Gallardo v 430
Author
Discussion

mdrc

Original Poster:

446 posts

304 months

Monday 7th May 2012
quotequote all
I've recently been considering swapping my 430 for a California and decided against based on views expressed here.......I'm waiting for 458 prices to come down and wanted to try something else in the meantime......so comparing a 430F1 Spider against a Gallardo E-gear Spider.........what's the verdict please?

I haven't yet driven a Gallardo and never owned a Lambo.....had Ferraris for the last 10 years.....oh and I'm 6-2 .... Is height and driving position an issue please?

gbrownlow

4,843 posts

201 months

Monday 7th May 2012
quotequote all
Simples - having driven both of them extensively stick with the F430 IMHO .

Can't see there being anything to be gained by making that change unless you just fancy a change of scenery and an associated cost to change of £20k with the buying and selling premiums

At the end of the day its personal preference. I have a F430 F1 spider my mate has a Lambo ( he is a pussy )but personally I cant see there be £20k value/difference changing either way.

Stick with what you have got unless you have money to burn or you have really found the car of your dreams.

Made this type of mistake once before by fancying a change and it cost me £40k all in and put me back a couple of years


Mclelland77

114 posts

203 months

Monday 7th May 2012
quotequote all
I think it's fair to say the 430 is the 'better' drivers car but for sheer fun nothing comes close to a Gallardo Spyder, period. It's a bit of a clown car but as such has a sense of humour about it which the British public get and I've had nothing but positive reactions whilst driving mine. Being 6'5" is a bit of a squeeze with the roof up for me although doable and some people don't like the slightly off set pedals but it really isn't an issue to be honest in the e-gear, don't get a manual as you won't have anywhere for your left leg to go! obviously I'm biased as I have one and it was my dream to get one for many years but even after a year of ownership it's still the greatest pleasure to drive and never fails to give me the James may 'fizz' get one I'm confident you'll love it.

caraddict

1,092 posts

175 months

Monday 7th May 2012
quotequote all
Mclelland77 said:
I think it's fair to say the 430 is the 'better' drivers car but for sheer fun nothing comes close to a Gallardo Spyder, period. It's a bit of a clown car but as such has a sense of humour about it which the British public get and I've had nothing but positive reactions whilst driving mine. Being 6'5" is a bit of a squeeze with the roof up for me although doable and some people don't like the slightly off set pedals but it really isn't an issue to be honest in the e-gear, don't get a manual as you won't have anywhere for your left leg to go! obviously I'm biased as I have one and it was my dream to get one for many years but even after a year of ownership it's still the greatest pleasure to drive and never fails to give me the James may 'fizz' get one I'm confident you'll love it.
Have you ever compared it to a regular pre-facelift Gallardo? It seems owners are far more excited with their Spyders than their coupe sisters.

GrahamF430

326 posts

195 months

Monday 7th May 2012
quotequote all
Biased, by then I had the same choice too. F430 F1 gearbox is much more refined, in my opinion.

Mclelland77

114 posts

203 months

Monday 7th May 2012
quotequote all
caraddict said:
Have you ever compared it to a regular pre-facelift Gallardo? It seems owners are far more excited with their Spyders than their coupe sisters.
Afraid not although I'm sure you're aware there's a few mechanical improvements between a pre '06 car and later spyder's/coupes but I would say for me the cars just more fun without a roof, it's that simple.

franki68

11,710 posts

252 months

Monday 7th May 2012
quotequote all
surely we should have sticky on this subject so often does it come up ?

Just drive one and make your own mind up,you will get 50% of people telling you the 430 is better,and 50% saying the gallardo.

If you like the way a ferrari steers you probably wont like the lambo ,but there is no right or wrong,I bought the car that made me smile more after a lenghty comparison of the 2 cars you are talking about.

Mclelland77

114 posts

203 months

Monday 7th May 2012
quotequote all
franki68 said:
surely we should have sticky on this subject so often does it come up ?

Just drive one and make your own mind up,you will get 50% of people telling you the 430 is better,and 50% saying the gallardo.


If you like the way a ferrari steers you probably wont like the lambo ,but there is no right or wrong,I bought the car that made me smile more after a lenghty comparison of the 2 cars you are talking about.
He's right, Uh-matt can also give good advice between the 2 cars but at the end of the day we all want different things at different times from cars so there is no definitive answer although Gallardos are more fun ;-)


Edited by Mclelland77 on Monday 7th May 13:40

GALLARDOGUY

8,160 posts

250 months

Monday 7th May 2012
quotequote all
The gallardo spyder (especially the LP560/4 version) is one of the best looking and designed convertibles ever.

The 430 is clumsy and ill resolved in comparison.

I was the same as the OP, always had Ferrari's but I thought the 430 was simply ugly, so went to Lamborghini and do not regret it for a moment.

gbrownlow

4,843 posts

201 months

Monday 7th May 2012
quotequote all
GALLARDOGUY said:
The gallardo spyder (especially the LP560/4 version) is one of the best looking and designed convertibles ever.

The 430 is clumsy and ill resolved in comparison.

I was the same as the OP, always had Ferrari's but I thought the 430 was simply ugly, so went to Lamborghini and do not regret it for a moment.
Better the car performs well and makes the guy good looking at the same time than the other way round ;-)

GALLARDOGUY

8,160 posts

250 months

Monday 7th May 2012
quotequote all
Well my LP560 has 70 BHP more than a 430 so it performs just fine thanks.

UH-Matt

2,173 posts

271 months

Monday 7th May 2012
quotequote all
Covered a million times but I moved from a 2007 Gallardo Spyder E-gear to a 2007 F430 F1 (coupe) and wouldn't go back. The 430 is ahead of the Gallardo and mile more fun if you like to drive. However if you can stretch to an LP560 then I suspect the opinion would differ (as Lp560 is quite a bit ahead of the older Gallardo in my book).

Edit: Worth adding I went from a G Spyder to a 430 Coupe because although I do like convertibles I think the 430 in convertible form is FUGLY, lines all ruined compared to coupe but G gets away with it far better!

Edited by UH-Matt on Monday 7th May 16:43

gbrownlow

4,843 posts

201 months

Monday 7th May 2012
quotequote all
UH-Matt said:
Covered a million times but I moved from a 2007 Gallardo Spyder E-gear to a 2007 F430 F1 (coupe) and wouldn't go back. The 430 is ahead of the Gallardo and mile more fun if you like to drive. However if you can stretch to an LP560 then I suspect the opinion would differ (as Lp560 is quite a bit ahead of the older Gallardo in my book).

Edit: Worth adding I went from a G Spyder to a 430 Coupe because although I do like convertibles I think the 430 in convertible form is FUGLY, lines all ruined compared to coupe but G gets away with it far better!

Edited by UH-Matt on Monday 7th May 16:43
Beauty is in the eye of the beholder !

Never had anyone say my spider is fugly with either the roof down or up.

As Clarkson said maybe convertibles don't suit old, fat and bald guys lol

caraddict

1,092 posts

175 months

Monday 7th May 2012
quotequote all
Mclelland77 said:
caraddict said:
Have you ever compared it to a regular pre-facelift Gallardo? It seems owners are far more excited with their Spyders than their coupe sisters.
Afraid not although I'm sure you're aware there's a few mechanical improvements between a pre '06 car and later spyder's/coupes but I would say for me the cars just more fun without a roof, it's that simple.
Okey, I'm a Ferrari guy and not that into Lamborghinis (although I adore the Diablo, the LP560 and the Aventador). I thought the mechanical improvements happened with the Gallardo facelift.

I don't like the pre-facelift Gallardo, but the LP560 is truly gorgeous in both coupe and roadster form!

PS. I wouldn't call the F430 Spider beautiful, but it's still better looking than 99% of the cars on the road...

UH-Matt

2,173 posts

271 months

Monday 7th May 2012
quotequote all
gbrownlow said:
UH-Matt said:
Covered a million times but I moved from a 2007 Gallardo Spyder E-gear to a 2007 F430 F1 (coupe) and wouldn't go back. The 430 is ahead of the Gallardo and mile more fun if you like to drive. However if you can stretch to an LP560 then I suspect the opinion would differ (as Lp560 is quite a bit ahead of the older Gallardo in my book).

Edit: Worth adding I went from a G Spyder to a 430 Coupe because although I do like convertibles I think the 430 in convertible form is FUGLY, lines all ruined compared to coupe but G gets away with it far better!

Edited by UH-Matt on Monday 7th May 16:43
Beauty is in the eye of the beholder !

Never had anyone say my spider is fugly with either the roof down or up.

As Clarkson said maybe convertibles don't suit old, fat and bald guys lol
I am probably younger than you, unfortunately definitely getting a little bald and fat though!

Either way I do like convertibles on the right car, but for me the 430 lines get lost in the Spider. The Gallardo executes it far better IMHO.


Diamond blue

3,288 posts

231 months

Monday 7th May 2012
quotequote all
GALLARDOGUY said:
The gallardo spyder (especially the LP560/4 version) is one of the best looking and designed convertibles ever.

The 430 is clumsy and ill resolved in comparison.

I was the same as the OP, always had Ferrari's but I thought the 430 was simply ugly, so went to Lamborghini and do not regret it for a moment.
Quite understand what your getting at re the folding roof but the problem I had with the Gallardo Spyder is the laughable lack of storage space. Roof folds away neatly but takes all the space behind the seats (Unlike the 430 ) and the luggage compartment is tiny.Half the size of a 430. A result of the 4wd no doubt.
I cancelled my interest in it originally because that lack makes it a weekend toy really and limits its potential use.
Cant comment re driving it but opinion is split pretty much 50:50 it seems.

gbrownlow

4,843 posts

201 months

Monday 7th May 2012
quotequote all
UH-Matt said:
I am probably younger than you, unfortunately definitely getting a little bald and fat though!
Thats not good if you are only in your twenties ????

Best you sell the car and invest it in a hair transplant and a personal trainer lol

Anyway back to the subject and as I have said before I can't see circa £20k difference in the 2 cars in question whichever way you were going to change. From a financial point alone it does not really make any sense.

If someone was to give me £20k cash I would swap for an equivalent Gallardo spider

UH-Matt

2,173 posts

271 months

Monday 7th May 2012
quotequote all
gbrownlow said:
UH-Matt said:
I am probably younger than you, unfortunately definitely getting a little bald and fat though!
Thats not good if you are only in your twenties ????

Best you sell the car and invest it in a hair transplant and a personal trainer lol

Anyway back to the subject and as I have said before I can't see circa £20k difference in the 2 cars in question whichever way you were going to change. From a financial point alone it does not really make any sense.

If someone was to give me £20k cash I would swap for an equivalent Gallardo spider
29 and been going bald for years mate wink

Mclelland77

114 posts

203 months

Tuesday 8th May 2012
quotequote all
Just realised your local(ish) to me so if you fancy a go in a Gallardo Spyder drop me a line as always happy to help a fellow pistonheader.

franki68

11,710 posts

252 months

Tuesday 8th May 2012
quotequote all
gbrownlow said:
Thats not good if you are only in your twenties ????

Best you sell the car and invest it in a hair transplant and a personal trainer lol

Anyway back to the subject and as I have said before I can't see circa £20k difference in the 2 cars in question whichever way you were going to change. From a financial point alone it does not really make any sense.

If someone was to give me £20k cash I would swap for an equivalent Gallardo spider
But financial common sense isn't something to worry about when buying a super car,otherwise we'd all be running round in cars that do 70mpg as opposed to 7mpg.