California v 430
Author
Discussion

mdrc

Original Poster:

446 posts

304 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
Now that California prices have reached a more reasonable level, what's the consensus on the sense of swapping a 430 for one? Are they any better a car....are they completely different? On a more practical note (as if that ever matters with a Ferrari), does the California hard top make it more usable? What's the view please?

GrahamF430

326 posts

195 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
I think many would see a natural progression from 355 > 360 > 430 > 458. This would bypass the California on the grounds that it's a bit "softer" in looks and appeal. Even if I had the money, I doubt I'd look at the California. I'll wait until I see what happens to the 458 prices over the next few years (and future values of the F430 too).

wineman02

397 posts

230 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
I would go for a Cali. The reason being that it is more practical, looks great as a spider or coupe, is more more economical and is a 2+2. I like a spirited drive but I go nowhere near the capabilities of my car and would not track it. Therefore on road performance for me would be near identical. Having got a 2 seater Ferrari and having owned a 2+2 I love the fact that in the 2+2 I could take my son, and my friend and his son out in it to Goodwood etc. It really made the whole experience a bit more special. Both look beautiful but the Cali more modern (especially the interior).

Early 430 have probably had 70-80 of their depreciation but the Calis maybe only 20-30% of theirs if that is a consideration (this is a guess BTW!). If you have that itch then why not take one out and see if you fall in love or still prefer your 430. I think Ferraris are purchased with the heart as the saying goes.

Edited by wineman02 on Tuesday 24th April 15:34

mdrc

Original Poster:

446 posts

304 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
Thanks! These are exactly the two polarised views I've had to date! The one saying the California is the more modern car and more practical and the one saying that it's the car to bypass en route to a 458! Anyone else with a casting vote maybe?!

RevHappy

1,850 posts

193 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
If you want a one car GT solution the Cali is great, if you want a supercar keep the 430.


Edited by RevHappy on Tuesday 24th April 16:00

911Thrasher

2,573 posts

230 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
+1 I'm for the natural progression: 355 360 430 458
If you want to go GT, get a proper one: 575 or 599

mdrc

Original Poster:

446 posts

304 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
How strong is the market for 575s? They do seem to hang around for a long time before selling

RevHappy

1,850 posts

193 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
Indeed a '07 599 is less than a '09 Cali

RevHappy

1,850 posts

193 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
mdrc said:
How strong is the market for 575s? They do seem to hang around for a long time before selling
I think it's a tricky price point, a good 550 is going around late £40's, 575 is late £60's then a big £40k jump to the 599.

At the £40-70 window your also into 360 and early 430's.

The big V12 GT cars with only two seats is a small market IMO.

Schnellmann

1,893 posts

235 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
wineman02 said:
I would go for a Cali. The reason being that it is more practical, looks great as a spider or coupe, is more more economical and is a 2+2. I like a spirited drive but I go nowhere near the capabilities of my car and would not track it. Therefore on road performance for me would be near identical. Having got a 2 seater Ferrari and having owned a 2+2 I love the fact that in the 2+2 I could take my son, and my friend and his son out in it to Goodwood etc. It really made the whole experience a bit more special. Both look beautiful but the Cali more modern (especially the interior).

Early 430 have probably had 70-80 of their depreciation but the Calis maybe only 20-30% of theirs if that is a consideration (this is a guess BTW!). If you have that itch then why not take one out and see if you fall in love or still prefer your 430. I think Ferraris are purchased with the heart as the saying goes.

Edited by wineman02 on Tuesday 24th April 15:34
Have you tried carrying passengers in the back of a Cali? Unless you have children without legs (or you are 3 ft 6) I am not sure it is possible. Glad to be contradicted but I was looking at a Cali last weekend and you couldnt Hav got a rizzla between the back of the front seats and the rear seats.

430 or 458 (or 599) would be my choice.

911Thrasher

2,573 posts

230 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
mdrc said:
How strong is the market for 575s? They do seem to hang around for a long time before selling
I have been looking at them closely as I really like them - manual ones tend to sell really quickly (the one for sale on PH has actaully had a deposit put on a couple days ago).

I think there is also a color factor with those cars: red are harder to churn, black ones tend to be easier.

As for price it seems that 65-70kGBP is the price to pay for a good one.

wineman02

397 posts

230 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
I understand the reasoning behind opting for a 430 for supercar performance but the Cali is not that much slower on paper. Sure around a track the 430 would kill it but if you are really really honest how often have you (the OP) taken your 430 to its limit or near to it? I am guessing that for most people it is a case of "it can" rather than "I do".

Sure the rear seats do not offer the room you might find in a 612 or FF but I am a short arse so have my seat quite forward!

In regard to the 599 - a different proposition being a V12 and not a spider.

I think the Cali is pretty much perfect for 90% of the time if being honest. It just ticks the box for most eventualities.

RevHappy

1,850 posts

193 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
wineman02 said:
I understand the reasoning behind opting for a 430 for supercar performance but the Cali is not that much slower on paper. Sure around a track the 430 would kill it but if you are really really honest how often have you (the OP) taken your 430 to its limit or near to it? I am guessing that for most people it is a case of "it can" rather than "I do".

Sure the rear seats do not offer the room you might find in a 612 or FF but I am a short arse so have my seat quite forward!

In regard to the 599 - a different proposition being a V12 and not a spider.

I think the Cali is pretty much perfect for 90% of the time if being honest. It just ticks the box for most eventualities.
The Cali is quick on paper due to the seven speed dual clutch box. You sit higher and feel less connected to the road and the car. As a do it all car it's great, but they have now added more power and an optional handling pack for those who don't just want to drive around town all day.

StuH

2,557 posts

304 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
mdrc said:
Now that California prices have reached a more reasonable level, what's the consensus on the sense of swapping a 430 for one? Are they any better a car....are they completely different? On a more practical note (as if that ever matters with a Ferrari), does the California hard top make it more usable? What's the view please?
Something I'm starting to consider myself, loved the 355 but with just the 2 seats, the Mrs and 7 year old daughter - as well as 2 nephews (6 & 8) it's really nice to be able to carry the family around so they can share the fun. Particularly as it's mostly used at weekends. I'd love a 599 or 458 but I really think a 2+2 is the way forward next time, and the Cali as it starts to come down in price makes for an appealing alternative to a 911 cab. The other options like the Masa GranCabrio are just a little TOO soft and down on performance for when I am out by myself and want to give it the beans.

Hopefully the rear seats are OK for young kids??

willy wombat

1,153 posts

179 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
I've owned both a 430 Spider and a California at different times and I think that it entirely depends on what you plan to use the car for. If Welsh (or Italian etc) mountain roads, track days etc are your main thing then the 430 is probably the car for you. If long distance touring is more your bag, or you want it as a daily driver, then it's the California. Other points - the California's gearbox is fabulous - much better than the 430. Also, don't be fooled into thinking that the California is soft. It can handle mountain roads etc really well and the noise from the exhaust when it's driven hard is great. I echo the comments of others re the rear seats being unusable - I only ever used them for luggage (and you need to if touring because with the roof down the boot is very restricted).

wineman02

397 posts

230 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
Totally agree that the Cali would not be as much fun for spirited driving as you are higher and less connected, but how often do you do that currently? If it is more than 50% of the time with early Sunday morning drives etc then I guess a 430/599 is the way to go. If less, but you want to do that occasionally and have fun but also go out touring then the Cali would be perfect.

I guess it comes down to if you are buying it for a hardcore driving machine or for a mixture of spirited driving and sharing the thrill with some touring thrown in as well.

I don't live in a city so would not be using it around town but for longer trips and into Europe. Ideally I would like both and guess the perfect modern combo is a Scud, 599 and a Cali!

RevHappy

1,850 posts

193 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
I also think it depends on what other cars you have play with? I'm currently thinking what could replace a 430. So this is an interesting thread as I've tried the Cali and was a little disapointed. The 599 is a big old girl more suited to hiting continents than an apex. The scud was great but you'd need a track to get the most out of it or save it for big trips. I might look at a 430 spider just for a change while the 458 continues to fall if another Ferrari is the best next car?

Edited by RevHappy on Tuesday 24th April 19:22

andy355

1,347 posts

269 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
having had both 430 and california, i think the cali is a much much better car. also when i was buying the cali i was strongly encouraged that way by 2 big dealerships on the basis of usability over a 599 (i prefer the looks of 599)

it really is an excellent car and whereas i went into it thinking i might be a bit disappointed its been the opposite, smiles all round. that said i will maybe sell mine as i like to have "new" cars but dont know what next - 458 is too big a jump up in price for now

willy wombat

1,153 posts

179 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
Hey, RevHappy - believe me, I can hit an apex in my 599!

RevHappy

1,850 posts

193 months

Tuesday 24th April 2012
quotequote all
willy wombat said:
Hey, RevHappy - believe me, I can hit an apex in my 599!
I don't doubt you can, but I don't think that's primary design brief. In my mind its a big power GT flagship car, it would get to the alps with ease and have a bit of fun when you got there. But a 458 would run rings around it as would a scud i imagine, it's the curse of the V12 which puts it into the game price wise.