356 Speedster replicas
356 Speedster replicas
Author
Discussion

Ken Sington

Original Poster:

3,964 posts

269 months

Friday 6th May 2011
quotequote all
Anyone know anything about these?:

http://www.westcoastspeedsters.com/

or any other manufacturers that are worth checking out?

I'd fancy an original car but those are serious money.

(Ps if anyone mods or otherwise thinks this should go in the kit car section, please feel free to relocate it, but my interest lies in a ready to roll car, not a box of bits so I put it in here!)

marky911

4,434 posts

250 months

Friday 6th May 2011
quotequote all
Morning,
Chesil is the big name in these, amongst others I suppose. My dads built a couple in the past for customers and built properly, they're every bit as beautiful as a proper one.

The Chesils have been featured in some of the Porsche mags before.
No doubt someone will have beaten me to replying, by the time I write this on my phone. smile

Edited for a missing word.

Edited by marky911 on Friday 6th May 09:54

Greenwich Ross

1,219 posts

204 months

Friday 6th May 2011
quotequote all
What's the deal on whether these fine looking replicas can be labelled (badge-wise) as a Porsche? I only ask as I thought items like logos were, generally, copywritten.

R.

thegoose

8,077 posts

241 months

Friday 6th May 2011
quotequote all
I believe these guys make really good ones:
http://www.intermeccanica.com/
However, the video on their front page is VERY sexist and cheesy rolleyes

MogulBoy

3,066 posts

254 months

Friday 6th May 2011
quotequote all
An astonishing piece of marketing there!

Tifosi

254 posts

298 months

Tuesday 10th May 2011
quotequote all
These guys are UK agents for 356 Speedster replicas.

http://www.mcgurk.com/Home

Saw one there when I picked up my car. They look very nice indeed, I think they can be specced to your requirements too.

DS240

5,788 posts

249 months

Tuesday 10th May 2011
quotequote all
Greenwich Ross said:
What's the deal on whether these fine looking replicas can be labelled (badge-wise) as a Porsche? I only ask as I thought items like logos were, generally, copywritten.

R.
I could be wrong, but I thought they could not be badged as Porsche when they come from the manufacture(copyright/rights etc)..... but what's this, a bag of badges in the glovebox. Hope the owner doesn't stick them on when they get the car home!

barchetta_boy

2,515 posts

263 months

Tuesday 10th May 2011
quotequote all
I seriously looked into this very recently, got the urge big time for a 550 Spyder replica, realised these are like hen's teeth and looked instead at Speedsters.

Chesil are made from a modified Beetle chassis. They are the most numerous replica around, and can look sensational. They are much narrower inside than a real 356, the sill is about 6 inches thick, though you wouldn't notice this until it's pointed out.

Intermeccanica have a great reputation but are very rare. Another option is Chamonix / Beck which are made on a custom tubular chassis like the real 356 and so are much roomier inside and more visually accurate (eg no fuel filler flap on front wing which a Chesil has).

I actually made a serious offer on a Beck Speedster recently, it may still be advertised on PH and other places, it's in Lapis Blue with cream leather and up at £24,995. Beautiful car, my wife and I fell in love with it, but my bid wasn't quite enough to secure it and on reflection I decided it was too much money to spend on a new replica - I was scared of depreciation.

While testing the Speedster I also sat in a 1973 911T and that made me realise that patina is something that is really important to me and the Beck car just felt too new. I can't fault it visually though. To drive, well, the Beetle DNA is obvious and you won't be passing much traffic but then that probably isn't why you buy a Speedster (unless it's a real Carrera for £200k!).

In the end I decided to go in a completely different direction and picked up a Caterham 7 last weekend. Fantastic car.

Hope this helps,

Joel

PS: I spoke to Andy Hill at Victoria Sports Cars in Littleborough who has the Lapis Beck Speedster. If you're serious about one I'd recommend a visit to his premises.

scrowls

8 posts

184 months

Wednesday 6th July 2011
quotequote all
Hi Joel, I have seen this lapis blue speedster and was thinking about a cheecky offer. how did the car drive? its says 115hp so it should go ok i guess, i have driven a original a few times and it was great, i just hope the chamonix doesn't feel like a focus if you know what i mean.

oh yea, well done on the caterham!
Simon

DougieMc

1,794 posts

252 months

Wednesday 6th July 2011
quotequote all
I just picked up my new Chesil 356 Speedster last week will pop some photos up when I get a minute.
It drives like a old car, looks like a old car, but you have the feeling that at least the engine side of things will be reliable.

Yes the purest can tell the difference but without the pricetag Im happy with what I have

Love it.

Dougie

barchetta_boy

2,515 posts

263 months

Wednesday 6th July 2011
quotequote all
scrowls said:
Hi Joel, I have seen this lapis blue speedster and was thinking about a cheecky offer. how did the car drive? its says 115hp so it should go ok i guess, i have driven a original a few times and it was great, i just hope the chamonix doesn't feel like a focus if you know what i mean.

oh yea, well done on the caterham!
Simon
Cheers Simon. It drove nicely - lovely air cooled rattle from the engine, pulled well, steered ok and stopped ok. With Beetle mechanicals you won't be passing much, but it absolutely doesn't drive like a focus!

Joel

scrowls

8 posts

184 months

Wednesday 6th July 2011
quotequote all
Thats good news then...

But I've just heard that tubular chassis are not aloud in Belgium, Germany and the Netherlands. Has anybody heard of this, If so this screws my plans this weekend! No Chamonix!

BertBert

21,346 posts

242 months

Wednesday 6th July 2011
quotequote all
scrowls said:
Thats good news then...

But I've just heard that tubular chassis are not aloud in Belgium, Germany and the Netherlands. Has anybody heard of this, If so this screws my plans this weekend! No Chamonix!
How do caterhams manage?
Bert

marky911

4,434 posts

250 months

Wednesday 6th July 2011
quotequote all
DougieMc said:
I just picked up my new Chesil 356 Speedster last week will pop some photos up when I get a minute.
It drives like a old car, looks like a old car, but you have the feeling that at least the engine side of things will be reliable.

Yes the purest can tell the difference but without the pricetag Im happy with what I have

Love it.

Dougie
Congratulations Dougie!
I look forward to the pics. thumbup

whippy930

193 posts

192 months

Thursday 7th July 2011
quotequote all
This is merely my opinion, dont shoot me...

Chesil's are beautiful and yes, I agree they are well put together... Maybe, too well... You can take a 3.2 and turn it, visually at least, into a '73 RS replica. I know one or two people, owners of original 73RS's, who are constantly being asked - "Whats that based on?" and it bugs the sh*t out of them... This will never happen with a Chesil IMHO because everyone who knows what its supposed to be will know its not real. They, beauty aside, have no patina and are too prissy... The wheels are too far in under the said wide cills... They just dont look right, they are beautiful, well put together, reliable but just not cool used chic-y looking...

Maybe thats not that point though... Sorry if I'm missing it!

shirt

25,559 posts

232 months

Thursday 7th July 2011
quotequote all
i kind of agree. i really couldn't bring myself to spend 25k on something that is really just a beetle in a fancy frock. the 356 speedster was the first car that i remember thinking 'wow' about [when watching doc hollywood as a kid] and, like seeing a cobra, you just it's gonna be a fake.

however, i quite like the idea of this:


http://www.vintagereplicar.com/VintageReplicar/Hom...

at least it keeps in the spirit of a replica - only the 356-1 had a tubular chassis, all the rest were unibody.

still, at 30 large i think i'd much rather spend that on a useable 356coupe, or a good pre-73 911 or super-mint 912.

Daggerpie

1,434 posts

232 months

Thursday 7th July 2011
quotequote all
Saw this replica at the Malvern VW fest on sunday, colour not to my choice but a great car never the less. Have no idea on the manufacters though, sorry:



barchetta_boy

2,515 posts

263 months

Friday 8th July 2011
quotequote all
shirt]i kind of agree. i really couldn't bring myself to spend 25k on something that is really just a beetle in a fancy frock. the 356 speedster was the first car that i remember thinking 'wow' about [when watching doc hollywood as a kid said:
and, like seeing a cobra, you just it's gonna be a fake.

however, i quite like the idea of this:


http://www.vintagereplicar.com/VintageReplicar/Hom...

at least it keeps in the spirit of a replica - only the 356-1 had a tubular chassis, all the rest were unibody.

still, at 30 large i think i'd much rather spend that on a useable 356coupe, or a good pre-73 911 or super-mint 912.
Yeah, that's pretty much where I got to. At th garage where I viewed the Speedster they also had a 70 911 2.4E. The smell of that car inside was just lovely... the patina is really important to me.



scrowls

8 posts

184 months

Tuesday 12th July 2011
quotequote all
Hi Guys,
Just to let you know Dutch law wont let me bring the chamonix speedster into the Netherlands.They say it will take thousands of euros for checks to be done, so not a happy bunny,

Im on the look out for a original looking one but dont have the 25k for a new one. Im looking at the second hand and there are some lovely ones with only a few thousand miles but something is always wrong. Could any one recomend anywhere for parts i.e. seats. spedo dails, etc.

Cheers.

DougieMc

1,794 posts

252 months

Wednesday 14th September 2011
quotequote all
As promised above heres a little write up on our new toy and our recent trip
I know its not real but its Awesome

http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/gassing/topic.asp?h=0...