Strad, 430, 599, Scud
Discussion
TISPKJ said:
Strad for Sunday morning fun and track days, 599 for all that power !
430 seems out of place ?
Don't think the 430 is neccessarily out of place it's probably the best bargain out of the lot of those at the moment.430 seems out of place ?
Strad and Scud, ripped out lacking a bit of creature comfort
599 monster power but imho not as good handling as the 430, the 599 is a big car and you can feel it
430 a bit less raw than the scud,strad, got some additional cature comfort and still an amazing performer and currently a performance car bargain.
John.
steelej said:
TISPKJ said:
Strad for Sunday morning fun and track days, 599 for all that power !
430 seems out of place ?
Don't think the 430 is neccessarily out of place it's probably the best bargain out of the lot of those at the moment.430 seems out of place ?
Strad and Scud, ripped out lacking a bit of creature comfort
599 monster power but imho not as good handling as the 430, the 599 is a big car and you can feel it
430 a bit less raw than the scud,strad, got some additional cature comfort and still an amazing performer and currently a performance car bargain.
John.
TISPKJ said:
I was thinking price wise, lovely car for sure but from what 60k now ? Strad and 599 circa 100 and scud from 120 ? 430 seemed a little like the poor relation in the above group in terms of value.
Although you could say that the 430 is approaching the bottom of it's depreciation curve looking at where the 360 and 355 currently sit making it in my personal opinion the best value for money out of that lot. An awful lot of car for the money, but it all depends on what you're after.John.
jackal said:
Is the 599 a hoot on twisty A or B roads ?
Or just a little bit too wide and weighty ?
Take a 599 GTB. Switch to sports. Find a challenging sweeping A road with some twisty bits and gun it. Now marvel how Ferrari can build a car which combines the clinical competence of a German supercar with full on Italian DNA. Yes, the 599 is a big car. But that makes its technical delivery all the more amazing.Or just a little bit too wide and weighty ?
For difficult B roads best buy a Caterham.
Have not driven the 599 but the 550 is already a lot of fun on twisties, better than you expect. We all know how much of a leap the 599 was so I'd expect it to be fantastic. But she won't be a Scud rival of course. The feel will be very different.
I think you need to drive all these and then make up your mind. For me, the greatest thing about Ferrarinis that each model is unique and it has it's own design philosophy. You can therefore pick which one suits your car usage and personal preference best. If you're after a screamer pick Scud or Strad, if you're after a wonderful GT, pick 599, if you're after something in between pick 430.
Onno
I think you need to drive all these and then make up your mind. For me, the greatest thing about Ferrarinis that each model is unique and it has it's own design philosophy. You can therefore pick which one suits your car usage and personal preference best. If you're after a screamer pick Scud or Strad, if you're after a wonderful GT, pick 599, if you're after something in between pick 430.
Onno
Interesting thread. I often wonder if I should sell Aston DBS to upgrade a 430 Spider to a 16M (love the 430, the 16M is presumably much more of the same and more exclusive) but every time I consider it, I can't think the 16M is a DBS better than the already brilliant 430 Spider?
Advantages would be the 16M would likely be better than either 430 or DBS, (I love techy, high performance, lithe cars) and a lower cost of running one car - presuming the depreciation is not a major hit even with a 16M is nearly £100k more than a 430?
Disadvantages would be that I wouldn't have both a GT, manual, coupe in a sedate colour and a spider, F1, sports car in a bold colour in my garage. Also, nothing looks like a DBS.
Best off where I am methinks.
Advantages would be the 16M would likely be better than either 430 or DBS, (I love techy, high performance, lithe cars) and a lower cost of running one car - presuming the depreciation is not a major hit even with a 16M is nearly £100k more than a 430?
Disadvantages would be that I wouldn't have both a GT, manual, coupe in a sedate colour and a spider, F1, sports car in a bold colour in my garage. Also, nothing looks like a DBS.
Best off where I am methinks.
I probably love the image, the idea of the 599 the best and it looks the best to me as well. The more grown up V12 personality suits me more but the running costs and that enzo engine sans warranty scares me a little.
The strad is special and collectable and is perhaps as good looking as the 599 but it's less useable and lacks the very appealing build quality, modernity and technology of the other 3 cars. Fun to gun it in but I didn't find it especailly interesting when just pottering around in or on regular journeys either.
The vanilla 430 is probably the one i would have most fun in more of the time. As its the cheapest emotionally it will be more liberating and get used and ragged more and the prospect of a last chance with a manual is equalling tempting ... the only problem is its not really special enough and the looks just aren't quite right.
The Scud fixes that though because it IS special and potentially collectable in future years. It's probably the ideal choice for me but not only is it not worth double the price of a 2005 430 but sadly its also the one that's out of budget.
The strad is special and collectable and is perhaps as good looking as the 599 but it's less useable and lacks the very appealing build quality, modernity and technology of the other 3 cars. Fun to gun it in but I didn't find it especailly interesting when just pottering around in or on regular journeys either.
The vanilla 430 is probably the one i would have most fun in more of the time. As its the cheapest emotionally it will be more liberating and get used and ragged more and the prospect of a last chance with a manual is equalling tempting ... the only problem is its not really special enough and the looks just aren't quite right.
The Scud fixes that though because it IS special and potentially collectable in future years. It's probably the ideal choice for me but not only is it not worth double the price of a 2005 430 but sadly its also the one that's out of budget.
Edited by jackal on Sunday 8th July 16:28
Gassing Station | Supercar General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



