Italian tax inspectors = Flood of exotica on the market?
Italian tax inspectors = Flood of exotica on the market?
Author
Discussion

Justices

Original Poster:

3,682 posts

195 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
How dare you not be able to have 30 bank accounts, undeclared property and not be able to put your Ferrari in your mother's name!! wink

http://news.yahoo.com/ferrari-crackdown-italy-decl...

paulqv

3,124 posts

226 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
Tax evasion cripples Greece/italy/spain. Been going on for years. I always worried when people over in these countries told me how smart they were in never paying tax or much tax. it's endemic and needs root and branch reform including prosecuting all the corrupt tax inspectors who for years have been getting bribed.

It makes you glad to live here. At least our civil servants are almost completely honest and above corruption. Likewise our politicians. i know i will get slated and the piss taken out of me for that, but is my view

Paul

Cheib

25,484 posts

206 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
paulqv said:
Tax evasion cripples Greece/italy/spain. Been going on for years. I always worried when people over in these countries told me how smart they were in never paying tax or much tax. it's endemic and needs root and branch reform including prosecuting all the corrupt tax inspectors who for years have been getting bribed.

It makes you glad to live here. At least our civil servants are almost completely honest and above corruption. Likewise our politicians. i know i will get slated and the piss taken out of me for that, but is my view

Paul
This. The tax take as a % of GDP in the likes of Greece is worse than many Emerging Market economies....it's a national sport in these countries. I have worked in finance for the last twenty years and have worked conistently through that period with people of all European nationalities...if there is one nationality that has stood out for doing dodgy deals and sailing close to the wind it's the Italians.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/financialcrisis...

Certainly before the Celtic Tiger Ireland had a massive black economy too and probably does again now. Given how corrupt the Catholic church ahs been over time it's perhaps not a coincidence that Italy, Spain and Irealand are all Catholic countries.

Streetrod

6,484 posts

237 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
The party's over guys, welcome to the real world. Ah well on the plus side imported LHD Ferrari's and Lambo's should be a steal in the foreseeable future

Enricogto

646 posts

176 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
old story with a lot of loopholes!
Anyway this rush to find cheaters from the car they drive, one of the few assets where you can't evade, is only sensationalistic as everything could be done more quietly simply by running two querys on the IRS databases.
Paul, I agree, but how much of your income every year goes into taxes? How would you rate the services you recive back from state/municipality?
Answer those simple questions and you'll find why whe are in this situation.
I frankly don't get the comment regarding italian banks (I work in this sector), but it seems to me we are for sure not the worst, at least in this sector.

Enrico

kryten22uk

2,350 posts

262 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
"Many are trying to sell their luxury cars but they can't get the cost they paid for them," he said.

Poor little poppets! Fancy not being able to sell your car for what you bought it for. Italy sounds awful...

paulqv

3,124 posts

226 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
Enricogto said:
Paul, I agree, but how much of your income every year goes into taxes? How would you rate the services you recive back from state/municipality?
Answer those simple questions and you'll find why whe are in this situation.
I frankly don't get the comment regarding italian banks (I work in this sector), but it seems to me we are for sure not the worst, at least in this sector.

Enrico
In direct taxes about 30% average and indirect about another 20%. In the UK we had some very good analysis of this recently. The top 10% pay most taxes in direct eg income tax and VAT and in indirect eg fuel duty and VAT etc by some significant margin. The lower 20% are usually net non payers, ie they recieve more from the state than they give in.
If we want a civilised society where no one starves or is deprived of help then we all need to pay our taxes however much we don't like doing so!
What i object to is paying tax here to have people in other countires lifestyle funded. EG Paying pensions in Greece, which simply are not avaialable here, nor economically or socially viable. Sadly tax payers never have any real choice as to what their taxes are used for, excpet at Election time and even then the choices are between the frying pan and the fire!

Please vote for me to become the benevolent dictator of this country!

Enricogto

646 posts

176 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
kryten22uk said:
"Many are trying to sell their luxury cars but they can't get the cost they paid for them," he said.

Poor little poppets! Fancy not being able to sell your car for what you bought it for. Italy sounds awful...
Badly written article.
No one expects to sell a used good for the price he bought it new, but actually dealers and private buyers are offering silly money because the recent belt tightening on car taxes that is affecting both cheaters (no problem) but also people who regularly pay taxes.

I'll give you my example:
I'm on a perm contract with a major italian bank, I own my house with no mortgage on top, no other debts and own a Z4M. The bank pays taxes for me in the form of an amount hold back from my montly payroll. I have cash in the bank.
I'd like to buy another car (I'm on PH in the end!) but I won't because if I own a powerful car (with the Z I'm already at the limit) then the IRS believe that I must spend X on holidays, Y on clothes.... and that regularly don't add up to your actual income. Once the difference between what you declared and what they believe you should earn to have that lifestyle is larger than 20% you are fined (even if you clearly can't cheat) fro twice the difference between real and projected income, applying the higher tax bracket.
To add insult to injury, the sistem ignore completely spending and saving propension, and for example this year I buy a new 200K £ Ferrari and declare it (impossible not to) then next year I must again include that 200K in my income, thus ignoring completely depreciation.....
Now, fancy to come here for living? shout

Enrico

Edited by Enricogto on Wednesday 23 May 11:34

Enricogto

646 posts

176 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
paulqv said:
In direct taxes about 30% average and indirect about another 20%. In the UK we had some very good analysis of this recently. The top 10% pay most taxes in direct eg income tax and VAT and in indirect eg fuel duty and VAT etc by some significant margin. The lower 20% are usually net non payers, ie they recieve more from the state than they give in.
If we want a civilised society where no one starves or is deprived of help then we all need to pay our taxes however much we don't like doing so!
What i object to is paying tax here to have people in other countires lifestyle funded. EG Paying pensions in Greece, which simply are not avaialable here, nor economically or socially viable. Sadly tax payers never have any real choice as to what their taxes are used for, excpet at Election time and even then the choices are between the frying pan and the fire!

Please vote for me to become the benevolent dictator of this country!
You have my vote if you find me a way to live in Scotland. And if you make tax exempt any sport car and 100 octane fuel (As per any PHers presidential election program)!
woohoo

paulqv

3,124 posts

226 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
Enricogto said:
You have my vote if you find me a way to live in Scotland. And if you make tax exempt any sport car and 100 octane fuel (As per any PHers presidential election program)!
woohoo
Enrico!

you have written my election manifesto for me!

Ciao

Paulo

AJSG

327 posts

218 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
Enricogto said:
Now, fancy to come here for living? shout
Or how aboout when we get a bill from Microsoft Ireland, considered grey list in Italy so the Italian entity has to pay a EUR 50 handling fee to the accountant for the special submission.

I have been trying to convice the staff of our tiny office in Ferrara to move here, but fiscally its an absolute nightmare. Even if they moved but left any kind of asset in their name in Italy they would have a huge yearly accountancy burden.

For me Italy is closed for business.

Enricogto

646 posts

176 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
AJSG said:
Or how aboout when we get a bill from Microsoft Ireland, considered grey list in Italy so the Italian entity has to pay a EUR 50 handling fee to the accountant for the special submission.

I have been trying to convice the staff of our tiny office in Ferrara to move here, but fiscally its an absolute nightmare. Even if they moved but left any kind of asset in their name in Italy they would have a huge yearly accountancy burden.

For me Italy is closed for business.
AJSG,

tell me what you do and if I'm able to work, I'll move in less than a blink!

AJSG

327 posts

218 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
Enricogto said:
tell me what you do and if I'm able to work, I'll move in less than a blink!
Very hard to move nowadays...unless you can leave nothing behind or have never paid taxes. Our old economist had to sell (actually sell) everything to het grandmother and she still in fully "white".

We are always recruiting, currently we need high level porogramers with experience in writing to exchanges....and we need salespeople, lots of salespeople...

Enricogto

646 posts

176 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
AJSG said:
Very hard to move nowadays...unless you can leave nothing behind or have never paid taxes. Our old economist had to sell (actually sell) everything to het grandmother and she still in fully "white".

We are always recruiting, currently we need high level porogramers with experience in writing to exchanges....and we need salespeople, lots of salespeople...
Mmmh I'm more of a financial topics background, mainly Big4 and market risk management.... :-(

AJSG

327 posts

218 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
Enricogto said:
Mmmh I'm more of a financial topics background, mainly Big4 and market risk management.... :-(
We write, fit, and execute all our own models...all listed.

Kilsoj

163 posts

194 months

Wednesday 23rd May 2012
quotequote all
Cheib said:
Given how corrupt the Catholic church ahs been over time it's perhaps not a coincidence that Italy, Spain and Irealand are all Catholic countries.
F me that's the biggest pile of rubbish I have heard.....you don't have to be catholic to be corrupt but it helps!

JazzyO

1,125 posts

212 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
I love Italy, have done since I was 2 and I was seriously considering buying a house there a year or so ago. I'm very glad I didn't. Unless things change radically (and why would they?), it seems it is best to avoid owning any asset in Italy.


Onno

Cheib

25,484 posts

206 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
Kilsoj said:
Cheib said:
Given how corrupt the Catholic church ahs been over time it's perhaps not a coincidence that Italy, Spain and Irealand are all Catholic countries.
F me that's the biggest pile of rubbish I have heard.....you don't have to be catholic to be corrupt but it helps!
Why ? The Catholic Church has been rife with corruption for many years and certainly in these countries has been increedibly powerful. The Catholic church pretty much ran Ireland until the 50's or 60's and some might say it still does! When you have an institution that has been as powerful as the Catholoc church and as corrupt as the Catholic church it makes sense that would permeate throughout society.

AJSG

327 posts

218 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
JazzyO said:
Unless things change radically (and why would they?), it seems it is best to avoid owning any asset in Italy.
As you said nothing will change...I found the property ownership stories' success tends to rely on you (the owner) having some very good local contacts. Even then its not guaranteed.

I have a small flat there, I started life as a Civil Engineer, local friends of mine a Civil Engineers...yet it took me 5 years to redecorate/redevelop. Granted the village is UNESCO protected and all that rubbish...but even then the locals are so lazy and dishonest that I ended up using 3 architects and 5 building companies.

Enricogto

646 posts

176 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
AJSG said:
JazzyO said:
Unless things change radically (and why would they?), it seems it is best to avoid owning any asset in Italy.
As you said nothing will change...I found the property ownership stories' success tends to rely on you (the owner) having some very good local contacts. Even then its not guaranteed.

I have a small flat there, I started life as a Civil Engineer, local friends of mine a Civil Engineers...yet it took me 5 years to redecorate/redevelop. Granted the village is UNESCO protected and all that rubbish...but even then the locals are so lazy and dishonest that I ended up using 3 architects and 5 building companies.
Wait wait wait!
I can understand your horror stories and to some extent even agree.
But I believe the same applies, to any country, maybe with slightly different percentages.
What really affects doing business is bureaucracy, if overhauling a flat even in an UNESCO site, but with the correct permission to build is up to public sector and the fact that you need every kind of permit even to choose wich colour paint the walls. This and the fact that sometimes people think that cheating on foreigners is right and makes you cooler, not understanding that they are eliminating potential future clients and affecting badly their country's perception. And that, to me that i'm honest, drives me literally crazy.
So, sorry in advance for my stupid co-nationals.

Enrico