Stuff to do while my gearbox is out?
Stuff to do while my gearbox is out?
Author
Discussion

brakedust

Original Poster:

1,059 posts

239 months

Wednesday 29th October 2008
quotequote all
Having my gearbox out as my 2nd gear keeps on 'popping' out when changing down, warranty company are picking up the bill, so while its out...... is it worth changing my clutch or anything else?

Clutch was changed along with all slave components at 33372 and I'm sitting at over 54000 but all seems fine at the moment.

Nefarious

989 posts

295 months

Thursday 30th October 2008
quotequote all
I guess it depends if you've got the AA warranty or not. If so, don't worry about the clutch until it goes (then they can sort it). If you don't have a warranty, then probably best change the friction plate and slave cylinder at least - IMO

jesfirth

1,743 posts

272 months

Thursday 30th October 2008
quotequote all
I would sort out any rust to that part of the chassis in the tunnel while the gearbox is out - it will give you good access and having done it it doesn't take long.

From my own experience that aprt of the chassis is usually pretty good because the oil from the engine gearbox etc protects it but you may find a little rust at the vertical and horizontal welds/joints

kojak

4,547 posts

283 months

Thursday 30th October 2008
quotequote all
Nefarious said:
I guess it depends if you've got the AA warranty or not. If so, don't worry about the clutch until it goes (then they can sort it). If you don't have a warranty, then probably best change the friction plate and slave cylinder at least - IMO
The AA will only cover £500. A clutch fail will cost £1000/£1200. A lot of that is labour of course. Clutches tend to last 20000/25000 miles.

cupra20v.t

1,149 posts

219 months

Thursday 30th October 2008
quotequote all
sorry to go a bit off topic but are there warranties out there that will cover say clutch replacement,gear box issues? or do they all have limits?

what would a warranty cost and does the car have to meet specific criteria, as i know i wanted a waranty on a previous car and it had to be reatively know no older than say 6 years and have no more than 100k on the clock.

my car is a 1997 p reg with 37k on the clock.

Storer

5,024 posts

245 months

Thursday 30th October 2008
quotequote all
I would do the clutch while the car was apart. One less thing to worry about and the car has done 20K miles since it was last replaced.

FarmyardPants

4,379 posts

248 months

Thursday 30th October 2008
quotequote all
cupra20v.t said:
sorry to go a bit off topic but are there warranties out there that will cover say clutch replacement,gear box issues? or do they all have limits?

what would a warranty cost and does the car have to meet specific criteria, as i know i wanted a waranty on a previous car and it had to be reatively know no older than say 6 years and have no more than 100k on the clock.

my car is a 1997 p reg with 37k on the clock.
I looked at warranties when I bought my cerb at the end of '05 to cover engine rebuilds etc. The premiums were rather high to say the least (c£1,200 pa IIRC). Although the AA warranty only pays 475 max per claim, that's 5 times the premium, and let's face it any bill will be at least that. So unless you're confident that you can go 5 years without something going wrong, you should have the AA warranty.

For the higher premiums you might as well put the money in the bank instead, imo. Even if you pay faithfully for a few years, there's always a chance they'll dispute the claim. The only exception is if you have reason to believe something big is coming up wink

esso

1,849 posts

247 months

Thursday 30th October 2008
quotequote all
I would check the clutch plates to see how much friction material is left on them and certainly replace the slave cylinder seals and check the slave cylinder bores for scoring/wear.

DonnyMac

3,634 posts

233 months

Thursday 30th October 2008
quotequote all
kojak said:
The AA will only cover £500. A clutch fail will cost £1000/£1200. A lot of that is labour of course. Clutches tend to last 20000/25000 miles.
Tell me this isn't so... mine feels a little 'notchy'?

esso

1,849 posts

247 months

Thursday 30th October 2008
quotequote all
DonnyMac said:
kojak said:
The AA will only cover £500. A clutch fail will cost £1000/£1200. A lot of that is labour of course. Clutches tend to last 20000/25000 miles.
Tell me this isn't so... mine feels a little 'notchy'?
New clutch~£550(approx)
New slave with seals~£250ish
New master cylinder~£70
+labour+VAT if you dont do it yourself.

ridds

8,372 posts

274 months

Saturday 1st November 2008
quotequote all
esso said:
DonnyMac said:
kojak said:
The AA will only cover £500. A clutch fail will cost £1000/£1200. A lot of that is labour of course. Clutches tend to last 20000/25000 miles.
Tell me this isn't so... mine feels a little 'notchy'?
New clutch~£550(approx)
New slave with seals~£250ish
New master cylinder~£70
+labour+VAT if you dont do it yourself.
Or

Exchange unit from Racing Green £348
Seal kit for Slave £38
4 bolts £5
A weekend on your back

wink

You can do it for a lot less.

kojak

4,547 posts

283 months

Saturday 1st November 2008
quotequote all
DonnyMac said:
kojak said:
The AA will only cover £500. A clutch fail will cost £1000/£1200. A lot of that is labour of course. Clutches tend to last 20000/25000 miles.
Tell me this isn't so... mine feels a little 'notchy'?
As esso has shown. Sorry. I should know, i've had 2 clutches both due to fingers breaking.

As for the 'notchy' bit you refer to, it could be early signs of finger failure, but it could also be just your fluid that needs topping up. Hope thats all it is.

caduceus

6,130 posts

296 months

Sunday 2nd November 2008
quotequote all
ridds said:
You can do it for a lot less.
Do tell Ridds ole chap scratchchin My box is out too, and I'm gonna check the clutch for wear. Also get the box fixed properly this time.

EFA

Edited by caduceus on Sunday 2nd November 09:01