Discussion
Jules360 said:
I desperately wanted the 12c. Drove it, didn't like it then tried the 458, expecting to hate that also. Bought one immediately (and drive it most days)
Exactly the same here - would have loved to 'Buy British', and even liked the subtler styling - but, the 458 experience clinched it for me.The 12c for me, I find the 458 (and all the current Ferrari lineup) far too 'busy' for lack of a better word but to some that would translate to the car being more exicting to drive etc. The overall build quality/engineering integrity of the car I personally find better as well. Actual performance of the cars really didn't even come into it and I think nowadays no one really doubts the 12c is the faster car but for me the 12c was just by a good bit the more enjoyable car all round to drive. I can however see why many people would prefer the 458 though.
The only way one can really judge is to drive both and decide for yourself. The cars will appeal to different people despite being positioned in the same segment of the market.
The only way one can really judge is to drive both and decide for yourself. The cars will appeal to different people despite being positioned in the same segment of the market.
Was in the market for a 458 or McLaren and to my surprise the answer was
Neither - Lamborghini Gallardo spyder LP570-4 Performante Edizione Tecnica is what you want
Went to drive a 458 and a McLaren MP4 12C. Ended up driving all 3 cars back to back and bar far the best FUN for just sunny sunday morning driving, which is what I want from a 4th car, was the Lamorghini which was completely the opposite from my pre test drive thoughts and opinions. Even paid more for the old Lambo than the other 2
McLaren was a great piece of engineering and extremely fast but TBH sounded dreadful the Ferrari 458 was somewhere in between the clinical Mac and the outrageous and fun Lambo
As a daily drive I think the 458 just edges out the McLaren but the Mac is definitely better value for money.
As the most FUN car the Lambo won by a country mile. Looks and a sound to die for and totally admired by all the general public on the test drive whereas the Mac and 458 hardly got a look ?
Neither - Lamborghini Gallardo spyder LP570-4 Performante Edizione Tecnica is what you want
Went to drive a 458 and a McLaren MP4 12C. Ended up driving all 3 cars back to back and bar far the best FUN for just sunny sunday morning driving, which is what I want from a 4th car, was the Lamorghini which was completely the opposite from my pre test drive thoughts and opinions. Even paid more for the old Lambo than the other 2
McLaren was a great piece of engineering and extremely fast but TBH sounded dreadful the Ferrari 458 was somewhere in between the clinical Mac and the outrageous and fun Lambo
As a daily drive I think the 458 just edges out the McLaren but the Mac is definitely better value for money.
As the most FUN car the Lambo won by a country mile. Looks and a sound to die for and totally admired by all the general public on the test drive whereas the Mac and 458 hardly got a look ?
JazzyO said:
I like the post by GRBF430F1 or whatever his moniker is (really dude, pick something easier...
)
Whilst I would never make the same choice, I really applaud someone who tries them all and chooses what fits best. It would be a sad world if everyone has to agree all the time.
Onno
Thats how I roll lol
)Whilst I would never make the same choice, I really applaud someone who tries them all and chooses what fits best. It would be a sad world if everyone has to agree all the time.
Onno
I'm not saying the Lambo was the best car or best piece of engineering but for what I was looking for it ticked far more boxes than the other 2 cars.
Bearing in mind its a convertible and I only drove it in the wet and cold with the roof up, the top down summer experience is going to be even more exciting, which was something neither of the other 2 coupes can even offer.
If I could afford a 458 spider then I concede I would of probably bought that but the Lambo is such a fantastic wow car if its not a daily driver or long haul cruiser you are looking for it should be top of your list ahead of the other 2 coupes.
Its a really really special car and makes me smile and chuckle continuously
458
The problem with the 12C was even though it felt 10 times faster than the Ferrari, just didn't have any soul to it. Just very digital.
Oh and when we were on the Supercardriver Euro tour this year, the 2 Mclarens on it took it in turns in breaking down each day. All of the Ferraris, Bugatti Veyron SS, Porsches were all faultless. (The Dodge Viper only just made it out of the UK before breaking down)
So Ferrari for fun and weirdly... reliability.
The problem with the 12C was even though it felt 10 times faster than the Ferrari, just didn't have any soul to it. Just very digital.
Oh and when we were on the Supercardriver Euro tour this year, the 2 Mclarens on it took it in turns in breaking down each day. All of the Ferraris, Bugatti Veyron SS, Porsches were all faultless. (The Dodge Viper only just made it out of the UK before breaking down)
So Ferrari for fun and weirdly... reliability.
Gassing Station | Supercar General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


