F430 vs gallardo
Author
Discussion

dreamweaver7

Original Poster:

39 posts

176 months

Monday 12th March 2012
quotequote all
Hi - i currently drive an m3 and am now in a position to buy my first super car.....

My dilemma is that I am having trouble deciding between F430 (05-08) and the Gallardo (04-08). I want a convertible, spider, f1/e-gear (given i am based in london) with about £70-80k to spend.

I thought this would be a very common question for newbies - however I have read quite a few pages on these forums which are very helpful but none of these seem to assess this comparison directly - i have also read a few car reviews but would really like views from people who have owned and driven them.

I test drove both of them and here is what i think - grateful for any views other people may have...


Compared to the f430, the following is my list of pros and cons for the gallardo:

Postives:
+ i felt much more in control of the car (i.e. if i did something stupid, the car would pull me in the right direction) - i guess because of the 4 w drive
+ i like the looks of the gallardo slightly more
+ got more features like electric mirrors, proper sat nav etc.

Negatives:
- brakes seem quite heavy
- e-gears shifting wasn't as smooth as the F1
- slightly more expensive than the F430 (I am assuming depreciation of both cars would be same in the next 3 yrs or so)
- seats seemed much more firmer

Sarnie

8,379 posts

240 months

Monday 12th March 2012
quotequote all
If your based in London then what you DON'T want is either the F1/E-gear..........manual is what you should be after and both systems are a bit clumsy and awkward at constant low speeds. Plus you'll go through a clutch much quicker.

70proof

6,158 posts

186 months

Monday 12th March 2012
quotequote all
so you have done your research and driven both...... don;t listen then to anyone here....

simply ask yourself which one put the biggest grin on your face, and buy that one, quit-pro-quo..

doesn;t matter about faults etc etc etc .... the seating position, pedal offset and footwell space still pisses me off everytime i climb in the car, all for a few seconds until i turn the key, then all is forgotten except that that makes me grin....

70proof

6,158 posts

186 months

Monday 12th March 2012
quotequote all
Sarnie said:
If your based in London then what you DON'T want is either the F1/E-gear..........manual is what you should be after and both systems are a bit clumsy and awkward at constant low speeds. Plus you'll go through a clutch much quicker.
totally agree, the e gear downchanges for you when you slow down.... and badly!!!

yetie

377 posts

238 months

Monday 12th March 2012
quotequote all
Lambo puts a bigger smile on your face rofl

UH-Matt

2,173 posts

271 months

Monday 12th March 2012
quotequote all
I am well qualified here having had a Gallardo Spyder, currently in a F430 Coupe and possibly heading back to an LP570 this year....

Firstly the Gallardo is the only car I actually think looks good as a Spyder. I went for an F430 coupe because I just don't like the lines of the F430 as a Spyder. Either way I am sure you have your own view here smile

Handling: Gallardo inspires confidence because it has the 4x4 drive, sounds like you have already noticed this. HOWEVER for me this also makes the F430 more exciting, rear drive and having a twitchy rear can be great fun when you begin to master it! Put a proper geo setup on a F430 and the handling is emmese, its setup quite tame from factory.

Looks: Gallardo has more wow factor, its going to be looked at more, it is not at all subtle. If you want to be looked at then the Gallardo is the way to go. F430 can be a lot more subtle but its still never going to blend in. I went from an orange Gallardo to a grey F430 and still get just as much attention.

Features: To be honest the Gallardo doesn't have more features, perhaps your just comparing a high spec gallardo with a low spec f430, every car is different and you definitely need to spend some time working out which features are a must for you before you buy a car.

Gearbox: The egear in 04-08 Gallardos is NOT as good as the F1 in F430's of the same vintage. Love the F1 gearbox on my '57 F430 and it feels miles ahead of the Egear I had on my '07 Gallardo. That said if you can stretch to an LP560 then this beats them both hands down!

Depreciation: Nobody will be able to answer this. The market seems to be in limbo at the moment and certainly very different to 12-18 months ago when you couldn't lose on a Gallardo. I suspect that over the next 12-18 months both cars will indeed lose a similar amount but nobody can really tell. Gallardo were in high demand but don't seem to be now (market looks very slow from my point of view viewing classifieds daily).

For me I moved from Gallardo to F430 for a few reasons:

- My 07 Gallardo had just run out of warranty. Lamborghini do not have the confidence to offer an extended warranty on their cars, and I don't want to run the risk of potentially very very expensive bills. Ferrari on the other hand for a car of the same year gave me 2 years extended warranty at no cost because I bought from a main dealer, this is a huge selling point if you want some piece of mind.

- I was a little bit bored. I change often. I felt I had "done" the lambo thing and wanted to try a Ferrari. I feel like while the gallardo was confidence inspiring with the 4x4 I am having WAY WAY more fun in my Ferrari, have already done more miles in it too including little trips to the shops etc etc.

- Ferrari feels more usable. I have to reverse up a steep driveway to get my car into its parking, the Gallardo would not do this when cold, and I went through a clutch trying, it was not at all happy when cold. The Ferrari on the other hand is far far more willing out of the box. Of course I do warm my cars up correctly, but for my general usability with my parking situation and heavy traffic in the city centre the 430 is much happier than the Gallardo.

- Driving position. I am 6ft2 and although I did not mind the Gallardo driving position, now I Have had the 430 I realise how uncomfortable I was before. The pedals are very middle and I had to sit at a slight wonk, the 430 driving position suits my build much better.

Will write more as I think of things, hope my comments help a little bit.

1Gav

11 posts

186 months

Monday 12th March 2012
quotequote all
You are bang on with your pros vs. cons and I went for the Lambo first then the Fezza (albeit a manual coupe to a Scuderia).
Absolutely loved the Gallardo (get an 06 or newer) but now prefer the 430.

You pays your money and you takes your choice.

UH-Matt has a peach of a 430 Spider, fully loaded, which may currently be for sale.
He and Mosi have extensively driven both and I'm sure either or both will pitch up soon with more insight.

Sarnie

8,379 posts

240 months

Monday 12th March 2012
quotequote all
1Gav said:
You are bang on with your pros vs. cons and I went for the Lambo first then the Fezza (albeit a manual coupe to a Scuderia).
Absolutely loved the Gallardo (get an 06 or newer) but now prefer the 430.

You pays your money and you takes your choice.

UH-Matt has a peach of a 430 Spider, fully loaded, which may currently be for sale.
He and Mosi have extensively driven both and I'm sure either or both will pitch up soon with more insight.
Matt's car isn't a spider wink

1Gav

11 posts

186 months

Monday 12th March 2012
quotequote all
Must have got him mixed up with someone else.

UH-Matt

2,173 posts

271 months

Monday 12th March 2012
quotequote all
.. it is a loaded peach of a car though wink

andrew

10,368 posts

223 months

Monday 12th March 2012
quotequote all
head : ferrari
[ you know the rest ]

UH-Matt

2,173 posts

271 months

Monday 12th March 2012
quotequote all

dan72

38 posts

213 months

Monday 12th March 2012
quotequote all
I've had three gallardos two spyders and a coupe but the 430 is a keeper. Not loads better but definitely better.

Edited by dan72 on Monday 12th March 18:21

iandc

3,893 posts

237 months

Monday 12th March 2012
quotequote all
UH-Matt said:
That is not at all helpful. They both look bloody gorgeous!!! biggrin

dreamweaver7

Original Poster:

39 posts

176 months

Monday 12th March 2012
quotequote all
thank you for all the input - much appreciated!

Blues

8,546 posts

250 months

Monday 12th March 2012
quotequote all
I had the same decision to make as you just one year ago, however I knew in my heart of hearts that I was going to buy the Gallardo Spider... until I drove the F430.

The ride, the driving position, the F1 box, the V8 sound, the luggage space - all suited my personal taste.

8k miles, 6 track days, 4 trips to France later, I have absolutely no regrets. It could well be a keeper for me smile

However - it is down to personal taste, so there really is no correct answer.

russy01

4,823 posts

212 months

Monday 12th March 2012
quotequote all
UH-Matt said:
F430 is lovely, but wow the gallardo in that colour is fantastic. Am I right in thinking its a 1st gen with the lp560 front?

Try5t

722 posts

239 months

Monday 12th March 2012
quotequote all
430 Spider would be my choice... cheaper servicing and running costs compared to my mate's Gallardo.



[url]


|http://thumbsnap.com/CC90fcWe[/url]

yetie

377 posts

238 months

Monday 12th March 2012
quotequote all
the lambo is like a piece of art only the dino comes close to it in my eyesrofl

yetie

377 posts

238 months

Monday 12th March 2012
quotequote all
lots more 430's out and about there, get the lambo in a silly colour ...its nice to be different to the rest smokin