Ferrari 575M with incomplete service history - deal breaker?
Ferrari 575M with incomplete service history - deal breaker?
Author
Discussion

roygarth

Original Poster:

2,674 posts

279 months

Friday 21st September 2012
quotequote all
The service history is:

10/03/2005 Annual service HR Owen 1,555 miles
21/02/2006 Annual service Graypaul 2,836 miles
20/05/2007 6,250 service and cambelts Charles Hurst 5,416 miles
18/06/2010 Annual service Graypaul 10,395 miles
22/11/2011 Annual service Graypaul 13,940 miles

Current mileage 16,000.

So 3 year gap between 2007 and 2010 no MOT certificates and can't check online as was in Northern Ireland at this time.

Run a mile?


Davo456gt

696 posts

180 months

Friday 21st September 2012
quotequote all
cam belt change due - get that done as part of the deal, and get a good PPI

Warranty ??

johnnyreggae

3,175 posts

191 months

Friday 21st September 2012
quotequote all
Have you asked Charles Hurst if they serviced in the gap ? As noted above PPI & cambelt service & away - the most recent are the most important

RoyaleDetailing

534 posts

277 months

Saturday 22nd September 2012
quotequote all
Personally i dont think its a deal breaker. Get the PPI done to make sure the car is currently mechanically fine. Also get it factored into the price so you dont lose out when you come to sell. If its an F1 you can verify the mileage off the gearbox.

Pork

9,455 posts

265 months

Saturday 22nd September 2012
quotequote all
I would want assurances that the gap wasnt a time it was ragged around Europe. Surely, either the miles didnt move or its been serviced somewhere? Would have thought there's limited places wit would have gone to, particularly if in Ireland.

4leks

177 posts

206 months

Saturday 22nd September 2012
quotequote all
I personally would not touch it unless heavy discount is negotiated. My 2p

Kilsoj

163 posts

194 months

Sunday 23rd September 2012
quotequote all
being in northern ireland, there are only two garages that i know of who service ferrari, and i think the same applies for the whole of ireland

hursts

and beechill garage belfast who are independent specialists

i dont think there is really anyone else, so i would check with both of them and take it from there

Sudesh

561 posts

238 months

Sunday 23rd September 2012
quotequote all
roygarth said:
The service history is:

10/03/2005 Annual service HR Owen 1,555 miles
21/02/2006 Annual service Graypaul 2,836 miles
20/05/2007 6,250 service and cambelts Charles Hurst 5,416 miles
18/06/2010 Annual service Graypaul 10,395 miles
22/11/2011 Annual service Graypaul 13,940 miles

Current mileage 16,000.

So 3 year gap between 2007 and 2010 no MOT certificates and can't check online as was in Northern Ireland at this time.

Run a mile?
Hi,

Send me a PM with the car reg and I might be able to check something out for you as im in Northern Ireland; there are a few independent service specialists here too, but would be surprised if they didn't stamp the book.

456mgt

2,518 posts

297 months

Sunday 23rd September 2012
quotequote all
The curious bit is no MOTs for the missing period. It's done a fair few miles in that interval and I don't know how it was taxed without it. Have you contacted the owner for that period? I suspect it wasn't serviced at all. I'd avoid it; regardless of the reason, it doesn't sound like tlc and will be a liability to move on. Unless of course it's super cheap!

jhoneyball

1,803 posts

307 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
Pork said:
I would want assurances that the gap wasnt a time it was ragged around Europe. Surely, either the miles didnt move or its been serviced somewhere? Would have thought there's limited places wit would have gone to, particularly if in Ireland.
Are you *seriously* suggesting that a modern Ferrari cant be driven for under 5k miles without falling apart?

Rant on: it absolutely *astonishes* me that Ferrari customers fell for the whole cambelt scam, many (maybe even most) having perfectly unworn cambelts changed at a few thousand miles of use only. Naturally, this involved an engine-out workshop experience, pushing vast amounts of revenue through the dealers. It was a scam on an almost intergalactic scale. Now they cant do this any more (california legislation on servicing, if i remember right), they have moved on to F1 clutches, going from a very well engineered solution that could and should last 50-80k miles (with careful use) to something that eats itself often in well under 10k miles. How is this good engineering? But still you keep buying into this, and willingly letting Ferrari bend you over and rape you senseless. Frankly I am amazed.

Rant off.

Pork

9,455 posts

265 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
jhoneyball said:
you *seriously* suggesting that a modern Ferrari cant be driven for under 5k miles without falling apart?

Rant on: it absolutely *astonishes* me that Ferrari customers fell for the whole cambelt scam, many (maybe even most) having perfectly unworn cambelts changed at a few thousand miles of use only. Naturally, this involved an engine-out workshop experience, pushing vast amounts of revenue through the dealers. It was a scam on an almost intergalactic scale. Now they cant do this any more (california legislation on servicing, if i remember right), they have moved on to F1 clutches, going from a very well engineered solution that could and should last 50-80k miles (with careful use) to something that eats itself often in well under 10k miles. How is this good engineering? But still you keep buying into this, and willingly letting Ferrari bend you over and rape you senseless. Frankly I am amazed.

Rant off.
No. What I am suggesting is in the time its not got history doesn't mean it hasnt been used. A car with 3 years missing history could easily have covered 30k miles.


Mind, even full history doesn't verify the miles but if I bought a car with a large gap in the history, the price would need to reflect this - not because cambelt deterioration or whatever, but merely there's a greater opportunity for the milage to be inaccurate.

I know some people are overly sensitive but in quoting me, you're barking up the wrong tree. smile


Edited by Pork on Monday 24th September 09:40

jhoneyball

1,803 posts

307 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
Pork said:
No. What I am suggesting is in the time its not got history doesn't mean it hasnt been used. A car with 3 years missing history could easily have covered 30k miles.


Mind, even full history doesn't verify the miles but if I bought a car with a large gap in the history, the price would need to reflect this - not because cambelt deterioration or whatever, but merely there's a greater opportunity for the milage to be inaccurate.

I know some people are overly sensitive but in quoting me, you're barking up the wrong tree. smile
ok ok, sorry, it was a rant that has been burbling under the surface wanting to explode for a while.

Surely a modern ferrari has mileage recordings which cannot be hacked? This isnt rocked science

Cerbieherts

1,652 posts

172 months

Monday 24th September 2012
quotequote all
The f1 equipped cars store the mileage in the gearbox control unit, expressed as total kilometres travelled. The engine doesn't get removed in the v12 for belt changes, however it is important to note that the belt tensioner bearings are prone to failure more than belts prematurely failing, so get it done if you go ahead with the purchase. As for the comment about unnecessary servicing, well I've built a fair few motors that have grenaded themselves due to pump/tensioner failure on f-cars, so it's a risk that's up to the owner. And yes, F1 clutches should definitely last more than 10k, and premature failure is very often down to poor setup at time of install, or damaged flywheels and slave bearings not being replaced at the same time...