Government announces some protection at last!
Government announces some protection at last!
Author
Discussion

paulqv

Original Poster:

3,124 posts

226 months

Tuesday 12th June 2012
quotequote all
I tend to use a few forums on the internet. On this site I generally use about two. What is remarkable are the number of unpleasant people who post in this specific forum! On the Scotland forum, I can seldom recall the frequent level of bad manners and rudeness that I find in this area,

Anyway,

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-18404621

Hopefully this will happen soon and the small minority of people who behave that way will be named and shamed. Perhaps they should be all gathered up and put in a far away field and allowed to just shout and be rude to each other!

Owners of these types of cars are normally, 'different' but having met quite a few who post here, i can say that they have all been really nice people!

Paul

Schnellmann

1,893 posts

235 months

Tuesday 12th June 2012
quotequote all
I hope you have your flame-proof suit on today.

I agree with your comment that on occasion posts/posters are out of line (although of course the line between offensive and funny is a difficult one to draw).

I sometimes do wonder why the PH team don't intervene and stop threads and/or expel posters more frequently though as there are many posts that are racist, sexist, classist or just plain rude/offensive, which I thought were not allowed under the forum rules.


raptor600

1,356 posts

177 months

Tuesday 12th June 2012
quotequote all
Schnellmann said:
there are many posts that are racist, sexist, classist or just plain rude/offensive
Really?

I can't remember seeing any.

BelfastBoy

779 posts

191 months

Tuesday 12th June 2012
quotequote all
raptor600 said:
Really?

I can't remember seeing any.
Lots of laugh out loud funniness in this thread, but also a lot of unpleasantness (including pretty overt homophobia)as well:

http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/gassing/topic.asp?h=0...

Schnellmann

1,893 posts

235 months

Tuesday 12th June 2012
quotequote all
BelfastBoy said:
Lots of laugh out loud funniness in this thread, but also a lot of unpleasantness (including pretty overt homophobia)as well:

http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/gassing/topic.asp?h=0...
I was just about to post that link! As you say, some of it was quite funny but other sections just abusive.

paulqv

Original Poster:

3,124 posts

226 months

Tuesday 12th June 2012
quotequote all
Humour and gently taking the piss are fine. I am referring to just plain rudeness or abuse. Whilst there can sometimes be a fine line between the two, generally we all know when the line has been crossed. If people think it has then a simple apology is all that is needed to sort things. Those who are the subject of this will be the ones who won't apologise etc


pork911

7,365 posts

214 months

Tuesday 12th June 2012
quotequote all
What has unpleasantness, bad manners and rudeness got to do with these proposals?

WCZ

11,574 posts

225 months

Tuesday 12th June 2012
quotequote all
The FML&B forum is fine and I've personally not observed anything that would warrant any prosecution under that new legislation.

The type of offence that 'trolling' gets beyond distasteful and has seen successful court cases are things like attacks and sick comments on tribute fb pages of the recently deceased, bullying and false accusations etc.

paulqv

Original Poster:

3,124 posts

226 months

Tuesday 12th June 2012
quotequote all
WCZ said:
The FML&B forum is fine and I've personally not observed anything that would warrant any prosecution under that new legislation.

The type of offence that 'trolling' gets beyond distasteful and has seen successful court cases are things like attacks and sick comments on tribute fb pages of the recently deceased, bullying and false accusations etc.
Perhaps you should have read some of the comments on the Verdi threads on here by those supporting mr verdi! I think many of those comments would easily have met that criteria!


WCZ

11,574 posts

225 months

Tuesday 12th June 2012
quotequote all
paulqv said:
Perhaps you should have read some of the comments on the Verdi threads on here by those supporting mr verdi! I think many of those comments would easily have met that criteria!
Perhaps, but I think that was idiots as oppose to malicious trolling!

davek_964

11,382 posts

206 months

Tuesday 12th June 2012
quotequote all
I would be surprised if the changes affect the kind of thing that happens on PH threads. I remember seeing the story about that lady in the news, and it wasn't just that abusive comments were made about her - people apparently even set up fake FB accounts and sent inappropriate messages to young girls. That is an order of magnitude worse than the kind of thing that happens on PH.

Having said that - I use (and post) on PH a lot less than I used to, because I do find it quite an unpleasant site these days. There are just too many arguments all the time - it reminds me of a school playground.

pork911

7,365 posts

214 months

Tuesday 12th June 2012
quotequote all
The verdi supporters wouldn't be caught by defamation.

The fear that their critics might would make forum owners and mods more anxious about them.

rdbrooksie

205 posts

198 months

Tuesday 12th June 2012
quotequote all
Schnellmann said:
BelfastBoy said:
Lots of laugh out loud funniness in this thread, but also a lot of unpleasantness (including pretty overt homophobia)as well:

http://www.pistonheads.co.uk/gassing/topic.asp?h=0...
I was just about to post that link! As you say, some of it was quite funny but other sections just abusive.
To have a good debate on an issue is one thing, but to be called by a stranger 'faggot' because I posted a comment on here (I'm married to a gorgeous woman!) whether that was meant to be amusing or not I felt was inappropriate. But hey, I didn't loose any sleep over it and after all, I drive a Countach and a Gallardo and enjoy the cars as much as the next Piston Head....

BelfastBoy

779 posts

191 months

Tuesday 12th June 2012
quotequote all
rdbrooksie said:
To have a good debate on an issue is one thing, but to be called by a stranger 'faggot' because I posted a comment on here (I'm married to a gorgeous woman!) whether that was meant to be amusing or not I felt was inappropriate. But hey, I didn't loose any sleep over it and after all, I drive a Countach and a Gallardo and enjoy the cars as much as the next Piston Head....
That was the comment I was specifically referring to, and I sure as hell didn't find it funny.

Galsia

2,266 posts

221 months

Tuesday 12th June 2012
quotequote all
There is a big difference between somebody on a message board calling you a faggot once and somebody starting a hate campaign against you on various forums and social networking sites.

The former should be dealt with by forum moderators and the latter by the police.


pork911

7,365 posts

214 months

Tuesday 12th June 2012
quotequote all
BelfastBoy said:
rdbrooksie said:
To have a good debate on an issue is one thing, but to be called by a stranger 'faggot' because I posted a comment on here (I'm married to a gorgeous woman!) whether that was meant to be amusing or not I felt was inappropriate. But hey, I didn't loose any sleep over it and after all, I drive a Countach and a Gallardo and enjoy the cars as much as the next Piston Head....
That was the comment I was specifically referring to, and I sure as hell didn't find it funny.

The term is likely not defamatory nor it's use there bullying or a hate crime.

The law doesn't and shouldn't interfere in what belfastboy doesn't find funny.

BelfastBoy

779 posts

191 months

Tuesday 12th June 2012
quotequote all
pork911 said:

The term is likely not defamatory nor it's use there bullying or a hate crime.

The law doesn't and shouldn't interfere in what belfastboy doesn't find funny.
Actually, I agree with you on the basic point here - nothing in the thread I linked to is serious enough to warrant investigation by the authorities under this new legislation. However, what I actually meant was that I found someone's casually vindictive employment of the term 'faggot' deeply offensive and unpleasant. Do you find that an acceptable, or even funny, word to use on a message board, or in everyday life? Whether you agree or not, this is a deeply homophobic term of abuse. If I were heard using that word in my job, I'd most likely find myself seeking new employment. That's all I have to say on this subject.

paulqv

Original Poster:

3,124 posts

226 months

Tuesday 12th June 2012
quotequote all
BelfastBoy said:
Actually, I agree with you on the basic point here - nothing in the thread I linked to is serious enough to warrant investigation by the authorities under this new legislation. However, what I actually meant was that I found someone's casually vindictive employment of the term 'faggot' deeply offensive and unpleasant. Do you find that an acceptable, or even funny, word to use on a message board, or in everyday life? Whether you agree or not, this is a deeply homophobic term of abuse. If I were heard using that word in my job, I'd most likely find myself seeking new employment. That's all I have to say on this subject.
Very well put. The old test of 'if its't what you would say in public or to your family,,,' still has some merit!

pork911

7,365 posts

214 months

Tuesday 12th June 2012
quotequote all
BelfastBoy said:
pork911 said:

The term is likely not defamatory nor it's use there bullying or a hate crime.

The law doesn't and shouldn't interfere in what belfastboy doesn't find funny.
Actually, I agree with you on the basic point here - nothing in the thread I linked to is serious enough to warrant investigation by the authorities under this new legislation. However, what I actually meant was that I found someone's casually vindictive employment of the term 'faggot' deeply offensive and unpleasant. Do you find that an acceptable, or even funny, word to use on a message board, or in everyday life? Whether you agree or not, this is a deeply homophobic term of abuse. If I were heard using that word in my job, I'd most likely find myself seeking new employment. That's all I have to say on this subject.
Offence is taken not given though that was likely the intent of the poster in the link.

I totally agree it can be a highly unpleasant homophobic term and in the context above it is - it can though be a term of endearment in some particularly narrow circumstances.

People being offended is a necessary possibility of freedom of speech and should never give rise to prohibition. Defamation, harassment and hate speech is something entirely different. What's sensible to keep your job is another matter.

rdbrooksie

205 posts

198 months

Tuesday 12th June 2012
quotequote all
BelfastBoy said:
pork911 said:

The term is likely not defamatory nor it's use there bullying or a hate crime.

The law doesn't and shouldn't interfere in what belfastboy doesn't find funny.
Actually, I agree with you on the basic point here - nothing in the thread I linked to is serious enough to warrant investigation by the authorities under this new legislation. However, what I actually meant was that I found someone's casually vindictive employment of the term 'faggot' deeply offensive and unpleasant. Do you find that an acceptable, or even funny, word to use on a message board, or in everyday life? Whether you agree or not, this is a deeply homophobic term of abuse. If I were heard using that word in my job, I'd most likely find myself seeking new employment. That's all I have to say on this subject.
Well said.