Is the Enzo or CGT the spiritual successor to the F50?
Is the Enzo or CGT the spiritual successor to the F50?
Author
Discussion

Schnellmann

Original Poster:

1,893 posts

235 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
I know the CGT is a Porsche, but in terms of concept is the CGT closer to the F50 than the Enzo? CGT and F50 both used motorsport derived engines that were unique to the car and not used elsewhere in the respective P/F ranges, both were cabriolets, both manual and both without any real driver aids nor electronics and different suspension/throttle modes.

The driving experience of the F50 and CGT might therefore be closer. Unfortunately, I've not had the opportunity to drive any of the three cars so can't make this ultimate comparison. Perhaps someone that has could comment?

TIGA84

5,613 posts

262 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
Enzo closer in terms of engine, CGT was literally a one off all round, can't think of a V10 in any Porsche motorsport although not sure of derivatives engine wise Styling, yes both convertible and not from anything in the range so possibly.

If anything, if you want to have motorsport pretentions, MC12? Seems to have similarities moreso than the enzo/cgt.

I may be talking codswallop here though.

ETA - I have driven none of the above btw, so an armchair view at best.

neil-f

1,647 posts

238 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
CGT engine was never used by Porsche in motorsport as far as I know but someone might prove me wrong biggrin

TonyHetherington

32,091 posts

281 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
Don't forget that there were many "motorsport derived" (be it marketing or actual) aspects of the Enzo. When you take one apart it's a race car through and through. Everything from the aerodynamics (the floor is fabulous) to the gearbox, to the suspension, to the carbon tub etc. etc.

Schnellmann

Original Poster:

1,893 posts

235 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
neil-f said:
CGT engine was never used by Porsche in motorsport as far as I know but someone might prove me wrong biggrin
The 10-cylinder was not used in motorsport but I believe it was originally developed for that purpose and later used (no doubt with lots of changes) for the CGT. I just copied this from the Wiki entry for the CGT:

"The development of the Carrera GT can be traced back to the 911 GT1 and LMP1-98 racing cars. Due in part to the FIA and ACO rule changes in 1998, both designs had ended. Porsche at the time had planned on a new Le Mans prototype for 1999. The car was initially intended to use a turbocharged flat-6, but was later redesigned to use a new V10 engine, pushing the project back to planned completion in 2000. The V10 was a unit secretly built by Porsche for the Footwork Formula One team in 1992, but later shelved. The engine was resurrected for the Le Mans prototype and increased in size to 5.7 litres."

chevronb37

6,472 posts

217 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
neil-f said:
CGT engine was never used by Porsche in motorsport as far as I know but someone might prove me wrong biggrin
The engine is said to be derived from the stillborn LMP1 project. I'm not aware of it ever being used in a race car subsequently.

supersport

4,646 posts

258 months

Thursday 24th May 2012
quotequote all
chevronb37 said:
neil-f said:
CGT engine was never used by Porsche in motorsport as far as I know but someone might prove me wrong biggrin
The engine is said to be derived from the stillborn LMP1 project. I'm not aware of it ever being used in a race car subsequently.
That's because it hasn't been. Currently only the 911 is built as a race car, and the LMP2 RS Spyder used a V8 soon to appear in the 918.

Sadly the good old days when Porsche built more race car models than road car is long gone, but roll on 2014 when the LMP1 should breath again woohoo

Murcielago_Boy

2,014 posts

270 months

Friday 25th May 2012
quotequote all
456MGT on here has both the F50 and the Carrera GT. I've driven his cars back to back and driven the Enzo and I would say:
SPEAK TO HIM! smile

- Enzo is a stradale on steroids and further away from the F50's driver involvement than the CGT.
- Which means CGT is not so much the spiritual successor as Porsche's own F50 with Enzo-level performance
- The F50 is a much more satisfying car to drive than the Enzo. Much, much more. And more bespoke...The Enzo had a more or less a strad gearbox, strad brakes, the 599's V12 (although the 599 came out later).. It's not really that "bespoke" - whereas there's more or less nothing in the F50 (apart from the gearbox maybe?) which found it's way onto any other Ferrari.. which is VERY similar to the Carrera GT.
- the Carrera GT is probably a better car than the Enzo and is definitely better made.

ETA: This might be useful:
http://pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&t...

Edited by Murcielago_Boy on Friday 25th May 13:13

Schnellmann

Original Poster:

1,893 posts

235 months

Friday 25th May 2012
quotequote all
Murcielago_Boy said:
456MGT on here has both the F50 and the Carrera GT. I've driven his cars back to back and driven the Enzo and I would say:
SPEAK TO HIM! smile

- Enzo is a stradale on steroids and further away from the F50's driver involvement than the CGT.
- Which means CGT is not so much the spiritual successor as Porsche's own F50 with Enzo-level performance
- The F50 is a much more satisfying car to drive than the Enzo. Much, much more. And more bespoke...The Enzo had a more or less a strad gearbox, strad brakes, the 599's V12 (although the 599 came out later).. It's not really that "bespoke" - whereas there's more or less nothing in the F50 (apart from the gearbox maybe?) which found it's way onto any other Ferrari.. which is VERY similar to the Carrera GT.
- the Carrera GT is probably a better car than the Enzo and is definitely better made.

ETA: This might be useful:
http://pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&t...

Edited by Murcielago_Boy on Friday 25th May 13:13
Thanks. Those were my suspicions when I posted. Thanks also for the link as that is a great thread. Having an F50 and a CGT really is having your cake and eating it!

dmcars123

23 posts

174 months

Friday 25th May 2012
quotequote all
I see where your coming frm with F50 and CGT.

They are similar in lots of respects such as being manual and with removable roof sections.

The styling is also more alike than the enzo which is far more angular and aggressive than the F50 and CGT.

Also the prices of F50 (£450K) CGT (£310) are much closer thann an Enzo (£800k).

However obviously the technical design of the F50 and Enzo are far more similar. V12 engine and a fair few similar/shared components.

I think a CGT is the last of a certain breed of supercars (manual etc) whereas the Enzo is probably the first of the new breed of super/hyper cars. Which are far more technical. Even though they were built at the same time.

DM