612. California, DBS
612. California, DBS
Author
Discussion

SlartiF430

Original Poster:

1,828 posts

185 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
I'll be looking at getting 4 seater fun car in the summer. I'm looking at 612, California and DBS. I don't need proper back seats - my daughter is still an infant so ok for another couple of years. I'm completely torn on which one to go for. I love the look of the DBS, I love the modern features/ look of the Cali and there's something about the v12 fez that I also like but I can't put a finger on what. So far, from what I've read, the negatives of each : 612 = dated, high running costs. Cali = doesn't look like a wild Ferrari eg I'd miss the huge air splitter that gives my 430 rear end that bonkers Ferrari look. DBS = a little too grown up(?).

What do the supercar collective think?

Mario149

7,789 posts

209 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
From a financial PoV, you've still got an awful lot of money to lose on a Cali or DBS. Much as I like them both, it'd be the 612 for me despite the fact that it's the least pretty of the 3. Buy one in the mid £50ks and even though you'll spend say £1k more on servicing per year than the other 2, you'll still be in the black compared to them overall.

That said, I am particularly 'residuals focussed' when it comes to my purchases as I always have half an eye on what I might fancy next, so while I may have the means to spend more and/or buy newer than sometimes I do, I choose not to in order to maximise my potential pot size for the purchase after (all my purchases are cash), which may not be as important to you

Adz The Rat

19,159 posts

240 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
IMO, who cares what it costs to service or how much you lose on it?

Just get whichever will be the most fun, and that is the California by a mile.

Absolutely fantastic cars, definitely not a "soft Ferrari" as some people think. Very very fast, a great drive, and the bullet crack when changing up on full throttle is addictive.

jimmyslr

824 posts

304 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
SlartiF430 said:
I'll be looking at getting 4 seater fun car in the summer. I'm looking at 612, California and DBS. I don't need proper back seats - my daughter is still an infant so ok for another couple of years. I'm completely torn on which one to go for. I love the look of the DBS, I love the modern features/ look of the Cali and there's something about the v12 fez that I also like but I can't put a finger on what. So far, from what I've read, the negatives of each : 612 = dated, high running costs. Cali = doesn't look like a wild Ferrari eg I'd miss the huge air splitter that gives my 430 rear end that bonkers Ferrari look. DBS = a little too grown up(?).

What do the supercar collective think?
I thought hard about this. The rear seats in a Cali or DBS don't really exist. I wonder if a child seat would result in it fouling the front seat and/or even an infant having feet rammed against the seat in front. I'd suggest trying your car seat to see how it fits with Mini Slarti onboard. Feet rammed against the front seat can't be good in a prang.

I ended up with a 612 for this reason, albeit my kids are bigger. My 3 year old in a car seat has his feet all over the back of my seat (no shoes allowed for this reason) yesterday and the 612 has loads more room.

The Maser GTS gets lots of love and is a decent 4 seater. Wasn't a Fezza though so didn't excite me so much. V pretty though.

James

prashan

256 posts

226 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
Would definitely recommend the 612. Having owned one for 2 years, there's nothing quite like the sound of a V12 Ferrari. Mine resold again through Tom Hartley recently so market still has an interest and most cars would have taken the biggest depreciation hit...try and go for one with the HGTS pack.sports exhaust transforms the car...and oh yes, carries 4 adults with ease.

Prashan

TISPKJ

3,780 posts

238 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
I guess as said above, really depends how much rear room you need, some mixed opinions on this forum regards putting kids in the back from memory.
As a fun car if you can live with the rear room then Cali it is.
Search on here for Novitech fitted wheels I think it was, that will make your mind up for you :-)

Bluebottle911

815 posts

226 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
Adz The Rat said:
IMO, who cares what it costs to service or how much you lose on it?

Just get whichever will be the most fun, and that is the California by a mile.

Absolutely fantastic cars, definitely not a "soft Ferrari" as some people think. Very very fast, a great drive, and the bullet crack when changing up on full throttle is addictive.
+1. If you can afford the Cali, go for it. Alternatively, stick with 430 and put infant in boot.

Mario149

7,789 posts

209 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
Adz The Rat said:
IMO, who cares what it costs to service or how much you lose on it?
With the best will in the world, unless you happen to be a Saudi Sheikh or someone similarly rolling in it, that is at best naive advice.

I know that if I owned any of those cars I'd have a ball. I might like one a tad more than the other, but at the end of the day, I'd still have a great time in any of them. Why lose more money than you have to unless there's one you desperately want above the others?

cayman-black

13,268 posts

247 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
DBS. Great value for money!

Davo456gt

696 posts

180 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
what do you want to use the back seats for ?

California useless in rear if your over 6 feet as a driver.
DBS I think is the same size internally as an original Vanquish - so you may struggle if your kids have legs
612 is a full four seater of the 3, but isn't too everyone's tastes.

You may want to take a look at the 456GT - not that I'm bias, but it has more space than the first two.
I almost changed it for a Vanquish last year, but gave up when I saw the lack of rear leg room.

haroonok

74 posts

244 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
irrespective of rear seats a 612 is just a fantastic car to own and drive.

Chad_Hugo

680 posts

209 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
If it's a fun car for spring/summer and rear seats aren't a major concern as you mentioned, Cali for sure.

Doesn't always photograph so well, but stunning in the flesh (like all V8 Ferrari's), looks wise to me it's a lot more fun, sporty, sexy, than the DBS, which is a beautiful car but as you pointed out does look a lot more 'mature'.

Comparing 2009 examples of DBS/Cali with similar miles the price difference isn't huge at all, could be less than 10%, it's hard to say how far along the depreciation curve the Cali is but for sure it's taken a big hit already being 4 years old so I don't think you will do too badly out of it at all. Value wise it's held up far better than I expected.

612 might be less of a risk depreciation wise, but in my opinion 4 seat advantage aside it does look a bit dated and the styling lets it down. Very different car of course so not really comparing like for like there.

P14SMM

230 posts

186 months

Sunday 1st December 2013
quotequote all
Had a DBS and great car! Looked at a Cali and also great car , 612 is butt ugly and I've just sold a Maserati grandcabrio sport got look at one and drive it but make sure it's the sport as they are a great car, sound good and offer a good back seat! Stunning with the roof down and I only got £71500 for a 62 plate with every option and 6k miles so now very good value for a £115 car!!

Colossus

337 posts

245 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
Think you would struggle with a baby seat in either the Cali or DBS. 612 may have the Ferrari V12, but I simply can't get over the looks and it is now quite dated. Would second a Maser GT Sport, fabulous all round car that takes a baby seat (or two!) with ease. One of the best sounding cars around at any price and incredibly good value for what you are getting. Cabrio is fabulous but has no useable boot, so may struggle if you need to carry baby buggy etc. They are now also doing the MC Stradale with 4 seats if you want a more hardcore experience, seriously tempting proposition!

C

GusB

275 posts

190 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
If the need for back seats is just for a baby, could't you put them on the parcel shelf in a 599...

GusB

estacion

371 posts

263 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
Mario149 said:
From a financial PoV, you've still got an awful lot of money to lose on a Cali or DBS. Much as I like them both, it'd be the 612 for me despite the fact that it's the least pretty of the 3. Buy one in the mid £50ks and even though you'll spend say £1k more on servicing per year than the other 2, you'll still be in the black compared to them overall.

That said, I am particularly 'residuals focussed' when it comes to my purchases as I always have half an eye on what I might fancy next, so while I may have the means to spend more and/or buy newer than sometimes I do, I choose not to in order to maximise my potential pot size for the purchase after (all my purchases are cash), which may not be as important to you


...least pretty?

rfoster

1,482 posts

285 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
When I first saw the 612 at one of the motor shows I wondered what on earth Ferrari were thinking, after the beauty that was the 456 (in my opinion.) Now I'm a lot older my opinion has completely reversed - I think the 612 is just stunning. It would be my pick of the Ferraris for certain, if I was ever in a position to own and run one. A couple of my customers have had them but found them to be too big for UK roads, they're both in Californias now.

Mario149

7,789 posts

209 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
estacion said:
Mario149 said:
From a financial PoV, you've still got an awful lot of money to lose on a Cali or DBS. Much as I like them both, it'd be the 612 for me despite the fact that it's the least pretty of the 3. Buy one in the mid £50ks and even though you'll spend say £1k more on servicing per year than the other 2, you'll still be in the black compared to them overall.

That said, I am particularly 'residuals focussed' when it comes to my purchases as I always have half an eye on what I might fancy next, so while I may have the means to spend more and/or buy newer than sometimes I do, I choose not to in order to maximise my potential pot size for the purchase after (all my purchases are cash), which may not be as important to you


...least pretty?
You don't have to convince me, I love them! smile Almost bought one just over a year ago, ended up plumping for a 550 instead, mainly for residuals and the manual gearbox as other than that I was in principle happy with either. I do think the 550 is prettier, which was an added bonus, but it wouldn't have been a deal breaker had my opinion on looks been the other way round.

That said, I do think the DBS and the Cali are better looking than the 612, but it wouldn't stop me taking the 612 over either if I was in the OP's position. What I would probably do then would be to run a privately bought 612 for 18 months or so, sell it privately, then do the same with the Aston or Cali, thereby having 2 of the 3 bits of available cake and eating it with minimised amounts of depreciation smile


Edited by Mario149 on Monday 2nd December 13:42

Cheib

25,487 posts

206 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
I agree the 612 is wearing its years well...no idea why. I remember seeing the first one in Monaco years ago and thinking it was "challenging".

LukeyLikey

855 posts

178 months

Monday 2nd December 2013
quotequote all
I owned a Manual DBS (no rear seats) and a California (recently sold). The California is the better car. The noise, the modernity, the gearbox, all make the Ferrari that bit more entertaining.

Looks you have to give to the DBS but the Cali is much better in the flesh than pictures and the difference is not enough to swing it in the DBS' favour.

I took my 11 year old son on a road trip to Scotland in the California this summer, along with my wife. He moaned a bit but not too much. The Aston rear (had a DB9 before the DBS) is pretty similar in size, the 612 is a proper 4 seater but looks pretty big whenever you see them on the road.

On balance, you would regret not choosing the California I think.