Masa 4200 Spyder - Manual or Flappy
Masa 4200 Spyder - Manual or Flappy
Author
Discussion

gary_de_tam

Original Poster:

448 posts

247 months

Monday 19th March 2012
quotequote all
Hi,

Anyone have experience of the gearbox's on offer,
seems to be alot more semi-auto's on the market
although I'd prefer the man, is the paddle ok ?

read here, does not really give preference.
http://www.evo.co.uk/carreviews/evocarreviews/2558...

gt..

NeilH

344 posts

301 months

Monday 19th March 2012
quotequote all
Hello...

I have been fortunate enough to have driven both - and currently own a 4200 with the flappy.

As far as the manual is concerned, the clutch was very very heavy on it - and is my main recollection. Sure once you get used to it, like anything you adapt. Certainly however my wife did not like driving it.

The flappy is great, but again, you do need to adapt a little bit. The very later years had a better firmware that made the change better - certainly I don't have an issue with mine. However, it can be slow getting away from the lights. The sport mode sharpens the changes (and is actually better for the gearbox) and is the setting my car spends most of its life in.

Once you get used to the flappy, it is easy to live with. Sure, it is not the shapest system I have ever used, but it is also not the worst. Given the choice, I would take flappy over manual as it suits the car better.. but that is just the ramblings of one person !! rotate

gary_de_tam

Original Poster:

448 posts

247 months

Monday 19th March 2012
quotequote all
Hi Neil,

thanks for the response, what year do you have, is there
any truth in the updates on a particular year and a must have
option ?

gt..

limpsfield

6,680 posts

284 months

Monday 19th March 2012
quotequote all
NeilH said:
Once you get used to the flappy, it is easy to live with. Sure, it is not the shapest system I have ever used, but it is also not the worst. Given the choice, I would take flappy over manual as it suits the car better.. but that is just the ramblings of one person !! rotate
I have had my 4200 coupe for two years and was looking for a manual in the beginning after reading how bad the flappies were. But I am very glad I went for the flappy in the end - and mine is a 2002 car, significant improvements were made after apparently. I love it and really suits the car as per NeilH above.

NeilH

344 posts

301 months

Monday 19th March 2012
quotequote all
My car is the MY05 model, and yes, there is apparently a noticable difference in the older cars that have not had the latest firmware - but I can't comment on this first hand. Only thing I can say is that I drove an early model Ferrari 360 with exactly the same system on it (they both come from the same stable obviously) and it was very bad - an enormous pause between gears.

propaganda

407 posts

278 months

Monday 19th March 2012
quotequote all
The Cambiocorsa gearbox is not bad but you do need the very latest software to get the best out of it. Early versions were a bit lumpy. Maserati made significant improvements over the life of the car, and if I remember correctly you are looking to have at very least the "Go Fast" update installed.

I found manual is a bit hard going until it gets warmed up, 2nd to 3rd could be difficult.

maser_spyder

6,356 posts

213 months

Tuesday 20th March 2012
quotequote all
I've had my Spyder for six years, tried both when buying, found the manual cumbersome, and the paddles easy to live with. Plumped for the CC gearbox, and haven't regretted it at all!

I've technically replaced the Maser with the Gallardo (also E-gear / paddles), but it's still in my garage for the moment, not sure I'm ready to part with it.... wink

Colossus

337 posts

245 months

Tuesday 20th March 2012
quotequote all
Have driven both and owned a full manual 4200, which I preferred. One of the problems with the manual is that it needs to have the linkage regularly adjusted. It is only a very small job and costs next to nothing but can transform the way the shift action works. Many people are not aware of this and so live with a recalcitrant shift action. Clutch should not be heavy, they were actually fairly easy on the leg but a heavy one could signal that the clutch is on its way out.

My xperience of the CC box was that it was truly dreadful in traffic and town driving (don't think about a 3 point turn let alone reverse up a slight incline) but smoothed out a bit on the open road. I think it therefore depends where you will be doing most of your driving as to which 'box suits most.

Try boith systems if you can and yes the later CC cars were better but it is a relative thing. I now own a GranTurismo S which has the MC Shift and not only is it brilliant it is simply light years away from the clunky old CC system. Good luck!

russman777

167 posts

194 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
Think I saw you maser_spyder today in your spyder near mc d's roundabout,nice to see your enjoying it with the roof down,see a lot of california's in town with the roofs up on nice days,which I don't get lol

yetie

377 posts

238 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
spoke to Main Masa dealer today, asking about their gearbox and other things .... auto is way forward in their eyes

maser_spyder

6,356 posts

213 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
russman777 said:
Think I saw you maser_spyder today in your spyder near mc d's roundabout,nice to see your enjoying it with the roof down,see a lot of california's in town with the roofs up on nice days,which I don't get lol
wavey

The roof only stays up when it's a storm with a name.... wink

russman777

167 posts

194 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
nice to hear smile ,did you have a race with an r8 lately as mate my mate said he had a race with a spyder

maser_spyder

6,356 posts

213 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
russman777 said:
nice to hear smile ,did you have a race with an r8 lately as mate my mate said he had a race with a spyder
Followed a white R8 a few days ago, but was on Lansdown Road, 40 limit, so hardly a 'race'! By cracky, it was noisy, made mine sound very quiet indeed.... smile

russman777

167 posts

194 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
Oh right lol,yeah its very loud indeed prob one of the loudest around,he's got a quicksilver exhaust system on it

andymadmak

15,727 posts

301 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
Well I also tried both... and I got the manual. Clutch on mine is nice and light too. Shift is smooth and only really a bit clunky when going into reverse when cold. Other than that I at least have the reassurance of decent clutch life!

Either way, the 4200 spyder, especially the later glass rear window models are an epic bargain

Andy

maser_spyder

6,356 posts

213 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
andymadmak said:
Well I also tried both... and I got the manual. Clutch on mine is nice and light too. Shift is smooth and only really a bit clunky when going into reverse when cold. Other than that I at least have the reassurance of decent clutch life!

Either way, the 4200 spyder, especially the later glass rear window models are an epic bargain

Andy
Regarding clutch life....

I bought mine with 18000 miles on it, and was first serviced within a couple of months of purchase, measured at 77-ish% remaining.

Last service was done at 42000 miles, clutch measured at 55% remaining.

It's an early model CC gearbox.

So clutch life can be OK, depending how you drive the car!

EC2

1,547 posts

284 months

Monday 26th March 2012
quotequote all
Pesonally had a manual 4200 Coupe and loved it. Never liked the CC. However, it's all personal. Buy what you want not what others tell you.