have picked it up and the result would still have been the same. Joel would have fixed it.

OPC 0 RSJ 1

Allan

Pickled Piper

6,452 posts

266 months

Monday 19th November 2007
quotequote all
I would say it is a good recommendation for RSJ. Agree, Porsche Hatfield should have found it if it was so obvious. However, like most warranties the Porsche warranty doesn't cover wear and tear items.

Arguably, RSJ should have found it before they let you take the car away?

ultimately, "they stood by the car" that they sold so all is well.

pp

RSJ

579 posts

289 months

Monday 19th November 2007
quotequote all
The thing is guys that we bought the car and drove it 400 miles back to London from Edinburgh and it didnt slip once.
Obviously we dont buy cars without checking gearbox/clutch etc.
It sat in the showroom and then went to Porsche for a 111 check and warranty.
It wasnt slipping on the way there either.
Porsche did their check and it passed and the customer took the car.
It started slipping at the point Julian took it as he called me the next day so it was straight away,same day.

The thing with 996 turbo clutches is that they are servo assisted and there is no way of telling when they are about to fail.It just happenned that it had about 10 miles left in it when Julian took it.Bit of a fluke really.We couldn't have known.No-one could.

With the standard car it starts to get harder and harder as it gets older and older and gets to a point its too hard to press down and you know its knackered and needs replacement and you can actually tell how much life a clutch has got left in it just by pressing it even without the car being on.
Well i can anyway after 10 years of selling them.

As i said due to the turbo clutch being servo assisted and light as a feather from start to finish till it fails,you just cant tell what life they have left in them.

Anyway thats the benefit of having an in house service centre.

Julian brought it back in a week later and we replaced it FOC.

Cost of clutch is actually still quite dear though.£900 for the part.
Labour,well depending how good your technician is.
I wont say how quickly Sid can do them,but he was the best at Hatfield before we got him.

£2500 at OPC is bloody dear though.That is the price though at OPC's.
Our retail price is £1450.

Joel

hoges11

1,011 posts

259 months

Monday 19th November 2007
quotequote all
Agreed not a warranty issue but very poor the 111 point check didnt pick it up. Joel did what any good dealer should do (but I'm sure there are many that wouldn't) so well done to him. An example of the advantage of buying through a dealer, Joe public wouldn't have picked up the tab I'm sure (thats why private purchases can be cheaper, so long as the seller is a realist that is).

Diesel130

1,549 posts

243 months

Monday 19th November 2007
quotequote all
Well, if it wasn't slipping when RSJ bought it, nor at the inspection, then it won't be picked up. Simple as that. There's no magic that can tell you when a clutch will fail. These cars have hundreds of moving parts and any one could fail randomly at any point in time. Probably helped on its way by Julian's attempt at 0 to 60, 5 mins after buying it (only kidding) !!!

Seriously though - this is good news for anyone wanting to buy a 996 - what better service could you get than buying from RSJ.

Also good to know that RSJ do servicing too - I always thought of them as a 'shop' and not a 'garage'.

thegoose

8,077 posts

241 months

Monday 19th November 2007
quotequote all
Hmm, I am the only one wondering how much care the OPC monkeys highly trained technicians took of it when test driving the car as part of the 111 point check? Car was fine when it went to them, not when it came back scratchchin Maybe someone did try a few drag starts in it and ruin it?

Sundeep

540 posts

269 months

Monday 19th November 2007
quotequote all
good service by RSJ clap

The Londoner

3,964 posts

269 months

Monday 19th November 2007
quotequote all
Methinks too much faith is put into the 111 point check. I put my car through one c/o my local PCGB region and I couldn't believe how quickly the technicians went through it. Perhaps they are more thorough when a punter is paying for it, but if not, I'd take the results with a pinch of something.

thegoose

8,077 posts

241 months

Monday 19th November 2007
quotequote all
The Londoner said:
Methinks too much faith is put into the 111 point check. I put my car through one c/o my local PCGB region and I couldn't believe how quickly the technicians went through it. Perhaps they are more thorough when a punter is paying for it, but if not, I'd take the results with a pinch of something.
You're probably right. Here are some variable motivations that there could be when the job is done:

1) The technician spends the allocated time checking the car as per the check list, noting things that actually do need attention (if any). smile
2) The technician is thinking of his monthly bonus, which is based on the time he takes to do jobs compared to the book time or time charged to the customer. He therefore ticks the boxes quickly, completes the 2 hour job in under 40 minutes and has another 1 hour 20 minutes towards his bonus target.
3) The service receptionist is mindful of his/her sales target so encourages the technician to create an unecessarily long list of jobs, for which they can then charge.

The time of the month may influence the above factors too.

The check also does not check anything cosmetic (i.e. if the paintwork is any good at all).

meridian

330 posts

314 months

Monday 19th November 2007
quotequote all
Fair play to RSJ. They present themselves as a business run with integrity, and here it is proved. Very easy (and cynical) to say that the fault should have been picked up prior to delivery, but maybe not, for the reasons already discussed. Credit where credit is due, RSJ are to be commended for their approach. Clearly a good outfit.

guyvert1

2,168 posts

273 months

Monday 19th November 2007
quotequote all
Best £1450 spent wink

s1deways

104 posts

246 months

Monday 19th November 2007
quotequote all
Well done Joel.

I have only had good experience dealing with him and will look to him come GT2 time(amongst other places)

I bought a 2003 996tt recently and had a 111 point check carried out at Porsche Guildford and they told me I had about 50% life left in my clutch.

surely it would have been nice for them to give you a heads up!

graeme36s

7,230 posts

248 months

Monday 19th November 2007
quotequote all
Sundeep said:
good service by RSJ clap
Plus one, honourable company

VerySideways

10,272 posts

303 months

Monday 19th November 2007
quotequote all
Sundeep said:
good service by RSJ clap
yes

Clevers

1,171 posts

232 months

Monday 19th November 2007
quotequote all
RSJ said:
The thing is guys that we bought the car and drove it 400 miles back to London from Edinburgh and it didnt slip once.
Obviously we dont buy cars without checking gearbox/clutch etc.
It sat in the showroom and then went to Porsche for a 111 check and warranty.
It wasnt slipping on the way there either.
Porsche did their check and it passed and the customer took the car.
It started slipping at the point Julian took it as he called me the next day so it was straight away,same day.

The thing with 996 turbo clutches is that they are servo assisted and there is no way of telling when they are about to fail.It just happenned that it had about 10 miles left in it when Julian took it.Bit of a fluke really.We couldn't have known.No-one could.

With the standard car it starts to get harder and harder as it gets older and older and gets to a point its too hard to press down and you know its knackered and needs replacement and you can actually tell how much life a clutch has got left in it just by pressing it even without the car being on.
Well i can anyway after 10 years of selling them.

As i said due to the turbo clutch being servo assisted and light as a feather from start to finish till it fails,you just cant tell what life they have left in them.

Anyway thats the benefit of having an in house service centre.

Julian brought it back in a week later and we replaced it FOC.

Cost of clutch is actually still quite dear though.£900 for the part.
Labour,well depending how good your technician is.
I wont say how quickly Sid can do them,but he was the best at Hatfield before we got him.

£2500 at OPC is bloody dear though.That is the price though at OPC's.
Our retail price is £1450.

Joel
Joel, out of interest, what would RSJ charge for a sports exhaust ?

jonlwright

1,825 posts

270 months

Tuesday 20th November 2007
quotequote all
Well, you could argue that it is better to have a 111 point check that is not too thorough if the point is to get the OPC warranty - as persumably anything it turns up needs to be sorted before they will authorise the sale of the warranty.

So, if your main objective is to get the warranty - I would be happy to have them glance over the car in 2 minutes and give me the warranty - then take it elsewhere to have a proper check done!

RSJ

579 posts

289 months

Tuesday 20th November 2007
quotequote all
As i said guys you cant blame the OPC really,or Damien who bought it,as the turbo servo assisted clutch gives no notice whatsoever of giving up until the moment that it does.

Damien says it was'nt even slipping when he drove it back from Hatfield on the way back from inspection.

It just happenned on the way home for Julian.

When we are selling carreras or boxsters we often change a clutch before the car even leaves here when you can tell that its got less than roughly 5000 miles left in it.

We have to change a lot of RMS's for our warranties and often let the customer have a new clutch at that point for £390 which is the cost of the clutch.Most of them take it up.

Thanx for all the kind words.
Much appreciated.

Of to Derby now to collect this
http://www.rsjsportscars.co.uk/vehicles/porsche_91...