Act of God?
Author
Discussion

pdv6

Original Poster:

16,442 posts

281 months

Wednesday 18th September 2002
quotequote all
Just seen on the front page of the local rag (Bristol Evening Post)...

A driver's car was wrecked when he was hit by another car who's driver was suffering an epilectic fit. The insurers are refusing to pay out, claiming that the fit was "an act of God".

WTF?

Who says insurance companies aren't a bunch of thieving ba$tards?

CarZee

13,382 posts

287 months

Wednesday 18th September 2002
quotequote all
That's a bit of a pisstake isn't it...

If the guy knew that he had epilepsy before he got in the car then he's surely culpable?

Don't epileptics have to surrender their licenses pending proper assessment and a medical-sign off on their state of health etc.. ? (One guy I knew did..)

pdv6

Original Poster:

16,442 posts

281 months

Wednesday 18th September 2002
quotequote all
quote:

Don't epileptics have to surrender their licenses pending proper assessment and a medical-sign off on their state of health etc.. ? (One guy I knew did..)


True. My little bro' had to lose his license for a year after receiving a head injury just in case he developed epilepsy.

Dazren

22,612 posts

281 months

Wednesday 18th September 2002
quotequote all
Hi Pete

I haven't read the newspaper, but I can't believe that.

What happens to drivers and their cars which are injured or wrecked due to other motorists dying, having heartattacks, being temporarily blinded by the sun, etc....?

These are all acts of god using the insurers definition.

The only way I can see the insurers getting away with this, is if the insured has a history of epilepsy and has not declared it when taking out the insurance. In this instance the driver suffering the attack would not be insured as he would have failed to disclose relevent details when taking out the policy, thus voiding it. Although in the newspaper instance the insurers would just say the drivers insurance is void, they wouldn't take the "act of god" defence.

cheers

DAZ

pdv6

Original Poster:

16,442 posts

281 months

Wednesday 18th September 2002
quotequote all
Exactly

Dazren

22,612 posts

281 months

Wednesday 18th September 2002
quotequote all
quote:

Don't epileptics have to surrender their licenses pending proper assessment and a medical-sign off on their state of health etc.. ? (One guy I knew did..)



Correct. On a first seizure minimum of twelve months. At the end of the twelve months you have to get a medical consultants opinion stating they are happy for you to drive, together with an application form (from DVLA) and send it all into the medical section at DVLA. You can then only drive when you receive your physical licence back in the post, so in practice you surrender your licence for longer than 12 months.

DAZ

mondeoman

11,430 posts

286 months

Wednesday 18th September 2002
quotequote all
There was a woman in the papers a couple of weeks back, had been hit (at low speed, at traffic lights) by a bloke having a fit. No physical damage to her, only her car. Insurance paid out no problem. Bicht then claims trauma and PTSD for seeing the guy have the fit - and GOT PAID!!! Laughable country we live in nowadays.

Podie

46,646 posts

295 months

Wednesday 18th September 2002
quotequote all
quote:

There was a woman in the papers a couple of weeks back, had been hit (at low speed, at traffic lights) by a bloke having a fit. No physical damage to her, only her car. Insurance paid out no problem. Bicht then claims trauma and PTSD for seeing the guy have the fit - and GOT PAID!!! Laughable country we live in nowadays.



Becoming increasingly like the states... ooh, they did this! SUE 'EM!

FFS!

scruff400

3,757 posts

281 months

Wednesday 18th September 2002
quotequote all
She got £6000.

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

285 months

Wednesday 18th September 2002
quotequote all
Scruff400 - I'm traumatised by your post - can I have my payout in dollars please?

mondeoman

11,430 posts

286 months

Wednesday 18th September 2002
quotequote all
quote:

Scruff400 - I'm traumatised by your post - can I have my payout in dollars please?


Sue me!

M@H

11,298 posts

292 months

Wednesday 18th September 2002
quotequote all
quote:

She got £6000.



SIX GRAND... WTF.. I'm still fcuked up from being in a rear end shunt 4 years ago, and when that came to court 2 1/2 years after the accident (whilst I was still having physio) I got half that

Matt.

lotusfan

593 posts

286 months

Wednesday 18th September 2002
quotequote all
I know of someone who crunched his motor when he sneezed, that was classed as an act of god too.

Fatboy

8,246 posts

292 months

Wednesday 18th September 2002
quotequote all
And insurance comapnies wonder why no-one has any sympathy when they whine about uninsured drivers

filmidget

682 posts

302 months

Wednesday 18th September 2002
quotequote all
But I don't believe in god... so i should always get paid out by insurance companies

Actually I am almost serious - if you believe in god then everything is an act of God surely!?! (hence the 'Will of Allah' style driving in many Arab states?). Plus i thought that's what insurance was for - protecting against things you have no control over?

Bunch of slimey bastards.

Cheers, Phil

incorrigible

13,668 posts

281 months

Wednesday 18th September 2002
quotequote all
So the next time a numpty pulls out in front of me will it be an act of god when I pummel them to death with a 5-iron ?

Maybe we should start our own insurance company ??

jamesmac

102 posts

282 months

Wednesday 18th September 2002
quotequote all
I've just split my sides with laughter reading Chassis & Hungryjim's comments in another post.

Can I sue both of them???

CarZee

13,382 posts

287 months

Wednesday 18th September 2002
quotequote all
quote:
Maybe we should start our own insurance company ??
Absolutely - Underwritten by Lloyds of Grossman

Jason F

1,183 posts

304 months

Thursday 19th September 2002
quotequote all
I don't see how they can justify someones medical condition as an act of god. Sounds like a standard insurance company con trick to me. Sue 'em.

As above, I don't believe in God, so I assume they will pay out for me no matter what. Actually, if my house was ever struck by lightning or a flood or something I would be very tempted to take 'em to court to PROVE that God destroyed my house........

>> Edited by Jason F on Thursday 19th September 06:41