Extreme Hankering - for a 575M
Extreme Hankering - for a 575M
Author
Discussion

bqf

Original Poster:

2,290 posts

202 months

Wednesday 28th September 2011
quotequote all
Folks
Never had a Ferrari before (more of a Porsche/Mercedes person - have a couple 911s and an E55 AMG), but I'm getting an extreme hankering for a 575 Maranello. My race mechanic is fettling one for a customer of his and it makes a great noise, and looks utterly fabulous - the most handsome ferrari of the last decade (imho).

Trouble is - there don't seem to be too many about, and the ones I have seen are all flappy paddle. I really want an open-gate manual (for me, one of the most beautiful engineering touches on any car!).

I've a couple fo questions for you folks in the know:

1. Are there many manual examples out there - or are they mostly F1-style?
2. Any major problems/issues with the 575 that I should know about?
3. What are they like to live with - I'll use mine no more than 2-3,000 miles a year - will I get away with one annual service??

Cheers

johnnyreggae

3,171 posts

191 months

Wednesday 28th September 2011
quotequote all
Friends tell me

1 - 10 % of about 250 cars in UK - all 550 are manual however
2 - no
3 - yes

4 - jfdi

rs48635

557 posts

245 months

Wednesday 28th September 2011
quotequote all
Maybe consider a 550 - and add the bits neede to make it look / sound / feel like the 575.

My fave mechanic Roberto Grimaldi looks after a few 550s, seem to recall seeing one customer car with the engine updates (single big intake plenum instead of triple) at least.
Whack on a Tubi exhaust and Bob's your disgruntled neighbour!

bqf

Original Poster:

2,290 posts

202 months

Wednesday 28th September 2011
quotequote all
Is the 550 the exact same body dimensions and style as the 575?

Mr Gearchange

5,892 posts

237 months

Wednesday 28th September 2011
quotequote all
The 550 was generally thought to be a much better car IIRC.

They made the 575 too soft to please fat americans - then it had to have the handling pack fitted so it handled and cornered properly.

550 is a bona fide classic in the making.

bqf

Original Poster:

2,290 posts

202 months

Wednesday 28th September 2011
quotequote all
How many 550's came to the UK??

I am tempted by them, but they don't look quite the same as a 575 - or am I totally wrong?

Must be manual though, so maybe the 550 is the way forward?

Any owners of either want to make a case?

Justices

3,682 posts

195 months

Wednesday 28th September 2011
quotequote all
rs48635 said:
Whack on a Tubi exhaust and Bob's your disgruntled neighbour!
biggrin

cgt2

7,487 posts

219 months

Wednesday 28th September 2011
quotequote all
Both are similar but 575 has sharper detailing around the lights, much better headlights, much better interior and fit/finish, which is particularly noticable on the move through lack of creaks/rattles.

Slightly more power than 550 and is epic with a manual gearbox and Tubi. Though on the 550 you also have the option of removing the centre pipe (different design on 575) which will give you pretty much the same power (lots).

Mine had a handling pack, but I dont necessarily subscribe to the myth that it's a bad car without, you need to try one and find out for yourself.

F355GTS

3,875 posts

286 months

Wednesday 28th September 2011
quotequote all
bqf said:
How many 550's came to the UK??

I am tempted by them, but they don't look quite the same as a 575 - or am I totally wrong?

Must be manual though, so maybe the 550 is the way forward?

Any owners of either want to make a case?
Had both and both are great in their own way, 550 clutch is heavy and gearchange deliberate meaning you tend to live on (ample) torque, 575 (F1) feels much faster, tend to drive it harder as it's so easy to downchange and use all the power. 575 has updated cabin and feels better made (may be subjective)

If i did it again I'd go 575 F1 everytime cloud9

rs48635

557 posts

245 months

Wednesday 28th September 2011
quotequote all
Not been in 575, but had a (very) fast drive in 550. Made my 3200 GT Assetto Corsa (twin turbo + handling kit) seem a bit slow and barge-like. This one had suspension mods "like fiorano handling pack), but standard engine and brakes. Awesome neck-snapping accelleration and braking, doing boy racer style overtaking on single carriage way. Car never felt big or unwieldy ( I was PAX only wink

paul0843

2,007 posts

238 months

Wednesday 28th September 2011
quotequote all
Had both..575 definately an improvement both mechanically and in looks IMO..

I think about 50-60 manuals came to uk,so not a massive
Selection to choose from..
I would always have 575 over 550

rs48635

557 posts

245 months

Thursday 29th September 2011
quotequote all
Not claiming EVO mag are the final arbiter on car choice, but the 575 didn't get top marks. Maybe it was not enough of an improvement on the 550 for them.

On the other hand the 550 won car of the car of the decade - against 9 other winners of car of the year (ECOTY)

johnnyreggae

3,171 posts

191 months

Thursday 29th September 2011
quotequote all
I agree : Evo always are to be believed in preference to real world owners

JazzyO

1,125 posts

212 months

Thursday 29th September 2011
quotequote all
I am totally in love with my 550, have been for 4 years and 47,000kms (30k miles). I have no desire to upgrade to a 575, I actually prefer the looks of the 550 (although minimally different) and power difference is small. I prefer the manual.

It has been an almost totally reliable machine, breaking down once with a clutch pressure group failure (although I did manage the 400 miles back to home) and a replaced ECU.

Annual cost has been a bit less than I had predicted. I've done 1 major, and other than that it's been minor annual services.

Awesome cars. Still quick, practical, and very handsome in my view. One thing that has struck me and continues to surprise me is that this car is still ingratiating itself to me. Demolishing kilometres on the Autobahn last Sunday showed her again doing what she does best: crush continents. I just feel good whenever I drive her.

There is a 458 on the way but the 550 is staying. smile


Onno

bqf

Original Poster:

2,290 posts

202 months

Thursday 29th September 2011
quotequote all
Thanks for all the replies so far, especially from satisfied owners. Seems that the 550 and 575 each have their loyal devotees!

Genuinely, I really can't decide between the two. I suspect I'll have to drive both, but then I'm not sure there is any noticeable performance difference?

The only thing in the back of my mind is the gearchange - I really think I have to have a manual. The F1 575 (£56k at Lancaster) looks great, but I just can't get away from wanting a manual gearchange - I hate the paddleshift in my E55 AMG - it's always in manual anyway.


bqf

Original Poster:

2,290 posts

202 months

Thursday 29th September 2011
quotequote all
JazzyO said:
I've done 1 major, and other than that it's been minor annual services.
Onno
Do you mind me asking how much the major and minor services are?

JazzyO

1,125 posts

212 months

Thursday 29th September 2011
quotequote all
bqf said:
Do you mind me asking how much the major and minor services are?
Major was 3k euro, minor couple of hundred.


Onno

F355GTS

3,875 posts

286 months

Thursday 29th September 2011
quotequote all
bqf said:
Thanks for all the replies so far, especially from satisfied owners. Seems that the 550 and 575 each have their loyal devotees!

Genuinely, I really can't decide between the two. I suspect I'll have to drive both, but then I'm not sure there is any noticeable performance difference?

The only thing in the back of my mind is the gearchange - I really think I have to have a manual. The F1 575 (£56k at Lancaster) looks great, but I just can't get away from wanting a manual gearchange - I hate the paddleshift in my E55 AMG - it's always in manual anyway.
Once you get properly used to an F1 change you'll wonder why you spent so long stirring a stick smile I changed for my 550 to 575 F1 specifically to get the F1 having experienced the CC box in my Wife's Maserati Spyder, which as it happens has to be the worst F1 style box I've ever driven

JazzyO

1,125 posts

212 months

Friday 30th September 2011
quotequote all
F355GTS said:
Once you get properly used to an F1 change you'll wonder why you spent so long stirring a stick smile I changed for my 550 to 575 F1 specifically to get the F1 having experienced the CC box in my Wife's Maserati Spyder, which as it happens has to be the worst F1 style box I've ever driven
Hate to disagree, but I do. I don't like the F1 in the 575 as much as I do the manual in the 550. It's an analog GT (well some electronic systems but a very analog feel to the car) and it's a different drive than a V8 Ferrari. On my 458 order, there is no manual option but if there was, I would still go for the DCT. But for the 550, I prefer the manual. Different type of car, put to different use using a different drive style.

Of course - that doesn't mean that your opinion isn't perfectly valid! It's just the way that I personally feel about the 550/575. I know that many will disagree with me and that is perfectly fine. It's just that you said that once you (meaning anyone) have driven the F1 you won't go back, and I can't agree with that.


Onno

Plug550

1,108 posts

246 months

Friday 30th September 2011
quotequote all
FWIW, this months Glasses Guide shows that the 550 is worth £10400 more at trade value than the 575 manual, and £9675 more than the F1 box. All on [02] reg with 41000 miles. Intriguingly, the 550 has risen by £1000 this month, and the 575 by only £725. As best that can tell, the only other car to rise in value this month is the 911 C4S Targa, but I haven't checked all 1900 pages!

I've had my 550 for 6 years now, and is without doubt the best car I've ever driven. Reliable, fast, nimble, and an absolute dream to own and drive. I wholeheartedly agree with the OP though, manual is the only way to go!