Manual Gallardo
Discussion
polar8 said:
Obviously not many around and I've heard they are now discontinued by the factory.
that is the way all manufacturers r going..... no doubt a big audi influence here too.... easier and cheaper to have one tooling setup for relatively low volume cars... also, it's almost become the norm to have an electronic box in a car..... funny as in the states, some models get a manual box whereas no where else in the world does????P101 said:
If you like driving, you will like manual, if you like xbox/ps3 you will like egear.
Not at all true.A good F1 box can be equally as exciting on a hard drive as a manual. People need to get over the above and try these things for a good amount of time, it grows on you and very quickly you would not go back to a manual.
UH-Matt said:
P101 said:
If you like driving, you will like manual, if you like xbox/ps3 you will like egear.
Not at all true.A good F1 box can be equally as exciting on a hard drive as a manual. People need to get over the above and try these things for a good amount of time, it grows on you and very quickly you would not go back to a manual.
They discontinued it cause something like 1% of cars ordered were manual. Plus old tech, moving with the times (Ferrari) etc.
My LP560 is manual, obviously so much more involving and rewarding to drive. Having said that if I used the car a lot I would go with the E-Gear just for ease of use, but I don't so it makes sense to have manual.
My LP560 is manual, obviously so much more involving and rewarding to drive. Having said that if I used the car a lot I would go with the E-Gear just for ease of use, but I don't so it makes sense to have manual.
andrew said:
UH-Matt said:
P101 said:
If you like driving, you will like manual, if you like xbox/ps3 you will like egear.
Not at all true.A good F1 box can be equally as exciting on a hard drive as a manual. People need to get over the above and try these things for a good amount of time, it grows on you and very quickly you would not go back to a manual.
andrew said:
UH-Matt said:
P101 said:
If you like driving, you will like manual, if you like xbox/ps3 you will like egear.
Not at all true.A good F1 box can be equally as exciting on a hard drive as a manual. People need to get over the above and try these things for a good amount of time, it grows on you and very quickly you would not go back to a manual.
Tried a manual on a track day, didn't like it much at all, too clunky and hard work. It's totally personal preference, but most 'manual' people will just assume what Clarkson says about flappy paddles is true, when in fact it's really not.
Try both, obviously, but I think the e-gear is so much easier to live with, and a lot of fun.
Arial Atom, yes, manual, no question. But a Gallardo is a very different beast.
maser_spyder said:
Totally this.
Tried a manual on a track day, didn't like it much at all, too clunky and hard work. It's totally personal preference, but most 'manual' people will just assume what Clarkson says about flappy paddles is true, when in fact it's really not.
Try both, obviously, but I think the e-gear is so much easier to live with, and a lot of fun.
Arial Atom, yes, manual, no question. But a Gallardo is a very different beast.
Clarkson just cant drive, i managed very smooth gear changes even in my old and clunky 4200 cambiocorsa, I find paddless take somthing away, My old F430 was too perfect to drive if that maes sense. And that made it a little dull.Tried a manual on a track day, didn't like it much at all, too clunky and hard work. It's totally personal preference, but most 'manual' people will just assume what Clarkson says about flappy paddles is true, when in fact it's really not.
Try both, obviously, but I think the e-gear is so much easier to live with, and a lot of fun.
Arial Atom, yes, manual, no question. But a Gallardo is a very different beast.
famoussas said:
They discontinued it cause something like 1% of cars ordered were manual. Plus old tech, moving with the times (Ferrari) etc.
My LP560 is manual, obviously so much more involving and rewarding to drive. Having said that if I used the car a lot I would go with the E-Gear just for ease of use, but I don't so it makes sense to have manual.
we asked the % question of a helpful lambo dealer on here a while backMy LP560 is manual, obviously so much more involving and rewarding to drive. Having said that if I used the car a lot I would go with the E-Gear just for ease of use, but I don't so it makes sense to have manual.
his answer was that in reality the dealer had not received an order for a manual gallardo for a couple of years
I'm a manual kinda guy.
The problem is with manufacturers becoming obsessed with 0-60s and ring times only flappy paddles will do because they are quicker,plus the reality is the majority of supercars are bought by poseurs who just want to be seen in the car , hence the decline in sales of manuals
The Americans won't stand for such bulls
t so certain manufacturers have had to introduce manual boxes into cars like the m5 hence why you can buy some cars in manual form in the states
But not here.
The current crop of flappy gearboxes such as the Porsche PDk and BMW dual clutch and the latest Ferrari ones are brilliant,I can completely understand someone going for them, in fact if I we're to buy a new 991 now it would be PDk
But personally nO matter how good a flappy paddle box is I feel I am losing out on some interaction with the car
Plus with the Gallardo you get that beautiful click clack gear change adds 10% to the fun IMO.
In the near future I can easily see manual gallardos and 430s getting premiums over egear/f1 equpped cars due to rarity,and an inability to buy a manual Ferrari or lambo
The problem is with manufacturers becoming obsessed with 0-60s and ring times only flappy paddles will do because they are quicker,plus the reality is the majority of supercars are bought by poseurs who just want to be seen in the car , hence the decline in sales of manuals
The Americans won't stand for such bulls
t so certain manufacturers have had to introduce manual boxes into cars like the m5 hence why you can buy some cars in manual form in the states But not here.
The current crop of flappy gearboxes such as the Porsche PDk and BMW dual clutch and the latest Ferrari ones are brilliant,I can completely understand someone going for them, in fact if I we're to buy a new 991 now it would be PDk
But personally nO matter how good a flappy paddle box is I feel I am losing out on some interaction with the car
Plus with the Gallardo you get that beautiful click clack gear change adds 10% to the fun IMO.
In the near future I can easily see manual gallardos and 430s getting premiums over egear/f1 equpped cars due to rarity,and an inability to buy a manual Ferrari or lambo
franki68 said:
I'm a manual kinda guy.
The problem is with manufacturers becoming obsessed with 0-60s and ring times only flappy paddles will do because they are quicker,plus the reality is the majority of supercars are bought by poseurs who just want to be seen in the car , hence the decline in sales of manuals
The Americans won't stand for such bulls
t so certain manufacturers have had to introduce manual boxes into cars like the m5 hence why you can buy some cars in manual form in the states
But not here.
The current crop of flappy gearboxes such as the Porsche PDk and BMW dual clutch and the latest Ferrari ones are brilliant,I can completely understand someone going for them, in fact if I we're to buy a new 991 now it would be PDk
But personally nO matter how good a flappy paddle box is I feel I am losing out on some interaction with the car
Plus with the Gallardo you get that beautiful click clack gear change adds 10% to the fun IMO.
In the near future I can easily see manual gallardos and 430s getting premiums over egear/f1 equpped cars due to rarity,and an inability to buy a manual Ferrari or lambo
What he said. I think the big shame of this situation is that we now have a generation of super car buyers who have never driven a manual car. Someone on here commented that they loved the downshifts of the paddle box, but how much more fun is it to perfect your heal and toe technique to do it properly with a manual?The problem is with manufacturers becoming obsessed with 0-60s and ring times only flappy paddles will do because they are quicker,plus the reality is the majority of supercars are bought by poseurs who just want to be seen in the car , hence the decline in sales of manuals
The Americans won't stand for such bulls
t so certain manufacturers have had to introduce manual boxes into cars like the m5 hence why you can buy some cars in manual form in the states But not here.
The current crop of flappy gearboxes such as the Porsche PDk and BMW dual clutch and the latest Ferrari ones are brilliant,I can completely understand someone going for them, in fact if I we're to buy a new 991 now it would be PDk
But personally nO matter how good a flappy paddle box is I feel I am losing out on some interaction with the car
Plus with the Gallardo you get that beautiful click clack gear change adds 10% to the fun IMO.
In the near future I can easily see manual gallardos and 430s getting premiums over egear/f1 equpped cars due to rarity,and an inability to buy a manual Ferrari or lambo
I have driven both transmissions many miles and as efficient as the new boxes are they still take away a large percentage of the interaction that goes towards making driving a performance car a totally immersive experience. I will also make the same accusation at the huge amounts of computing power that is now substituted for good chassis and suspension design. We are all slowly being seduced by an increasingly synthetic driving experience. Are the cars quicker and safer, probably yes but are they more fun, I think not
Streetrod said:
What he said. I think the big shame of this situation is that we now have a generation of super car buyers who have never driven a manual car. Someone on here commented that they loved the downshifts of the paddle box, but how much more fun is it to perfect your heal and toe technique to do it properly with a manual?
I have driven both transmissions many miles and as efficient as the new boxes are they still take away a large percentage of the interaction that goes towards making driving a performance car a totally immersive experience. I will also make the same accusation at the huge amounts of computing power that is now substituted for good chassis and suspension design. We are all slowly being seduced by an increasingly synthetic driving experience. Are the cars quicker and safer, probably yes but are they more fun, I think not
In years to come, I wonder if manuals will be worth more due to the rarity value.I have driven both transmissions many miles and as efficient as the new boxes are they still take away a large percentage of the interaction that goes towards making driving a performance car a totally immersive experience. I will also make the same accusation at the huge amounts of computing power that is now substituted for good chassis and suspension design. We are all slowly being seduced by an increasingly synthetic driving experience. Are the cars quicker and safer, probably yes but are they more fun, I think not
Streetrod said:
What he said. I think the big shame of this situation is that we now have a generation of super car buyers who have never driven a manual car. Someone on here commented that they loved the downshifts of the paddle box, but how much more fun is it to perfect your heal and toe technique to do it properly with a manual?
I have driven both transmissions many miles and as efficient as the new boxes are they still take away a large percentage of the interaction that goes towards making driving a performance car a totally immersive experience. I will also make the same accusation at the huge amounts of computing power that is now substituted for good chassis and suspension design. We are all slowly being seduced by an increasingly synthetic driving experience. Are the cars quicker and safer, probably yes but are they more fun, I think not
This is something that genuinely concerns me and the bit that saddens me is that is all being led by numbers. Number of gears, emissions, quickness of change, all attributes that can be quantifiably measured. They need to be smaller, quicker, faster etc and this is somehow better. Enjoyment is something that cant be measured. I think this may be why the old 458 v's 12C debate started, the 12C had to be better than the Ferrari in every quantifiable area, however in that one unquantifiable trate of enjoyment or desire, the Ferrari had the greater attraction. I was reading something the other night and someone said "who needs a gearchange to be 40ms, fine on a track, but on everyday life, driving to work, it doesnt need to be as lightning quick as that. I have driven both transmissions many miles and as efficient as the new boxes are they still take away a large percentage of the interaction that goes towards making driving a performance car a totally immersive experience. I will also make the same accusation at the huge amounts of computing power that is now substituted for good chassis and suspension design. We are all slowly being seduced by an increasingly synthetic driving experience. Are the cars quicker and safer, probably yes but are they more fun, I think not
0 - 60, blah blah, new pdk does this superfast, but how often do you really do that. I would rather have a nice manual gearbox that is involving and enjoying to drive rather than just letting the computers do it all.
Im pretty sure the Lp550-2 was being offered with manual for quite a while. Supposedly brilliant!
polar8 said:
Obviously not many around and I've heard they are now discontinued by the factory.
Why? Are they bad to use? Why would all owners want e-gear? Are they hard to resell?
I'm a manual guy and want a Gallardo but worried by the above.
Any opinions appreciated...
Thx
It depends what model you are speaking about. There were quite a few of the older cars in Manual, so that shouldn't be too much of a problem getting one. My father has a 2005 manual and it's great. The car was then tweaked slightly in 2006 and there seems to be less of those cars in manual. the car was then heavily tweaked to become the LP560) and I've only ever seem a couple of those in manual. Why? Are they bad to use? Why would all owners want e-gear? Are they hard to resell?
I'm a manual guy and want a Gallardo but worried by the above.
Any opinions appreciated...
Thx
As for the flappy paddle manual debate, I've had a number of cars over the years and have several cars currently in my stable. They are all a mix between manual and flappy paddle. I personally like both, it depends very much on what car it is though. For example I just bought a New Gallardo LP570 Superleggera a couple months ago, it's e-gear and I can tell you I wouldn't have bought that in a manual. I feel the paddles work brilliantly and in a car like that I wouldn't want a manual again. Having said that my Ferrari 355 is a manual and when I bought that I was only looking for a manual and I don't regret my decision at all. I feel it suits the character of the car better than the F1 + the software is so old now I personally feel it would feel to antiquated for me coming from things like Porsche's PDK and Lambo’s e-gear.
So to answer your question, it very much depends on the car. I personally wouldn't want the older flappy paddle cars because I feel they're just too clunky and slow. For example my Maserati Gransport is flappy paddle and it's very good in sport mode, but I personally find it far too slow and cumbersome in normal mode, to live with. So I always drive it in Sport

Anyway, I hope that helps. Try the flappy paddles before you discard it. You may well be surprised.
Gassing Station | Supercar General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


