Balboni or 430?
Author
Discussion

Granturismo Dan

Original Poster:

48 posts

242 months

Friday 2nd March 2012
quotequote all
Evening all,

Today I drove a Balboni, I wasn't really prepared in that I'd only nipped out for a haircut and 20 mins later found myself out on a test drive. As a result I had great big boots on and as a result I had my left knee rubbing under the steering wheel to avoid my left foot being on the foot rest and the brake pedal which felt a little restricting.

Also something else that was a little off putting was that when it was in manual mode it changed up a millisecond or two before I was ready and possibly 500rpm off the limiter. Not only off putting but really irritating and possibly dangerous if balancing the car around a corner. Is this normal? It didn't do it in Corsa, but of course that also means no TC. How much of an issue is no TC in a 2wd Gallardo?

Tomorrow I'm going back (with sensible shoes on) to have a go in a 430 as a comparison.

I've done a quick search on here for Balboni posts to try and get to the bottom of whether it's desireable or simply rare for the reason that it's not the favorite. All I found was a mixture of opinion. So, open to hear what people think on this.

My current toy as you can guess from my user name is a Maser GT-S. I've found this to be a great all rounder and have been happy with it for the 21 months I've had it, but I'm in a bit of an impulse purchase mood. I also have an S1 Elise. I found the Gallardo to be kind of in between the pair of them... which I suppose it would be really.

I was expecting (and hoping) to be blown away by the Balboni, and whilst I did give it a bit of a tickle, the majority of the journey was at 40mph and so it felt quite "normal". I'm planning on taking a longer more interesting drive tomorrow to try and get into it a bit more.

Has anyone here had both a Gallardo either 2wd or 4wd and a 430?
What were your thoughts on the differences between the two?
Strengths and weaknesses of them both?


Edited by Granturismo Dan on Friday 2nd March 23:22

djt77

272 posts

256 months

Saturday 3rd March 2012
quotequote all
What year are you looking at, I hear the later cars are better than the early ones, but not sure if they are refereed to as Balboni anymore? Here is bit of a review I found on another site http://www.lambopower.com/forum/index.php?showtopi...

70proof

6,158 posts

186 months

Saturday 3rd March 2012
quotequote all
Hi matey. Confused re e gear. If in manual mode you should dictate when the gear changes, and you should be able to hit the rev limiter! Maybe they changed it for the lp cars, sure others will comment. Driving at 40 also won't endear you to it..... smile

franki68

11,708 posts

252 months

Saturday 3rd March 2012
quotequote all
Best advice....ignore everyone's opinion and drive them both yourself,make your own mind up,there is little to choose between them and it depends on your personal tastes.

RevHappy

1,850 posts

193 months

Saturday 3rd March 2012
quotequote all
Gaive the maser strad a go as well, sounds epic in race and the gear box is great.

Granturismo Dan

Original Poster:

48 posts

242 months

Saturday 3rd March 2012
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies so far.

I'm going out in the 430 in a couple of hours time so will report back and probably have more questions...

RevHappy

1,850 posts

193 months

Saturday 3rd March 2012
quotequote all
Granturismo Dan said:
Thanks for the replies so far.

I'm going out in the 430 in a couple of hours time so will report back and probably have more questions...
If it's an F1 make sure its at least in sport.

topjay

787 posts

249 months

Saturday 3rd March 2012
quotequote all
Not much help on your question as i have had limited time in a 430 but the later G's gearbox if comparing egear & F1 is much much better than the F car.

If it helps your decision, Corsa does not mean no tc it, gives you about 2-3ft of movement before it kicks in and kills the power and brakes the inside wheel to bring you inline, it also does not shift up as you mention even if you sit on the limiter. If you want to turn off tc there is a esp button in the centre switches, i would not if i were you though unless on a track as there is quite a fine line between a bit of movement and suddenly facing the wrong way if you are really pushing it.
Sport gives you less movement and shifts up if you hit the limiter.

On 2 vs 4 wheel drive i can only speak from my experience and when it was discussed before others on here disagreed:-

Little difference in how they drive/feel just the 2 wheel is much more slippery and therefore slower.
As i mentioned previously on the Lambo drivers course which was all current owners & all the models in both egear & manual except the SL, people by the end of day were trying to avoid in this order, the manual cars, the spyder and then the 550-2. Everyone wanted the SL or 560.



sone

4,612 posts

269 months

Saturday 3rd March 2012
quotequote all
I've been considering the very same choice recently but not yet ready to go for it just yet. Anyway my mind was made up very quickly when I was given the option of a 12 month 4 k max claim warranty on the Lambo or a 2 year unlimited warranty on the 430,
I'd love to own a Lambo but I guess I'm just not brave enough.

jackal

11,251 posts

313 months

Saturday 3rd March 2012
quotequote all
lots of previous threads on here re: subjective driving differences of the 2 cars but yeah, drive both and decide yourself

martisracing

211 posts

220 months

Monday 5th March 2012
quotequote all
I have both a LP560 coupe and a 430 spider. The cars are very different in character. Without a doubt the 'better' car is the LP. If I could only have one it would be the LP. It is faster, has better performance, is better made, is more economic, handles better in that it is so forgiving and confidence inspiring and looks like a real supercar (double edged sword!). The technical wins to the 430 are the brakes and ride quality. The brakes are far more progressive than the LP. With regard to shift quality (they are both paddle shift) the LP is may be a fraction better but there is nothing in it really.
What makes the 430 so good is it being a soft top. That makes it so different to the LP that it is a totally different driving experience where the ultimate performance and handling is not so important. The 430 is also slightly more pratical has it has a bigger boot. Surprisingly you have to be more careful with speeds bumps in the 430 than the LP (it does not have lifting gear).The 430 also does not attract so much attention (mine is in black).
It is for these two reasons (and the fact that it is a soft top) that it is our car of choice for our annual summer holiday trip to Corsica.
Running costs are almost identical. Long term I think the LP would be a cheaper bet as there are so many Audi mechanical and suspension parts under the skin.
Hope that helps a bit.

Granturismo Dan

Original Poster:

48 posts

242 months

Monday 5th March 2012
quotequote all
Excellent replies, thank you all.
@ Martisracing, that's exactly the feedback I was looking for, thanks.

Unfortunately I didn't get a chance to drive the 430 as the dealer was absolutely rammed and didn't have a 430 out ready. I'm going back Friday to try their Spider.

I did take the Gallardo out again though and got on a lot better with it this time around.
It really is a great car, and very fast.

I'm coming around to the idea of waving goodbye to the Maser, although it would definitly be missed.

jackal

11,251 posts

313 months

Monday 5th March 2012
quotequote all
martisracing said:
handles better in that it is so forgiving and confidence inspiring
Very subjective this one, esp. if you don't like foolproof cars. I found an 06G a bit blunt, heavy and devoid of feel compared to the sinewy & agile 430. The inert steering was its main let down IMO. Ferrari more interesting to drive and steering/chassis/suspension feels so much sweeter.

SonnyM

3,475 posts

224 months

Monday 5th March 2012
quotequote all
But isn't the 06G quite different to the LP560 in handling, steering feel, e-gear etc?

jackal

11,251 posts

313 months

Monday 5th March 2012
quotequote all
SonnyM said:
But isn't the 06G quite different to the LP560 in handling, steering feel, e-gear etc?
Engine, body mods, some structural stiffening, revised E gear and just 20kg lighter isn't it ? I'd be surprised if the basic chatacter and feel of the car was significantly changed especially as the suspension and bushings all seem to be the same. Could of course be totally wrong though !

Surely if OP is in the market for a 560 he'd be looking at a Scuderia in any case ?

SpeedFreakDave

860 posts

243 months

Monday 5th March 2012
quotequote all
I've got a balboni and I don't have the issue with the up change. In sport mode it wont let you hit the rev limiter but it will in corsa. Tbh I wouldn't bother reving for the last few hundred revs, plenty of power across the power curve. The car is stunning and will soak up miles like a GT car if you want it. Great sound track. Handling is great, brakes a little wooden. Scuderia is a sharper drive but I didn't want to sit in a car with such a basic interior. The lambo has a stunning finish inside and out. If you are serious, drive them back to back with the right shoes on!

Enjoy.

AndrewD

7,659 posts

315 months

Monday 5th March 2012
quotequote all
jackal said:
Engine, body mods, some structural stiffening, revised E gear and just 20kg lighter isn't it ? I'd be surprised if the basic chatacter and feel of the car was significantly changed especially as the suspension and bushings all seem to be the same. Could of course be totally wrong though !

Surely if OP is in the market for a 560 he'd be looking at a Scuderia in any case ?
560 felt significantly quicker than my MY08G and Superlegover. It also seemed a bit quiter unless in corsa

andrew

10,365 posts

223 months

Tuesday 6th March 2012
quotequote all
AndrewD said:
jackal said:
Engine, body mods, some structural stiffening, revised E gear and just 20kg lighter isn't it ? I'd be surprised if the basic chatacter and feel of the car was significantly changed especially as the suspension and bushings all seem to be the same. Could of course be totally wrong though !

Surely if OP is in the market for a 560 he'd be looking at a Scuderia in any case ?
560 felt significantly quicker than my MY08G and Superlegover. It also seemed a bit quiter unless in corsa
i thought you drove a clio, not a corsa biggrin

AndrewD

7,659 posts

315 months

Tuesday 6th March 2012
quotequote all
andrew said:
AndrewD said:
jackal said:
Engine, body mods, some structural stiffening, revised E gear and just 20kg lighter isn't it ? I'd be surprised if the basic chatacter and feel of the car was significantly changed especially as the suspension and bushings all seem to be the same. Could of course be totally wrong though !

Surely if OP is in the market for a 560 he'd be looking at a Scuderia in any case ?
560 felt significantly quicker than my MY08G and Superlegover. It also seemed a bit quiter unless in corsa
i thought you drove a clio, not a corsa biggrin
You never write, you never call, then you come out with a comment like that smile

Granturismo Dan

Original Poster:

48 posts

242 months

Tuesday 6th March 2012
quotequote all
Thanks for your input chaps, deposit paid this morning.
Should be collecting the Balboni Thursday thumbup