PAS in 'Drivers cars'- would you rather be unassisted?
PAS in 'Drivers cars'- would you rather be unassisted?
Author
Discussion

Fantuzzi

Original Poster:

3,297 posts

177 months

Tuesday 17th July 2012
quotequote all
(Disclaimer - I do not own a high performance/supercar as I am a lowly student, so feel free to say the obivious!)

This has never really crossed my mind until recently (4-5mounths), mainly after totting up all of the comments Ive heard in passing from car journos.

That comment, well paraphrased and summerized, 'I would'nt buy a modern supercar-Id have an F40'.

Its normally in passing about what makes a greaat drivers car, and what can be considered one of the purest car for people like us and how (sometimes) modern supercars are somewhat remote if very capable.

Now I understand that many people will use high performance cars everyday, or often enough that the pain of wheeling big tires would be far too annoying (for some).

Yet if there was a 'no PAS' option to tick on your 458 or Scud, would you tick it. Many people have bought an F40 on this thread, and adore them, many have driven one and were intoxicated, despite the lack of steering assistance. I use the F40 as the main example (rather than say an Elise S which is a modern performancce car that lacks PAS) because even by todays standards its performance is up there with modern machines (3.7 to 60 is the on paper figure which isnt far off modern supercars, given it lacks a paddle shift geaarbox).

So would you tick a no PAS option on a modern car?

I wouldnt on a GT car,but for everything else I would.

Edited by Fantuzzi on Tuesday 17th July 12:38

900T-R

20,406 posts

288 months

Tuesday 17th July 2012
quotequote all
What does a 458 weigh - 1,400 kgs? Even in rear-mid engined format, that'd be way too much to cope without PAS especially with the sticky steamroller tyres needed to give the car its prodigious grip levels.

'No PAS' only works in an overall reduced weight/power/grip scenario (compared to where supercars are right now) - in which case I'm all for it.

Edited by 900T-R on Tuesday 17th July 12:57

andrew

10,368 posts

223 months

Tuesday 17th July 2012
quotequote all
having had the superleggera stall in a second gear corner ( no, i'm not too sure how in an "automatic", but, hey ) i can confirm that cornering big tyres without pas is bloody hard work !

BelfastBoy

779 posts

191 months

Tuesday 17th July 2012
quotequote all
900T-R said:
What does a 458 weigh - 1,400 kgs? Even in rear-mid engined format, that'd be way too much to cope without PAS especially with the sticky steamroller tyres needed to give the car its prodigeous grip levels.

'No PAS' only works in an overall reduced weight/power/grip scenario (compared to where supercars are right now) - in which case I'm all for it.
McLaren F1 supposedly weighs 1138kg, damn light for that kind of car - yet many objective comments about the car I've read comment on how heavy the steering feels. (Flipside is they also say how communicative and direct the steering is.) Could there be an argument for PAS in fat-tyred powerful cars on safety grounds? In other words, if you overcook it and find yourself sliding, would it be easier to catch and control the car if you had assistance?

900T-R

20,406 posts

288 months

Tuesday 17th July 2012
quotequote all
BelfastBoy said:
Could there be an argument for PAS in fat-tyred powerful cars on safety grounds? In other words, if you overcook it and find yourself sliding, would it be easier to catch and control the car if you had assistance?
Absolutely. The flipside is that PAS makes it also easier to over-correct, or to over-drive the car to make it slide in the first place...

otolith

69,806 posts

235 months

Tuesday 17th July 2012
quotequote all
900T-R said:
'No PAS' only works in an overall reduced weight/power/grip scenario (compared to where supercars are right now) - in which case I'm all for it.
yes

Weight mostly, I'd say, especially on rear drive cars. Power more of a problem on front drivers. Works brilliantly on an Elise or Exige despite very high limits of grip.

Fantuzzi

Original Poster:

3,297 posts

177 months

Tuesday 17th July 2012
quotequote all
otolith said:
yes

Weight mostly, I'd say, especially on rear drive cars. Power more of a problem on front drivers. Works brilliantly on an Elise or Exige despite very high limits of grip.
I agree, but thankfully high performance cars seem to be heading in that direction,or at least they should be given want more focussed cars and goverments want less CO2. The Alfa 4c and the New Gransport (if its made) hopefully will set a trend!

Thanks to all those that replied.