550 and R8 V8 - dealers and more information
Discussion
I'm helping a friend look for his first car, the sod is choosing between a 550 and a V8 R8. Budget is around £50k.
I'm looking for advice on dealers or websites where we can go for more information. The cars themselves there is plenty of info on, it's more things like how much to budget for running costs/aftermarket warranties and finding the guys who really know them to speak to and get an informed opinion.
He's going into it with his eyes open about likely running costs, it will be a weekend car doing maybe 2-4k per year realistically. He's based in London, preferably looking for places in the south east. I've had a good look round and Rardleys and Walkersport seem popular - any others I should try or websites I should look at?
I'm also posting this in the Audi section.
(just to note he's never owned a car but has driven plenty so the car shouldn't be completely wasted on him!)
Cheers,
Rich
I'm looking for advice on dealers or websites where we can go for more information. The cars themselves there is plenty of info on, it's more things like how much to budget for running costs/aftermarket warranties and finding the guys who really know them to speak to and get an informed opinion.
He's going into it with his eyes open about likely running costs, it will be a weekend car doing maybe 2-4k per year realistically. He's based in London, preferably looking for places in the south east. I've had a good look round and Rardleys and Walkersport seem popular - any others I should try or websites I should look at?
I'm also posting this in the Audi section.
(just to note he's never owned a car but has driven plenty so the car shouldn't be completely wasted on him!)
Cheers,
Rich
baby g said:
I'm helping a friend look for his first car, the sod is choosing between a 550 and a V8 R8. Budget is around £50k.
I'm looking for advice on dealers or websites where we can go for more information. The cars themselves there is plenty of info on, it's more things like how much to budget for running costs/aftermarket warranties and finding the guys who really know them to speak to and get an informed opinion.
He's going into it with his eyes open about likely running costs, it will be a weekend car doing maybe 2-4k per year realistically. He's based in London, preferably looking for places in the south east. I've had a good look round and Rardleys and Walkersport seem popular - any others I should try or websites I should look at?
I'm also posting this in the Audi section.
(just to note he's never owned a car but has driven plenty so the car shouldn't be completely wasted on him!)
Cheers,
Rich
Both very different cars to be honest. Running cost will be very different to. The R8 I believe needs serviced every 2 years or 20k miles, which ever comes first. Whereas the 550 will need done every year or... Ok I've forgotten the mileage but I can't think it would be more than 10k. I'm looking for advice on dealers or websites where we can go for more information. The cars themselves there is plenty of info on, it's more things like how much to budget for running costs/aftermarket warranties and finding the guys who really know them to speak to and get an informed opinion.
He's going into it with his eyes open about likely running costs, it will be a weekend car doing maybe 2-4k per year realistically. He's based in London, preferably looking for places in the south east. I've had a good look round and Rardleys and Walkersport seem popular - any others I should try or websites I should look at?
I'm also posting this in the Audi section.
(just to note he's never owned a car but has driven plenty so the car shouldn't be completely wasted on him!)
Cheers,
Rich
Both lovely cars though, so tell your friend to go drive both and see what he prefers. Regarding dealers, I can't comment on Audi dealers but Nick Cartwright is very good. He prepares his cars like new.
Hope that helps & good luck with the search.
Well as mentioned the running costs will be considerably different!
Personally, I love the 550 as it is a superb car with a front mounted V12 - not a lot to dislike really. But if I was buying a car to use etc for everyday I would be hard pushed not to go for the more modern R8 - I feel bad for saying it but that's where my money would go.
Chris
Personally, I love the 550 as it is a superb car with a front mounted V12 - not a lot to dislike really. But if I was buying a car to use etc for everyday I would be hard pushed not to go for the more modern R8 - I feel bad for saying it but that's where my money would go.
Chris
Thanks everyone!
Good question ref the insurance - I'll get him to make some enquiries about what he's letting himself in for.
Agreed the 550 will have higher running costs, hopefully offset to some extent by lower depreciation than in the R8. We're factoring in that the R8 will probably be an easier car to own, but it's very much for weekend trips and the like so far from a daily driver.
Rich
Good question ref the insurance - I'll get him to make some enquiries about what he's letting himself in for.
Agreed the 550 will have higher running costs, hopefully offset to some extent by lower depreciation than in the R8. We're factoring in that the R8 will probably be an easier car to own, but it's very much for weekend trips and the like so far from a daily driver.
Rich
Two very different cars, 550 is an old school V12 GT, R8 V8 is an 911 with a V8 heart.
Running cost would be at least double on the 550.
360 vs R8 V8 would be a closer race, but 360 would walk it as weekend only.
R8 V10 now that's a different story, but another 25k and that puts the 430 into the mix.
Running cost would be at least double on the 550.
360 vs R8 V8 would be a closer race, but 360 would walk it as weekend only.
R8 V10 now that's a different story, but another 25k and that puts the 430 into the mix.
I must say I don't understand the choice options. These cars are absolutely incomparable. I think your friend should drive both of them and then the choice will be clear. I find it very hard to believe that you would not pick a clear winner (which one that will be depends on your personal preference, both great cars).
For me, as a DD, I want a reliable car with mod cons. For a special, hobby car, I want something to stir the soul. In my opinion, you shouldn't mix the two. If you do, you will lose some of the magic of your P&J as its foibles become apparent. The 550 is a 16 year old car now. It is still fast, it is still great to drive, it is still special. But it is an old car.
If I was making your friend's choice, I'd buy an E92 Coupe for daily use and use the 550 for special days. Oh wait - that is what I have done.
Onno
For me, as a DD, I want a reliable car with mod cons. For a special, hobby car, I want something to stir the soul. In my opinion, you shouldn't mix the two. If you do, you will lose some of the magic of your P&J as its foibles become apparent. The 550 is a 16 year old car now. It is still fast, it is still great to drive, it is still special. But it is an old car.
If I was making your friend's choice, I'd buy an E92 Coupe for daily use and use the 550 for special days. Oh wait - that is what I have done.

Onno
As mentioned above, the cars don't seem very comparable
A 360 would be more comparable to the R8, and are also around the 50k mark (maybe as low as 40k). Has he considered those? Add another 10k to his budget and you are looking at Gallardos.
On the other hand if he is looking at a GT car, other than the 550 there's the DB9, Granturismo. Maybe Bentley Continental? All achievable for 50k
If it was my decision I'd get a 360 (manual). Most likely will hold it value better than the R8, and more special as a weekend car
A 360 would be more comparable to the R8, and are also around the 50k mark (maybe as low as 40k). Has he considered those? Add another 10k to his budget and you are looking at Gallardos.
On the other hand if he is looking at a GT car, other than the 550 there's the DB9, Granturismo. Maybe Bentley Continental? All achievable for 50k
If it was my decision I'd get a 360 (manual). Most likely will hold it value better than the R8, and more special as a weekend car
Nice write up on the 550 in this months EVO, where the extensively compare a stunning example with its forefathers and off spring. Depreciation is likely to be zero on the 550, whereas the R8 still has a way to go due to sheer numbers. As a 'feel good' Sundays and Highdays car, you'll not go too far wrong with a 550.
That's my car in EVO by the way
And it all came about by posting on theses pages!
That's my car in EVO by the way
And it all came about by posting on theses pages!Thanks everyone, really useful.
FranzKlampon - I had a good poke around your car at Brooklands a couple of weeks ago, it looks proper good.
The choice of cars came down from a few criteria:
- Not too showy
- Not too extreme, should still be comfortable
- Something a bit more special than high end BMs, Mercs, Jags etc
- Astons/Maseratis etc nice but plenty of time to do those later
- Porsches out because he just doesn't want one
This pretty much left the R8 among modern cars (GTR and American options failed the feeling special test, smaller marques feel more risky). Then you ask the question why you'd spend £50k on an R8 when you can get a Maranello for that money which ticks all of the above boxes as well. 355/360s are borderline but probably a bit more on the showy side, particularly exhaust noise.
Had a good time at Amari yesterday. We're going to visit a couple of places tomorrow, hopefully get a couple of drives and proceed from there.
FranzKlampon - I had a good poke around your car at Brooklands a couple of weeks ago, it looks proper good.
The choice of cars came down from a few criteria:
- Not too showy
- Not too extreme, should still be comfortable
- Something a bit more special than high end BMs, Mercs, Jags etc
- Astons/Maseratis etc nice but plenty of time to do those later
- Porsches out because he just doesn't want one
This pretty much left the R8 among modern cars (GTR and American options failed the feeling special test, smaller marques feel more risky). Then you ask the question why you'd spend £50k on an R8 when you can get a Maranello for that money which ticks all of the above boxes as well. 355/360s are borderline but probably a bit more on the showy side, particularly exhaust noise.
Had a good time at Amari yesterday. We're going to visit a couple of places tomorrow, hopefully get a couple of drives and proceed from there.
Kickstart said:
I do wonder with 550's whether we are now getting to the point when they will start to need engine rebuilds as the earliest ones are now 16 years old. My old car recently needed a fairly extensive and expensive rebuild and it had been serviced to death.
Not at all. Most 550's have less than 50k miles and I know of one that did 100k miles without any need for a rebuild. Mine has now done close to 50k and although some things are breaking at the moment, there is certainly no need for a rebuild, the engine is purring as sweet as ever. I plan a sympathetic restoration in the next 12 months and no rebuild is part of that plan.Onno
What were your thoughts on the R8 and the 550 at Amari?
I was considering a drive over there tomorrow to have a look at both these cars.
I'm having a dilemma / bit of a moment. Although I really enjoy my GTR, it's a fantastic car does everything so well I can't help but think I want something a bit different. The problem is people who have had a GTR have all said that nothing will be as good, the gear change the power etc.
Ive always liked the look of the 430 and the R8 but I'd be buying in at the bottom end of the market so run the risk of a car with history or potential issues.
I was considering a drive over there tomorrow to have a look at both these cars.
I'm having a dilemma / bit of a moment. Although I really enjoy my GTR, it's a fantastic car does everything so well I can't help but think I want something a bit different. The problem is people who have had a GTR have all said that nothing will be as good, the gear change the power etc.
Ive always liked the look of the 430 and the R8 but I'd be buying in at the bottom end of the market so run the risk of a car with history or potential issues.
Feel free to come and have a look at mine...
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/3812560.htm
Its alot of car for the money and it's in great condition.
http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/3812560.htm
Its alot of car for the money and it's in great condition.
s99ane said:
What were your thoughts on the R8 and the 550 at Amari?
I was considering a drive over there tomorrow to have a look at both these cars.
I'm having a dilemma / bit of a moment. Although I really enjoy my GTR, it's a fantastic car does everything so well I can't help but think I want something a bit different. The problem is people who have had a GTR have all said that nothing will be as good, the gear change the power etc.
Ive always liked the look of the 430 and the R8 but I'd be buying in at the bottom end of the market so run the risk of a car with history or potential issues.
I find amari cars horrifically overpriced and unrealistic ,I genuinely dont know how he sells some of them.I was considering a drive over there tomorrow to have a look at both these cars.
I'm having a dilemma / bit of a moment. Although I really enjoy my GTR, it's a fantastic car does everything so well I can't help but think I want something a bit different. The problem is people who have had a GTR have all said that nothing will be as good, the gear change the power etc.
Ive always liked the look of the 430 and the R8 but I'd be buying in at the bottom end of the market so run the risk of a car with history or potential issues.
s99ane said:
What were your thoughts on the R8 and the 550 at Amari?
I was considering a drive over there tomorrow to have a look at both these cars.
I'm having a dilemma / bit of a moment. Although I really enjoy my GTR, it's a fantastic car does everything so well I can't help but think I want something a bit different. The problem is people who have had a GTR have all said that nothing will be as good, the gear change the power etc.
Ive always liked the look of the 430 and the R8 but I'd be buying in at the bottom end of the market so run the risk of a car with history or potential issues.
Had a really good chat with John, one of their mechanics. Clearly knew his stuff, really enthusiastic about the cars and more than happy to spend as much time as it took to chew the fat over running these cars. Look him out if he's there when you visit. I was considering a drive over there tomorrow to have a look at both these cars.
I'm having a dilemma / bit of a moment. Although I really enjoy my GTR, it's a fantastic car does everything so well I can't help but think I want something a bit different. The problem is people who have had a GTR have all said that nothing will be as good, the gear change the power etc.
Ive always liked the look of the 430 and the R8 but I'd be buying in at the bottom end of the market so run the risk of a car with history or potential issues.
Gassing Station | Supercar General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


