Switch from E60 M5 to Granturismo S
Switch from E60 M5 to Granturismo S
Author
Discussion

manand38

Original Poster:

2,026 posts

237 months

Sunday 29th April 2012
quotequote all
Hi all,

has anyone made the switch from the M5 to the Maser? I know they're not really in the same bracket.

I went on an extended test drive of the Maser and really liked it.

70proof

6,158 posts

186 months

Sunday 29th April 2012
quotequote all
never warmed to the e60, so can;t see how you wouldn;t be happy with the switch TBH.... don;t get me wrong, e60 is epic in full attack mode, but e39 would be the one i would drive home every time....

manand38

Original Poster:

2,026 posts

237 months

Sunday 29th April 2012
quotequote all
Think I would miss the V10 and all that power, plus space, but the Maser would bring style and that V8 bark smile

Wish I had space for both cars..

Colossus

337 posts

245 months

Sunday 29th April 2012
quotequote all
About 6 or so years back I went from an E39 M5 to a Maser 4200 coupe and never looked back. The Bimmer is probably the best of its kind but the difference between the two in terms of soul and charisma is like going from black and white to technicolour! It is also worth noting that my Masers have all been far more reliable than any of the Bimmers I owned. Currently run a GranTurismo S and there really is plenty space in the back for adults and kids have no problem going to South of France or Italy in it, as mine can testify. I can honestly say the Maser is an incredibly well resolved package and then there is THAT sound, do it!!

manand38

Original Poster:

2,026 posts

237 months

Sunday 29th April 2012
quotequote all
How does the extended warranty system work is it similar to BMW?

w5pwr

458 posts

221 months

Sunday 29th April 2012
quotequote all
I went from E60 M5 to. GTS via a 997 Turbo......

Depends what you are looking for in the car, gearbox and fuel consumption are very similar to the M5 but you cannot compare the handling or power or the media functionality to the M5.

But when it comes to the sound the GTS is in a league of its own!


Most people do not recognise an M5 from a 520, the GTS gets a lot of attention , a lot of people have not seen one before and they are not sure what it is......

Trellis

590 posts

270 months

Monday 30th April 2012
quotequote all
Colossus said:
About 6 or so years back I went from an E39 M5 to a Maser 4200 coupe and never looked back. The Bimmer is probably the best of its kind but the difference between the two in terms of soul and charisma is like going from black and white to technicolour! It is also worth noting that my Masers have all been far more reliable than any of the Bimmers I owned. Currently run a GranTurismo S and there really is plenty space in the back for adults and kids have no problem going to South of France or Italy in it, as mine can testify. I can honestly say the Maser is an incredibly well resolved package and then there is THAT sound, do it!!
I'm ex E39 M5 (serial addict) and currently E46 M3, and am considering 4200 Coupe next myself. Have heard the sound of the Maser - and of course LOVE it, but am wary of the Top Gear reviews SLATING the gearbox and handling. Handling is what makes the E39 M5 - and I'm wary that I'll fall for a 4200 on a test drive for its superb interior and glorious sound, but once I've had it for a week and truly tested it, I'll be disappointed with what TG point out.

Is it just the usual TG having to be controversial?

Does the 4200 really handle poorly??

I'm also wary of the servicing specialists caning you just for the badge. Are there genuinely interested specialists who will try to help customers keep costs sensible?

any thoughts - gratefully received!


Fantuzzi

3,297 posts

177 months

Monday 30th April 2012
quotequote all
Trellis said:
I'm ex E39 M5 (serial addict) and currently E46 M3, and am considering 4200 Coupe next myself. Have heard the sound of the Maser - and of course LOVE it, but am wary of the Top Gear reviews SLATING the gearbox and handling. Handling is what makes the E39 M5 - and I'm wary that I'll fall for a 4200 on a test drive for its superb interior and glorious sound, but once I've had it for a week and truly tested it, I'll be disappointed with what TG point out.

Is it just the usual TG having to be controversial?

Does the 4200 really handle poorly??

I'm also wary of the servicing specialists caning you just for the badge. Are there genuinely interested specialists who will try to help customers keep costs sensible?

any thoughts - gratefully received!
Not so sure about the 4200, but the Gransport is meant to be amazing,

http://www.evo.co.uk/carreviews/cargrouptests/5077...

http://www.evo.co.uk/carreviews/cargrouptests/3059...
It seems to be an 'almost' car

Pork

9,455 posts

265 months

Monday 30th April 2012
quotequote all
Trellis said:
some intersting questions
I've run an E39 M5 and two E46's and now have a GranSport (essentially, the last 4200 with a little nip/tuck) so will hopfully be able to answere your questions, in some way.

The views on TG, IIRC, were of a relatively early 4200 (I think 2003 or something). Since then, the model has undergone some revisions, one of which is updates to the gearbox. While its probably not as accomplished as the SMG (is your M3 SMG?), its very similar and as long as you conisder its not an auto and drive it accordingly, it's a great bit of kit. Interstingly, in the SMG I think they advise to slightly lift off....in the Maserati, they say to keep your clog in it!

I still get the occasional change wrong which means its not perfectly smooth, but generally speaking, its great, particularly when pressing on. The blip on change down is just superb smile

In terms of the handling, again, I think it go improved as the model evolved. While the GS is thought by many to be a bit too extreme, the last of the 42's (from around late 2005 on) are considered to be about as good as the 42 got by many in the know.

In terms of specialist, there are a few around. I use Bill McGraths and like them. I've heard good things about many others too - Emblem on the south coast, Autoshield in Manchester and many more.

If you're keen, you'd do well to spend a few hours on maseratiforum.co.uk and sportsmaserati.co.uk - LOADS of info on there with many poeple have all the questions you have (or will have! smile).

Happy shopping.

Trellis

590 posts

270 months

Monday 30th April 2012
quotequote all
thanks Pork and Fantuzzi for those pointers - the EVO review your linked to on the original 42 seems pretty damning and in line with TG - ! I'll do more research elsewhere on the forums mentioned and praps get hands on with one after....

apologies to OP - not trying to hijack!

cheerssmile

EC2

1,547 posts

284 months

Monday 30th April 2012
quotequote all
The 2005 facelift made the 4200 a really wonderful car. Remember too that you could have the 4200 as a three pedal manual and not just automated clutch CC model.

Sexual Chocolate

1,583 posts

175 months

Tuesday 1st May 2012
quotequote all
Had both. My conclusion would be if you could stick E60 M5 running gear in a masser then you would have a pretty much perfect car.

Trellis

590 posts

270 months

Tuesday 1st May 2012
quotequote all
The manual versions are pretty rare I see. I'm not against flappy paddles at all if they do a good job. Been in an F360 with one and loved it.

I'll check out the post 05 facelift market.....

Colossus

337 posts

245 months

Tuesday 1st May 2012
quotequote all
I agree with your comments about the E39 M5 and the way it handles, a car that size should really not be that easy to throw around and slide, it almost defies physics. BUT, it lacks soul. It is probably one of the most complete cars I have owned but after nearly 4 years I wanted something different and once I had the Maser I couldn't understand why I hadn't made the change sooner.

Sure the 4200 is not the last word in suspension refinement, but actually it does not do a bad job. Mine was a 2003 car and as has been said they were improved over the years but unless you are looking for the last word in handling, for about 90% of the driving you will do, they are great fun. They can get a little ragged in exremis and crash a bit over badly pock marked roads but otherwise they offer so much more involvement and character than the M5. I think that the problem with many of the tests magazines do is that they are not really focused on an overall ownership experience, but more about how the cars behave at the limit and when being at 10/10ths, which is not how most of us drive our cars most of the time. Is a contemporary 911 a better car than the 4200, objectively it probably is, but subjectively I would take the Maser every single time.

Also depending on what the car would be used for it may be worth trying to look for a manual 4200. Although not as common as the CC 'box it was a good unit that someth=imes suffered from being poorly adjusted, which is a 10 minute job that a specialist mechanic could easily do. The CC box was a little crude in the way it operated and things like 3 point turn and reversing were a real challenge for the system and resulted in much slipping of clutch. The manual on the other hand was a satisfying change and I believe uses the same Getrag box as found in the E39 M5. If all you will be doing is country lane blasts and motorway cruising, the CC may be fine but it is probably worth trying both.

The 4200s really are great cars but then again the GranTurismo S is a quantum leap on from these cars and is for me just about the perfect car! Happy hunting!


Trellis

590 posts

270 months

Tuesday 1st May 2012
quotequote all
Colossus said:
I agree with your comments about the E39 M5 and the way it handles, a car that size should really not be that easy to throw around and slide, it almost defies physics. BUT, it lacks soul. It is probably one of the most complete cars I have owned but after nearly 4 years I wanted something different and once I had the Maser I couldn't understand why I hadn't made the change sooner.

I really relate to this, the M5 is clinical and hugely capable, but I LOVE the sound the 4200 makes on the youtube clips I've seen, and the interior is beautiful. TBH I've only once heard a Maser at tilt in the flesh and that was a very recent car - a Gran Tourismo and gorgeously out of my reach!

Sure the 4200 is not the last word in suspension refinement, but actually it does not do a bad job. Mine was a 2003 car and as has been said they were improved over the years but unless you are looking for the last word in handling, for about 90% of the driving you will do, they are great fun. They can get a little ragged in exremis and crash a bit over badly pock marked roads but otherwise they offer so much more involvement and character than the M5. I think that the problem with many of the tests magazines do is that they are not really focused on an overall ownership experience, but more about how the cars behave at the limit and when being at 10/10ths, which is not how most of us drive our cars most of the time. Is a contemporary 911 a better car than the 4200, objectively it probably is, but subjectively I would take the Maser every single time.

Again - makes sense to me, I dont drive at 10/10ths - I'm not the Stig. But I have been used to cars as capable as the M3 and M5 for the past 10 years and partly 'because' I'm not the Stig, I guess I fear a car which is incapable of supporting a competent but not talented driver. Put another way, I know the M3/M5 flatter me, whereas something 'exotic' like a Maser might not. I do think you've got a good point about the tests though.

Also depending on what the car would be used for it may be worth trying to look for a manual 4200. Although not as common as the CC 'box it was a good unit that someth=imes suffered from being poorly adjusted, which is a 10 minute job that a specialist mechanic could easily do. The CC box was a little crude in the way it operated and things like 3 point turn and reversing were a real challenge for the system and resulted in much slipping of clutch. The manual on the other hand was a satisfying change and I believe uses the same Getrag box as found in the E39 M5. If all you will be doing is country lane blasts and motorway cruising, the CC may be fine but it is probably worth trying both.

it wouldnt be a daily driver - more a weekend toy but also for the commute on sunny days/when I was in the mood. The commute is a 10 mile country lane blast, followed by 8 miles on wide A roads. At weekends, I'd be out mainly for fun, I wouldnt spend much time in stop start city traffic. Using the getrag box is somewhat reassuring, I had fears it was some very low volume specialist box that was underengineered and cost a fortune to fix

The 4200s really are great cars but then again the GranTurismo S is a quantum leap on from these cars and is for me just about the perfect car! Happy hunting!

thanks! :-)