Aston Martin to Gallardo
Aston Martin to Gallardo
Author
Discussion

ripley500

Original Poster:

390 posts

242 months

Wednesday 19th September 2012
quotequote all
Anyone on here gone from V8 Vantage to Gallardo (or vise vera)? - I'd be very interested to hear your thoughts/comments.

Thinking about changing my 4.3 V8 to 06+ Gallardo and reading the various posts on here it seems the Gallardo can be summed up with - great style, presence and capability but lacking a bit in that X factor (big TT seems to be a common statement). I absolutely love the Aston and driving it is always special, its not the fastest or best car in its class but it does have something 'special' about it - hence keen to get some fresh perspectives on people that have owned both.

Thanks

carpov

190 posts

192 months

Thursday 20th September 2012
quotequote all
Since you haven't had a reply, I can tell you that I was racing my 11 year daughter in Forza 4 last night. I was in a DBS and she was in a Gallardo. She whipped my ass!
The Gallardo had impressive straight line speed and was rock solid in the corners. Awesome engine soundtrack too.
It lost to the 458 though.

franki68

11,714 posts

252 months

Thursday 20th September 2012
quotequote all
ripley500 said:
Anyone on here gone from V8 Vantage to Gallardo (or vise vera)? - I'd be very interested to hear your thoughts/comments.

Thinking about changing my 4.3 V8 to 06+ Gallardo and reading the various posts on here it seems the Gallardo can be summed up with - great style, presence and capability but lacking a bit in that X factor (big TT seems to be a common statement). I absolutely love the Aston and driving it is always special, its not the fastest or best car in its class but it does have something 'special' about it - hence keen to get some fresh perspectives on people that have owned both.

Thanks
Big leap performance wise from 4.3 Aston to gallardo.ignore the big tt statements it's a way for Ferrari owners to justify their purchase by demeaning the competition.
I went from a gallardo into a DBS ,both are equally special but in different ways ,I will admit my heart beat faster getting into the gallardo .

UH-Matt

2,173 posts

271 months

Thursday 20th September 2012
quotequote all
Do it.

Have had all 3 cars mentioned (V8V, Gallardo, 430) and the Gallardo was the quickest.

V8V lovely looking thing, nice noise, very slow in comparison.

Gallardo, massive presence, very very quick, so easy to drive quickly thanks to 4x4.

430, not quite as obvious as the Gallardo (girlfriend preferred this), still very quick (felt a tad slower), probably more fun to drive due to rear wheel drive.

cronk-flakes

3,480 posts

284 months

Thursday 20th September 2012
quotequote all
I've driven both, and the Gallardo was incredible... The looks, the sound, and the overall feeling of getting into a Lamborghini, surpassed the Aston, in my opinion.

Do it and then post pictures! thumbup

JCB123

2,265 posts

227 months

Thursday 20th September 2012
quotequote all
I've driven both back-to-back (thanks 6th gear), and although I love both epically, the Lambo is just so much better in every sense; noise, presence, appearance, Lambo badge, speed, nimble, power response etc.

The V8V could've been a contender in the F430 and Gallardo battle all those years ago, but Aston failed in most areas with the exception of it being a beautiful car.

Sorry I can't comment on ownership of either though....

ripley500

Original Poster:

390 posts

242 months

Thursday 20th September 2012
quotequote all
Many thanks for constructive replies. Reassuring to hear that inside the Lambo 'feels' special as I must admit one of my concerns has been that from the inside the overall look & quality was not up to Aston standards, with the Aston feeling more bespoke.

It seems from this forum that 06 onwards are highly preferred/more reliable/better clutch - most seem to be egear with very few manuals around. Is there anywhere I can find what the options list is/was and are there any must-have options?

Thanks

70proof

6,158 posts

186 months

Thursday 20th September 2012
quotequote all
imo, most important thing is colour......
other spec then is dependant on you, and how long you intend to keep the car, and what it costs you....

some will say e gear is essential, in a spyder maybe it suits the character, but if the car will be kept a couple of years, don;t think its an issue if manual, it may take longer to sell, but will sell.... if you want to flip the car quickly, then e gear is essential....

not used my satnav/stereo in a year...
lifting gear is handy, but not essential....
reversing camera is not essential....
callisto wheels essential imho....

branding pack looks nice, alloy to steering wheel also...

the yellow car you are looking at is spartan in spec, but then if it is mint, with a good history, i would rather buy a low spec car in the right colour than a higher spec higher mileage car thats the wrong colour or less well cared for..... market is packed with spyders at the moment.... so not an easy choice..... a year adds 3-4k, e gear 3-4k... hth, also, once a car passes 20k miles, seems to take longer to sell, just an observation....wrong colour makes harder to sell.... light silver, blue, red.... again, imho...

Edited by 70proof on Thursday 20th September 22:25

lambo_xx

2,199 posts

228 months

Thursday 20th September 2012
quotequote all
ripley500 said:
Anyone on here gone from V8 Vantage to Gallardo (or vise vera)? - I'd be very interested to hear your thoughts/comments.

Thinking about changing my 4.3 V8 to 06+ Gallardo and reading the various posts on here it seems the Gallardo can be summed up with - great style, presence and capability but lacking a bit in that X factor (big TT seems to be a common statement). I absolutely love the Aston and driving it is always special, its not the fastest or best car in its class but it does have something 'special' about it - hence keen to get some fresh perspectives on people that have owned both.

Thanks
Haven't driven a V8 Vanatge but my Mother has a DB9 which I've driven extensively and I have a Gallardo and an Audi TT so hopefully should be able to provide some input.

The big TT statement is ridiculous, my TT is far comfier than the Gallardo for a start! Seriously though the Gallardo is fab! My Dad has an 05 car which he hardly ever uses, so I use it ever now and then to keep it ticking over and I bought a LP570 Superleggera in May which I've been using more or less as a daily driver. The Gallardo is going to feel much faster than your Aston and thanks to the 4 wheel drive it's all very usable. I had a 430 before I bought my Superleg and although it was great, it did squirm around if the road was cold/wet, whereas you really would need to be going for it to lose it in the Lambo.

E-gear Vs Manual is a ongoing debate. In a nut shell it's down to personal preference so try both and see what you feel. There are less manual 06> cars however they are still about. As for spec, Sat Nav is a must in my opinion, as it looks so much nicer than the tape deck they give you as standard yuck Most cars have the Sat Nav though. Lifting gear is handy but reasonably rare. The glass engine cover is nice as well.

70proof

6,158 posts

186 months

Thursday 20th September 2012
quotequote all
ripley500 said:
Reassuring to hear that inside the Lambo 'feels' special as I must admit one of my concerns has been that from the inside the overall look & quality was not up to Aston standards, with the Aston feeling more bespoke.
it's special 'coz its a lambo, not because of how it looks or feels or the materials.....

ripley500

Original Poster:

390 posts

242 months

Thursday 20th September 2012
quotequote all
70proof said:
some will say e gear is essential, in a spyder maybe it suits the character, but if the car will be kept a couple of years, don;t think its an issue if manual, it may take longer to sell, but will sell.... if you want to flip the car quickly, then e gear is essential....


Edited by 70proof on Thursday 20th September 21:06
Is it really that hard to sell on a manual? I'm thinking that I'd likely keep the car for 9-12 months and then change so buying the right car to 'easily' sell on later is a factor for me.

70proof

6,158 posts

186 months

Thursday 20th September 2012
quotequote all
ripley500 said:
Is it really that hard to sell on a manual? I'm thinking that I'd likely keep the car for 9-12 months and then change so buying the right car to 'easily' sell on later is a factor for me.
not hard if priced right, and given e gear has its flaws and detractors....
when talk is specific to the gallardo, most here will say the e gear is better than a manual....
then when discussed regards to other car's systems, then e gear is ste.... yet manual is good as any box..

bit like the while 2wd and 4wd lp cars..... amongst lp discussions, the 4wd is better as more sure fotted, but then the fezza is better 'cos it;s 2wd and more raw/exciting/less sure footed.... u can;t win...


Edited by 70proof on Thursday 20th September 21:45