Challenge Stradale - 2nd opinion
Challenge Stradale - 2nd opinion
Author
Discussion

Schnellmann

Original Poster:

1,893 posts

235 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
I think I have had the CS about 2 months now, although what with bad weather, the car spending 2 weeks in the garage for repairs and finally me needing fixing too I've not had that many opportunities to drive it. Still, I've tried my best and put on around 1200 km (which I don't think is too bad given the first owner managed just 800 in the CS's first 8 years!)

I took it out for a proper drive yesterday morning and again today. Over here in Switzerland it is only really worthwhile driving (in my view) very early in the morning as after that there is too much traffic and too many cyclists: I think the collective noun for cyclists should be "a plague"! The non-driver part of me recognises that it is very good that people are doing something healthy like cycling but they can be annoying and some are self-righteous t****. A few weeks back I came around a corner and found a cyclist riding almost in the middle of the road - and then he got annoyed when I went around him (as if he had a god-given right to be a mobile chicane). Unfortunately that sort of behaviour is not uncommon over here. On the same day I let my friend have a drive. We came up behind someone going slower....and they deliberately moved into the middle of the road (driving over the center line) to stop him overtaking, even though it was a long, straight road and it was perfectly safe to overtake.

Anyway, back to the CS now that I have had my rant! I think that I have got to know the car quite well, although I still need more time to explore the edges of its limits (got to be careful as I'm no driving-god and so don't want to find myself going beyond my limits on the public road). In short: what a brilliant car. The engine is so smooth, pulls wonderfully from low revs and builds to such a thrilling crescendo with that manic scream just a flex of the ankle away. Much as I would love an F40 I wonder whether the power delivery would be as satisfying. Certainly thrilling in a terrifying sort of way but overall I much prefer NA. A pity NA engines are dying out.

Although the CS is quite raw in some ways, I find it quite a delicate car to drive, at least on the road. It isn't at all physical as the steering is very light. Where I find I am hustling my 993 down country roads with the CS it feels much more like I am guiding it with movements of the wrists. Even with the broken arm (which is already much better) it is no problem to drive.

It is making me think about my prejudices against automated manuals. I was previously in the "proper manual" camp, believing that automated manuals take something away from the whole driving experience but now I am not so sure. There is something very satisfying about changing gear manually, when you get it just right, including heal-and-toeing. But as I was driving the CS on some really twisty, mountain-like roads it struck me that using the paddles made it much easier to concentrate on the actual driving, getting good lines through the corners and also made it so easy to change up (or more likely down) if I found I wasn't in exactly the right gear. Certainly the paddle shift in the CS flatters the lower-talented like myself.

The seats in the CS are wonderful. Maybe I am not driving fast enough to test their grip but they seem to hold me in place very well (might help that I an average height and average build). They are also very comfortable and I could imagine driving all day without getting out (if the wife and daughter allowed it!)

I know this has nothing to do with the CS but the countryside and the scenery here in Switzerland is just amazing. Even when I couldn't go quickly or got stuck in traffic I could just sit back and look the snow-capped mountains, the green fields and blue lakes. Our 13th year here and I never, ever get tired of the views.

Finally, what seals the deal is the way the CS looks. I stopped this morning for a coffee and still had to pinch myself whilst walking back to the car. And of course can't resist checking out the profile in shop windows.

Downsides? The biggest one is that most of the time I can only use part of the performance on offer, as otherwise would be going far too fast and I am constantly having to reign myself (and therefore the car) in. Pulling back on the leash all the time gets quite frustrating, although that is better than the alternative.

I'm not sure what car I could replace the CS with (I'm not going to yet of course as only just bought it, but I do tend to swap fairly frequently so most likely next year I will change). If I am having problems keeping the speed down with the CS then something even faster might not be the answer. Also, the CS seems quite good value in comparison to (say) an F40, which until recently was my dream car. But now I wonder whether the reality of the F40 would live up to my expectations. I am pretty sure that I would prefer driving an F50, but they don't appeal to me aesthetically in the same way the F40 does. It is similar with the CGT, which pushes all the buttons except the one marked "love the looks".

I'm thinking that I might go in the opposite direction. I've always wanted to own a Caterham. It is one of the cars that I think a true petrol-head should have at some point in their life. And actually they are perfect for the country lanes and back roads that we have here in Switzerland. But a Caterham also doesn't have the looks or emotional pull of a Ferrari. I'm sure it will give me something to think about when winter returns.

Apologies for the rambling post. Hope someone finds it interesting! Was just so fired up when I got back from the drive that felt I had to write something.

70proof

6,158 posts

186 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
agree that being unable to exploit the potential of one's car is the most frustrating aspect of supercar ownership..... raw top speed is not that exciting.... it's being at the limits of grip, it's having a great soudtrack, it's connecting with the road and car..... they say onwards and upwards, but as you say, this may be a caterham rather than a f40... i too have had similar thoughts...

iandc

3,893 posts

237 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
great write up and most amusing particularly the "plague" of cyclists!! Glad both you and the car now fixed and you are able to enjoy driving around that great scenary. I love Swizerland as they seem to be able to keep their roads like billiard tables despite the harsh winters. Enjoy!!

911Thrasher

2,573 posts

230 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
I have a CS and driving question: yup RS sold, CS on its way from Italy (1owner, low mileage)...should be in front of the door by the time I come back from Bali in 4wks.

So this is the big question: we will be doing a road trip "London Tuscany London" end of August - what is the best Geneva-Milan route you can recommend? Including Gran San Bernardo Pass.

hermes

250 posts

232 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
Nice write up. I symapthise with the 'what to get next' problem. I went from an Elise S1 to a Cayman S, to
a Cayman, and now am waiting to pick up my first Ferrari (a 355) in a couple of weeks.
Always fancied the CS too, but again how much of it can you use on the road. (Although that might not stop me trying one!)

Living in the Cotswolds, you also have my sympathies regarding self righteous cyclists. I received a
telling off from one a couple of weeks ago while out in the Lancia for not indicating at a junction.
In my defence, it was because I hadn't decided which way to go :-)


sone

4,612 posts

269 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
I've had my CS for a few weeks now not sure how many miles I've done to date but no doubt more than I said I would.biggrin
To date I'm very pleased with my purchase the car is an absolute blast to drive and the noise is fantastic. My last Ferrari was a 430 so I was a little nervous that I was going backwards, but I can report it was the best thing Ive ever done with regard cars.
Like the op I'm not sure where I will go next but perhaps a Caterham or similar would b a good idea. That said a Caterham would have to be an addition to the garage as I don't think you could replace the character these cars have with a kit based car. Don't get me wrong I like Caterfield type cars but they just don't have that extra little something that a CS has.

Cheers

Steve

s99ane

1,262 posts

265 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
sone said:
I've had my CS for a few weeks now not sure how many miles I've done to date but no doubt more than I said I would.biggrin
To date I'm very pleased with my purchase the car is an absolute blast to drive and the noise is fantastic. My last Ferrari was a 430 so I was a little nervous that I was going backwards, but I can report it was the best thing Ive ever done with regard cars.
Like the op I'm not sure where I will go next but perhaps a Caterham or similar would b a good idea. That said a Caterham would have to be an addition to the garage as I don't think you could replace the character these cars have with a kit based car. Don't get me wrong I like Caterfield type cars but they just don't have that extra little something that a CS has.

Cheers

Steve
Like a proper roof?

;D

TangoGTR

1,672 posts

212 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
Although not a CS, my previous car was a 997 GT3, where like you I struggled to keep speeds down. Incredibly capable car but was too easy to lose license in.

Before that I had an Ariel Atom 3, which was great fun to drive round the Cotswolds here. By not wearing a helmet, the wind on your face accentuates the feeling of speed, thus keeping overall speeds at more sensible numbers. An Atom has more visual impact than a Caterham, so maybe a bonus for you?

That said, I ultimately sold the Atom as it didn't have same visual impact as say a ferrari, in my eyes anyway.

In your shoes I would keep CS as the stunning looking car and get a Caterham or Atom as your car when you need a speed fix. If money isn't an issue then maybe a BAC Mono instead?

Dave

wtdoom

3,742 posts

239 months

Sunday 27th May 2012
quotequote all
You can exploit the potential of your cars on track . I track everything from a 964 c2 to a Carrera gt .
Do it , nothing better than seeing a true thoroughbred proving its mettle on track .

jackal

11,251 posts

313 months

Monday 28th May 2012
quotequote all
sone said:
I've had my CS for a few weeks now not sure how many miles I've done to date but no doubt more than I said I would.biggrin
To date I'm very pleased with my purchase the car is an absolute blast to drive and the noise is fantastic. My last Ferrari was a 430 so I was a little nervous that I was going backwards, but I can report it was the best thing Ive ever done with regard cars.
Like the op I'm not sure where I will go next but perhaps a Caterham or similar would b a good idea. That said a Caterham would have to be an addition to the garage as I don't think you could replace the character these cars have with a kit based car. Don't get me wrong I like Caterfield type cars but they just don't have that extra little something that a CS has.

Cheers

Steve
cool !

was convinced you'd go for a scud but congrats on the CS

Schnellmann

Original Poster:

1,893 posts

235 months

Monday 28th May 2012
quotequote all
Some responses:

911Thrasher: congrats on the CS. Hope u enjoy yours as much as I am enjoying mine. Would be interesting if you posted your thoughts on the comparison with the RS. Not sure I can recommend a good route. Geneva is on opposite end of Switzerland to the San Bernadino pass so yo migh be better off crossing into Italy near Geneva.

TangoGTR: I don't think you can register an Atom or Mono BAC in Switzerland. Rules here are quite restrictive. Unfortunately I don't have space for another car (plus I get enough grief from my wife for having a Porsche and Ferrari so adding a Caterham would be viewed as taking the p***!


Wtdoom: would love to go on track (although if I did it would definitely be in a Caterham or exige or similar) but not easy here in Switzerland as no race tracks and difficult to find free time. On average I only make it on track once every two years and even then it is normally on two wheels, not four.

4pot

481 posts

255 months

Monday 28th May 2012
quotequote all
The Swiss roads are fantastic, but most of the locals are complete idiots when it comes to being followed by a sports car. I can relate to being blocked from overtaking on numerous occasions, even when it was perfectly safe to do so.

Regards the CS, I imagine that this is perhaps a far better proposition to threading along Swiss roads, passes etc, than an F40. Perhaps the biggest downside to the CS, is that the Swiss police will be able to hear cong from further afield than if you were in an F40!


bromers2

1,867 posts

281 months

Monday 28th May 2012
quotequote all
I love hearing stories from fellow CS owners. It's my biggest dilemma of what to get next.

Congrats on your purchase Pierre - which one did you go for / spec ?

911Thrasher

2,573 posts

230 months

Monday 28th May 2012
quotequote all
bromers2 said:
I love hearing stories from fellow CS owners. It's my biggest dilemma of what to get next.

Congrats on your purchase Pierre - which one did you go for / spec ?
LHD, rosso scuderia (orange one), red/black alcantra, red harness, no radio, no stripe (but will be added)
1 owner from new, Jul04, 16000km (10kmiles)...still has delivery protective film on carbon interior!!!

And it's coming from Ferrari dealership, from its native country wink

My man Clive arranged everything and will deliver as soon as i'm back from Bali end of June.

bromers2

1,867 posts

281 months

Tuesday 29th May 2012
quotequote all
911Thrasher said:
LHD, rosso scuderia (orange one), red/black alcantra, red harness, no radio, no stripe (but will be added)
1 owner from new, Jul04, 16000km (10kmiles)...still has delivery protective film on carbon interior!!!

And it's coming from Ferrari dealership, from its native country wink

My man Clive arranged everything and will deliver as soon as i'm back from Bali end of June.
Perfect mate - well done.

LukeyLikey

855 posts

178 months

Tuesday 29th May 2012
quotequote all
Interesting thread! A couple of questions are on my mind, don't know if anyone can answer. I have never driven a CS or Scud but have owned a 360 and now 430 with both being spiders.

I put Capristo headers on the 430, which make an unimaginable difference - much more and better noise, much more power and especially torque - very big improvement, but even before that 430 was far ahead of 360.

I read on another thread about a 458 owner who felt disappointed that the 458 was not as far ahead of its competition as the 430 in its time.

So, the questions, first, what exactly were the improvements going from 430 to CS and second, does the same apply to a 458 and Scud?

tony h

2,703 posts

277 months

Tuesday 29th May 2012
quotequote all
LukeyLikey said:
Interesting thread! A couple of questions are on my mind, don't know if anyone can answer. I have never driven a CS or Scud but have owned a 360 and now 430 with both being spiders.

I put Capristo headers on the 430, which make an unimaginable difference - much more and better noise, much more power and especially torque - very big improvement, but even before that 430 was far ahead of 360.

I read on another thread about a 458 owner who felt disappointed that the 458 was not as far ahead of its competition as the 430 in its time.

So, the questions, first, what exactly were the improvements going from 430 to CS and second, does the same apply to a 458 and Scud?
biggest diff is always gearbox/diff . the 430 had the switchable steering wheel mounted manatino and improved f1 box, the 458 has the new dual clutch box. the step up in technology over previous model is incredible

JazzyO

1,125 posts

212 months

Tuesday 29th May 2012
quotequote all
tony h said:
biggest diff is always gearbox/diff . the 430 had the switchable steering wheel mounted manatino and improved f1 box, the 458 has the new dual clutch box. the step up in technology over previous model is incredible
I find the biggest difference not the DCT (although that is a big difference) but the improvement in software systems (F1 trac, E diff, ABS etc). They are so subtle, they give you the impression that you're Alonso when we all know we're not. On the F430 the systems are much cruder and you really feel them interfering. I love the switchability of the 458's character. You can go from puppy dog to (almost) hooligan in the flick of a switch. I say 'almost' hooligan, as it is not as raw as a Scud. For the final 5% of hooliganism the Scud is still the preferred choice (or a CS). But doing powerslides on tight corner exits is a doddle in a 458 on RACE, she really gives me a lot of confidence.

As for Schnellmann's comments, I can relate. I wondered about buying a 458 because of the difficulty in exploiting the abilities on normal roads. On a twisty Italian mountain road, she is glorious. Going for a drive in Holland, she is frustrating me. Only straight roads and millions of Gatso's. But a Caterham would be just as frustrating here, and I figure that it wouldn't actually help in Switzerland either. Caterhams are quick these days, you would get in just as much trouble then.

It is a reason I have classics in my stable. They are great fun when you're going straight at 50mph and people are much more tolerant of them.


Onno

pistolp

1,720 posts

253 months

Tuesday 29th May 2012
quotequote all
To say the 458 isn't a big leap forward on from the 430 is nonsense. It is lightyears up the road in almost everyway.

I thought the 430 was amazing when it came out, as I did the 360. However, the 458 I think will go down in folklore. It is that good. One criticism, is it too good? I would happily run it as my only car if I could. As it happens I live in London so it wouldn't be ideal. The best bit is the handling and the balance. I have never driven a mid engined road car that is so friendly at the limit. It is much easier to drive at the limit than something like the CS, it has a pointier front end yet somehow manages to also be much more friendly when it starts to oversteer. it doesn't seem to snap like the CS can from time to time. It always remains pregressive and on side. Overall you're just aware of a lack of inertia in the 458 when compared to the cars that came before it and that is a good thing in car that fast. It always feels like it is on tippy toes dancing down the road. Honestly it is staggering. There is no good reason a why a mid engined Ferrari should be as easy to hoon about in as an M3 but Ferrari have managed it, not only that but just look at the damn thing!

I love the CS though, more old school. The first of the new breed really and still untterly intoxicacting when you are nipping on. In my mind it's a car that is almost as rewarding at the limit but far less so when you are pootling - when compared to the 458. Don't get me wrong it is still a good car but the gearbox and overall handling of the car seem to come together when you are really pushing. With the 458, as mentioned above, it does everything all the time with style and panache. It just works and you don't have to be 'in the mood'.

As for the caterham idea, bang on. Everyone should try one at some stage. A level of of involvement and interaction that no other road car can hope to equal. No toys, no fuss, just pure driving. Just get one anyway and remind your wife who pays the bills. If you listen to her now you'll be doing that for the rest of your life! Enjoy the cars.

Schnellmann

Original Poster:

1,893 posts

235 months

Tuesday 29th May 2012
quotequote all
pistolp said:
Just get one anyway and remind your wife who pays the bills. If you listen to her now you'll be doing that for the rest of your life!
Er...perhaps good advice, but 24 years too late! smile

Keeping my wife on board with my purchases also has other advantages though...and given that I've had more than 27 cars and a couple of bikes since we have been together I've not done too badly....