Would you have welcomed Lamborghini taking over Pagani?
Would you have welcomed Lamborghini taking over Pagani?
Author
Discussion

Streetrod

Original Poster:

6,484 posts

237 months

Monday 23rd April 2012
quotequote all
So back in 1997 Horacio Pagani was developing the Zonda which he was financing out of his own back pocket. Lamborghini at the time were trying to restyle the Diablo with mixed results. The management turned to their retired marketing manager Ubaldo Sgarzi for advice, and knowing of Pagani and his car recommended they go have a look. So a few head guys headed over to Pagani's shed for a look-see and loving what he had done made him an offer $9million to buy the project. As money was tight Pagani took this offer very seriously but finally turned it down after his ten year old son convinced him not to give up on his dream.

Lamborghini returned home and went on to develop the Murcielago based on the Diablo's underpinnings.

So my questions are, should Pagani have sold and would owners on here with Lambo's from that era have welcomed the new car looking like the C12 but with a Lambo V12 in the back rather than the Merc engine, or was he right to stay the course?

As Pagani was recently offered and turned down an offer of 200 million euro’s for the company I think he made the right decision.

Caelum Blue

511 posts

229 months

Monday 23rd April 2012
quotequote all
I think Lamborghini would not have left the styling the same and we would not have seen the Zonda we all know. I also think that the Huayra would not have been developed.

Glad he turned them down.

JazzyO

1,125 posts

212 months

Monday 23rd April 2012
quotequote all
Caelum Blue said:
I think Lamborghini would not have left the styling the same and we would not have seen the Zonda we all know. I also think that the Huayra would not have been developed.

Glad he turned them down.
+1.


Onno

traxx

3,143 posts

253 months

Monday 23rd April 2012
quotequote all
On what planet could Pagani ever make enough money to deserve a 200m valuation?

Lambo FirstBlood

1,001 posts

210 months

Monday 23rd April 2012
quotequote all
traxx said:
On what planet could Pagani ever make enough money to deserve a 200m valuation?
I thought exactly the same thing when I read that. Their T/O can't be much more than 15% of that figure, I bet they don't make more than £5M P/A bottom line. PE ratio of 40!!!


AndrewD

7,659 posts

315 months

Monday 23rd April 2012
quotequote all
traxx said:
On what planet could Pagani ever make enough money to deserve a 200m valuation?
Wouldn't be the first time somebody paid well over the odds

Streetrod

Original Poster:

6,484 posts

237 months

Monday 23rd April 2012
quotequote all
AndrewD said:
traxx said:
On what planet could Pagani ever make enough money to deserve a 200m valuation?
Wouldn't be the first time somebody paid well over the odds
This!! I have given up trying to work out how companies are valued. Was there not some online photo company that has only been in existence for less than a couple of years and has yet to make a profit, was it not valued at close to a billion a couple of weeks ago as it was undergoing a buy out?

As for the Pagani offer I understand the company was the LVMH Group who had revenues of 6.6 billion Euros for the first quarter of 2012, a marked improvement on last year so not exactly short of a bob or two. To add Pagani to your portfolio would seem like a wise move considering the types of good they sell at $200 million too them may have made good business sense


Murcielago_Boy

2,014 posts

270 months

Monday 23rd April 2012
quotequote all
Streetrod said:
This!! I have given up trying to work out how companies are valued. Was there not some online photo company that has only been in existence for less than a couple of years and has yet to make a profit, was it not valued at close to a billion a couple of weeks ago as it was undergoing a buy out?

As for the Pagani offer I understand the company was the LVMH Group who had revenues of 6.6 billion Euros for the first quarter of 2012, a marked improvement on last year so not exactly short of a bob or two. To add Pagani to your portfolio would seem like a wise move considering the types of good they sell at $200 million too them may have made good business sense
Agreed. If it's true, I reckon it would be a fantastic strategic acquisition for LVMH.....

Having said that I also agree with Traxx too on the loony valuation, but that's strategic value right? - can anyone say Instagram?

From Horacio's pov, such a deal would turn the whole Pagani project from a few cars made in a shed in Italy (which puts off a LOT of potential owners in this market place (I mean - who fancies waiting months for a service kit or buying a Zonda R when there are no wet weather tyres available in the whole world?) into a real manufacturer.

Foolish IMO - for the moment he stays in a shed, praying for moneyed Qataris to fund the development of his next car. He didn't need to exit completely - he should have sold LVMH a stake so as to maintain his vision AND progress forward...

Streetrod

Original Poster:

6,484 posts

237 months

Monday 23rd April 2012
quotequote all
Murcielago_Boy said:
Streetrod said:
This!! I have given up trying to work out how companies are valued. Was there not some online photo company that has only been in existence for less than a couple of years and has yet to make a profit, was it not valued at close to a billion a couple of weeks ago as it was undergoing a buy out?

As for the Pagani offer I understand the company was the LVMH Group who had revenues of 6.6 billion Euros for the first quarter of 2012, a marked improvement on last year so not exactly short of a bob or two. To add Pagani to your portfolio would seem like a wise move considering the types of good they sell at $200 million too them may have made good business sense
Agreed. If it's true, I reckon it would be a fantastic strategic acquisition for LVMH.....

Having said that I also agree with Traxx too on the loony valuation, but that's strategic value right? - can anyone say Instagram?

From Horacio's pov, such a deal would turn the whole Pagani project from a few cars made in a shed in Italy (which puts off a LOT of potential owners in this market place (I mean - who fancies waiting months for a service kit or buying a Zonda R when there are no wet weather tyres available in the whole world?) into a real manufacturer.

Foolish IMO - for the moment he stays in a shed, praying for moneyed Qataris to fund the development of his next car. He didn't need to exit completely - he should have sold LVMH a stake so as to maintain his vision AND progress forward...
A "Shed" that's a little harsh I think. Anyway he is has almost moved into the new factory now.

As for being foolish by not taking the offer, I'm not sure. He has never relied on the Qataris to fund things; as a matter of fact his two main markets up until now have been the UK and the Far East. And with nearly 80 orders in the bag for Huraya's and people still pestering him to build Zonda's his company seems to be in rude health. Also you have to ask how much control he would have had to give up if he had sold, especially on such a personal product

As for wet weather tyre's for the Zonda R they have always been available as can be seen here towards the end of the video

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4YFR1yPhZmE


Murcielago_Boy

2,014 posts

270 months

Monday 23rd April 2012
quotequote all
Streetrod said:
A "Shed" that's a little harsh I think. Anyway he is has almost moved into the new factory now.

As for being foolish by not taking the offer, I'm not sure. He has never relied on the Qataris to fund things; as a matter of fact his two main markets up until now have been the UK and the Far East. And with nearly 80 orders in the bag for Huraya's and people still pestering him to build Zonda's his company seems to be in rude health. Also you have to ask how much control he would have had to give up if he had sold, especially on such a personal product

As for wet weather tyre's for the Zonda R they have always been available as can be seen here towards the end of the video

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4YFR1yPhZmE
Fair enough, I was being harsh. Your info's more likely to be up to date than mine - what I know/have seen:

- a pal of mine waited almost 8 months for some wet weather Zonda R tyres after being told that "errr.. we'd never developed any."

- Some years ago (not too long ago, the Zonda F had been released) I saw Zonda's being serviced by their UK service agent - a company called Verdi Ferrari.......
(remember the UK dealers - anyone remember Hudsons?? Good grief!!!! Perfect match).

- A few too many owners I've met (in the Far East) complaining that their are no real spares in stock, no real after sales, no real nothing beyond the original car. Perhaps that's changed.

- I've been to the (old?) "factory" - may not be a shed but it's not much more mate.

Magnificent car (the Zonda - I think the Huayra which I saw in Hong Kong, is a really ugly bit of kit ) but IMO all Pagani's are some way from being viable ownership propositions where you can jump in and drive them properly, especially in comparison to say a run-o-the-mill Enzo or a Bugatti Veyron.
A deal with LVMH would have changed all that IMO....
But then what do I know? smile


Edited by Murcielago_Boy on Monday 23 April 17:54


Edited by Murcielago_Boy on Monday 23 April 17:55

Streetrod

Original Poster:

6,484 posts

237 months

Monday 23rd April 2012
quotequote all
Murcielago_Boy said:
Streetrod said:
A "Shed" that's a little harsh I think. Anyway he is has almost moved into the new factory now.

As for being foolish by not taking the offer, I'm not sure. He has never relied on the Qataris to fund things; as a matter of fact his two main markets up until now have been the UK and the Far East. And with nearly 80 orders in the bag for Huraya's and people still pestering him to build Zonda's his company seems to be in rude health. Also you have to ask how much control he would have had to give up if he had sold, especially on such a personal product

As for wet weather tyre's for the Zonda R they have always been available as can be seen here towards the end of the video

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4YFR1yPhZmE
Fair enough, I was being harsh. Your info's more likely to be up to date than mine - what I know/have seen:

- a pal of mine waited almost 8 months for some wet weather Zonda R tyres after being told that "errr.. we'd never developed any."

- Some years ago (not too long ago, the Zonda F had been released) I saw Zonda's being serviced by their UK service agent - a company called Verdi Ferrari.......
(remember the UK dealers - anyone remember Hudsons?? Good grief!!!! Perfect match).

- A few too many owners I've met (in the Far East) complaining that their are no real spares in stock, no real after sales, no real nothing beyond the original car. Perhaps that's changed.

- I've been to the (old?) "factory" - may not be a shed but it's not much more mate.

Magnificent car (the Zonda - I think the Huayra which I saw in Hong Kong, is a really ugly bit of kit ) but IMO all Pagani's are some way from being viable ownership propositions where you can jump in and drive them properly, especially in comparison to say a run-o-the-mill Enzo or a Bugatti Veyron.
A deal with LVMH would have changed all that IMO....
But then what do I know? smile


Edited by Murcielago_Boy on Monday 23 April 17:54


Edited by Murcielago_Boy on Monday 23 April 17:55
Sorry to have to correct you again but as the resident Pagani geek here I feel the need biggrin

Zonda's, strange as it may seem are actually every day useable. One chap has put over 110,000km on his in six years. Harry Metcalf has close to 50,000km on his and various others have racked up even more. A Zonda is basically a very simple car, it has little in the way of electronics, the suspension does not use trick dampers and you don’t need to change the fuel tank every few years. Add the fact that the AMG engine is bullet proof needing very little in the way of maintenance and that all the major components are very easy to access, then you have a car that is easy to live with and cheaper to run.

HR Owen have now been appointed as the UK agents and too be honest I have not met anyone with any real complaints about their dealings with the factory.

Yes a buyout by LVMH could have injected a lot of cash, but too what end? The first Huayra's are now being delivered, dealers have been appointed in the USA and the waiting list is healthy. As such a niche player do they need to be any more than that??

Streetrod

Original Poster:

6,484 posts

237 months

Wednesday 25th April 2012
quotequote all
Guys if you have a spare 26 mins I surgest you watch this, this is why Pagani staying independent was such a good idea. Too much would have been lost as a part of a huge company: bow

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fz4KBh5I4WE

Justices

3,682 posts

195 months

Wednesday 25th April 2012
quotequote all
Great video, thank you for the link. I love Ferrari and Lamborghini, but companies such as Zonda and Koenigssegg still have their founder at the helm, are much more intimate and there is something very special about working with and taking charge of a car from the very man who's name is above the door.

ETA: There are some VERY nice looking Huayra's in there. The white and black/carbon finish especially.

Well worth downloading.

Keepvid.com



Edited by Justices on Wednesday 25th April 13:20

JazzyO

1,125 posts

212 months

Wednesday 25th April 2012
quotequote all
Streetrod said:
Guys if you have a spare 26 mins I surgest you watch this, this is why Pagani staying independent was such a good idea. Too much would have been lost as a part of a huge company: bow

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fz4KBh5I4WE
Nice! Looks just like when I was there (except for the cars). smile


Onno

peter450

1,650 posts

264 months

Wednesday 25th April 2012
quotequote all
Some Private Equity company paid ford 500 million for Aston, so i can see were the 200 million figure comes from

Still an over inflated price though

kbf1981

2,351 posts

231 months

Thursday 26th April 2012
quotequote all
traxx said:
a 200m valuation?
Brand value?

Future Pagani baseball caps, t-shirts, watches etc....maybe that was the idea given the buyer.

rdbrooksie

205 posts

198 months

Thursday 26th April 2012
quotequote all
Very interesting video and what a great set up!cool

LukeyLikey

855 posts

178 months

Thursday 26th April 2012
quotequote all
Really really good video. Thanks for the link. I love company stories like that. How could he sell? The company is him and his family - it would be like selling a piece of him.

He couldn't sell a part either, because how does a guy like that dance to someone else's tune? They would only want a controlling stake because the value is not in the profitability today but in the idea, philosophy and uniqueness over the next 50 years.

Like Louis Vuitton, Chanel, Ferrari or Patek Philipe 50 to 100 years ago, Pagani seems to be one of those rare businesses that makes little money to begin with but becomes an 'untouchable' brand over many years because of the purity and uniqueness of their philosophy.

Easily worth 200m Euros to smart long term minded people.

ph123

1,841 posts

249 months

Saturday 5th May 2012
quotequote all
LukeyLikey said:
Really really good video. Thanks for the link. I love company stories like that. How could he sell? The company is him and his family - it would be like selling a piece of him.

He couldn't sell a part either, because how does a guy like that dance to someone else's tune? They would only want a controlling stake because the value is not in the profitability today but in the idea, philosophy and uniqueness over the next 50 years.

Like Louis Vuitton, Chanel, Ferrari or Patek Philipe 50 to 100 years ago, Pagani seems to be one of those rare businesses that makes little money to begin with but becomes an 'untouchable' brand over many years because of the purity and uniqueness of their philosophy.

Easily worth 200m Euros to smart long term minded people.
Agree with this 100%.
Horacio's genius is far from fully recognised, and realised in actual sports cars.
His active aero trim devices on the Huayra, just fantastic in this day and age. Look forward to hearing how it manifests itself for the enthusiastic driver. We'll hear soon eneough.
And his (HP's) creativity, aspirations still have a long way to go ...
No wonder AMG Merc are well into bed ...

Justices

3,682 posts

195 months

Saturday 5th May 2012
quotequote all
So long as it doesn't go to Japan..