Advise wanted - water pump joint
Advise wanted - water pump joint
Author
Discussion

DaviesDJ

Original Poster:

46 posts

173 months

Saturday 7th April 2018
quotequote all
Dear all

I have pictures but am unsure how to insert here!

I have a problem in that on rebuilding my 4.5 AJP, when fixing the sump to the bottom of the engine there seems to be a 15 thou gap between the O ring sealing the bottom of the water pump to the sump! Looking at the disassembly pictures there no other fixings to this before - even though there are 2 bolt holes present!

Is this a common problem. I am going to solve this by making a 2mm thick neoprene gasket.

Any thoughts or experience welcome.

Many thanks for all your previous help on threads

Best wishes

Dave

Byker28i

82,781 posts

239 months

Saturday 7th April 2018
quotequote all
Don't know, I could go look at mine today if I know exactly where to look



From the front goes water pump, oil pump, PAS pump...

DaviesDJ

Original Poster:

46 posts

173 months

Saturday 7th April 2018
quotequote all
Bottom right corner of your picture - the 90degree bend coming from the sump and attaching to the underside of the water pump- my o-ring gap is quite significant

TwinKam

3,451 posts

117 months

Saturday 7th April 2018
quotequote all
A pic of your set-up would really help... you just need a 3rd party host such as tinypic (lots of others exist).
What has changed since you stripped yours? Is it the same block, same pump body, same sump? If nothing, then there's no reason why it should not be OK. I'm assuming you're doing a dry test assemble of the sump? ...you're not using a too 'fat' sealant on the sump joint are you?
There will be a visible gap between the castings, you may be able to even prod the side of the O-ring with a feeler gauge, but all three O-rings should get compressed enough to form an adequate seal when the sump gets bolted on.
It should be possible to measure the depth of the grooves, the diameter of O-rings' cord and your stated clearance etc in order to calculate if the resultant 'squish' is sufficient.
I fully appreciate that this is something to 'get right' now rather than when the engine is fitted (I'm in the same boat).

DaviesDJ

Original Poster:

46 posts

173 months

Saturday 7th April 2018
quotequote all
The problem seems to be the o ring not compressing enough - now I may be using the wrong ring - but it seems to sit in nicely - I think i will make a new gasket

The Nige

177 posts

211 months

Saturday 7th April 2018
quotequote all
Hi
Not sure if these help but this is a dirty one before we started


this one of the right hand corner of sump before replacing


one connection is ready for an o ring but the other is smooth, not sure if it helps.
Cheers

DaviesDJ

Original Poster:

46 posts

173 months

Saturday 7th April 2018
quotequote all
Exactly like mine! Basically my o ring seems to be too thin - many thanks for that

TwinKam

3,451 posts

117 months

Saturday 7th April 2018
quotequote all
The Nige said:
Hi
Not sure if these help but this is a dirty one before we started


this one of the right hand corner of sump before replacing


one connection is ready for an o ring but the other is smooth, not sure if it helps.
Cheers
...that's because the other O-ring sits in a similar groove in the pump body...
And I would check the size of those O-rings carefully... where did you source them from?
I don't have my Cerb notes here at home else I could tell you the size. Can you wait 'til Monday?

DaviesDJ

Original Poster:

46 posts

173 months

Saturday 7th April 2018
quotequote all
Certainly can - but when I dismanteled it there was a lot of silicone around that area! So I have ordered a bit of 2mm gasket material (neoprene) to make a gasket to go with it

ukkid35

6,378 posts

195 months

Saturday 7th April 2018
quotequote all
DaviesDJ said:
Certainly can - but when I dismanteled it there was a lot of silicone around that area! So I have ordered a bit of 2mm gasket material (neoprene) to make a gasket to go with it
Rick is being very polite

I would suggest that a workaround will do nothing other than mask an underlying problem that really needs to be understood

DaviesDJ

Original Poster:

46 posts

173 months

Saturday 7th April 2018
quotequote all
Very polite? It is clearly just a different o ring size to what I have and what appears to fit the grove. just wondered if anybody has had similar problems. TBH the time of that message is a little condescending

itsallyellow

3,825 posts

242 months

Saturday 7th April 2018
quotequote all
Every engine I have ever built or used has just had lots and lots of sealent, ultimately all you are trying to achieve is a sealed joint.

Mike

TwinKam

3,451 posts

117 months

Sunday 8th April 2018
quotequote all
DaviesDJ said:
Very polite? It is clearly just a different o ring size to what I have and what appears to fit the grove. just wondered if anybody has had similar problems. TBH the time of that message is a little condescending
confused Am I missing something?