The paint is matt black, its the same in the front boot surround. Very common problem I'm told, Got mine re-done under warranty, definitely matt I'm afraid.
Technically it isn't Matt black but satin black. It will be obvious on resale to anyone who has looked at a few cars IMHO if your car has been refinished in gloss. It's the bodyshop's mistake as they should have checked prior to doing the work so they should correct it for you.