550 or Gallardo ??
Author
Discussion

ojo

Original Poster:

162 posts

279 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Different but similar money can't decide ? anyone own or have owned both with experience ... as I've haven't owned a Lambo or front engined Ferrari

also get the feeling that either at £60kish won't depreciate - what do you all think

(I know there is probably a similar question somewhere in the archives but I can't find anything, not that I've looked too hard )


Edited by ojo on Wednesday 11th December 21:18

cgt2

7,497 posts

219 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
550 no question!

JazzyO

1,125 posts

212 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
You should go and drive them and decide what appeals to you. These cars drive totally differently. Both great cars, but very different prospects. In my humble opinion, they are incomparable.


Onno

JazzyO

1,125 posts

212 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
You should go and drive them and decide what appeals to you. These cars drive totally differently. Both great cars, but very different prospects. In my humble opinion, they are incomparable.


Onno

TobyLaRohne

5,793 posts

237 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
What a wonderful problem to have.

I'm not the biggest Ferrari fan but out of those two I'd take the Ferrari, but only if I could find one in identical spec as the one in Bad Boys 2... (yes I'm a loser).

Bluebottle911

815 posts

226 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
JazzyO said:
You should go and drive them and decide what appeals to you. These cars drive totally differently. Both great cars, but very different prospects. In my humble opinion, they are incomparable.
Onno
I would second that. It's a bit like comparing Chablis and Sauternes: both are white wines, but you wouldn't want Sauternes with your grilled sole any more than Chablis with your rice pudding, would you?

Like Onno, I opted for the 550, but then he has a 458 in his garage, too!

Claret Badger

222 posts

199 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
I had the same first world problem and opted for a 550.

I think the depreciation going forward will be less on a 550, they are also rarer and less 'flash' and possibly even a bit more practical too. I dont think the Gallardo as a newer car and an Audi is seen as necessarily being more reliable either.

The Gallardo is however to me the prettier car and will draw more attention, if thats what you want. It sounds more spectacular too.

There was also the small reason of not buying a Gallardo as at 6'6" I couldnt fit in one!

prashan

256 posts

226 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
A great problem to have... Having had a 612 and now a Gallardo Spyder...I love them both and but they are entirely different cars...as per other comments above, I'm sure the same with the 550.....

prashan

256 posts

226 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
A great problem to have... Having had a 612 and now a Gallardo Spyder...I love them both and but they are entirely different cars...as per other comments above, I'm sure the same with the 550.....

DevonPaul

1,761 posts

168 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
Both.

No, seriously.

Both are likely to hold, gain, or lose value at a very similar rate, so pick a good one, look after it, and in 12 months (or even 15 months as I suspect G prices are more winter dependant than 550s) swap then it for the other.

Paul

ojo

Original Poster:

162 posts

279 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for the comments - trying them out seems the thing to do they are both so different -- then again a 612 is tempting ??

DUMBO100

1,878 posts

215 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
Sadly I'm not in your position but I have driven both cars and the 550 is a beautiful last of the breed GT whereas the Gallardo is a proper white knuckle fast car driving experience. I would be tempted towards the 550 especially if it has the manual gear box but maybe I'm getting old

GRBF430F1

4,843 posts

201 months

Friday 13th December 2013
quotequote all
2 totally different cars and both fantastic but you need to decide if you want a GT car or a sports car.

I love the DBS but its not as exciting as a real sports car. When I can no longer get in and out of my cars easily I'm sure I will get one but for the time being I would take the Gallardo

roygarth

2,674 posts

279 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
I find my 550 a tad boring compared with the 430 I had before. For a cruise down to Monaco the 550 wins hands down. But for a 20 minute thrash to get the milk its the mad loud frenetic buzz of 430 I'm after. And I do the latter far more often!

As has been said you really must drive both.

jcf

159 posts

261 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
Bluebottle911 said:
I would second that. It's a bit like comparing Chablis and Sauternes: both are white wines, but you wouldn't want Sauternes with your grilled sole any more than Chablis with your rice pudding, would you?
1st world dilemma number 164?

Chad_Hugo

680 posts

209 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
Depends on if it's a very early high miles/in need of TLC Gallardo your talking about, or if a 06+ e-gear car (which would start at about 70k?) is possible.

If so, I would buy the Gallardo without any hesitation.

The Gallardo is a super car experience, with all the drama and excitement that brings, it's also one of the best looking cars in recent times, not overcomplicated or OTT like some more recent offerings, it's aged remarkable well in my opinion and a 8 year old example still looks amazing and has that road presence and wow factor.

It really is a beautiful car from every angle. It is considered very 'flash' however, and will attract quite a lot of attention. Far more than a 550 for sure.

Any good 04-06 example with FSH and decent spec (glass engine cover is a huge bonus)/reasonable miles should not really depreciate beyond current levels if you sell privately.

Mario149

7,789 posts

209 months

Monday 30th December 2013
quotequote all
Funnily enough, if I was to get out of my 550 and get into something in the same-ish price bracket it'd prob be a Gallardo just because they're a completely different beast to the 550 smile