F430 to Scuderia..???
F430 to Scuderia..???
Author
Discussion

kbooker

Original Poster:

728 posts

170 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
Hello

I've not had my 430 all that long but I'm increasingly tempted to change to a Scud'

Has anyone made the change?

Please offer up opinions for and against, I'm all ears....ears

Beaver

1,056 posts

315 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
Yes, I did that.
Drove my F430 to the dealer to p/x it and collect the Scuderia, on the way to the dealer I thought to myself that I must be mad.
Surely it couldn't be that much better?

Dropped 430 off, drove home in Scuderia.
Took it easy for about an hour, then changed down and accelerated.

The noise. Just incredible noise.

That and the acceleration made the difference worth it to me, and then some.
Plus the gearchange is soooo much better (and I think better in a more engaging way than a 458 'box).

Do it.

Alpinestars

13,954 posts

275 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
What he said ^.

Great car, easily better than a standard 430.

The noise, seats, acceleration, looks, all make for a car which is more engaging than a 458.

red_duke

826 posts

212 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
I disagree.

Having test driven a 2009 Scud it simply wasn't worth the £70,000 cost to change from my F430.

Dblue

3,288 posts

231 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
red_duke said:
I disagree.

Having test driven a 2009 Scud it simply wasn't worth the £70,000 cost to change from my F430.
Yup, have to agree with this. The Scuderia is fabulous but its not worth anything like the premium on a nice 430 IMHO. Real man maths stuff to justify that.
Course its arguable the Scud may actually appreciate in value a little which helps justify it more.

GRBF430F1

4,843 posts

201 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
Dblue said:
Yup, have to agree with this. The Scuderia is fabulous but its not worth anything like the premium on a nice 430 IMHO. Real man maths stuff to justify that.
Course its arguable the Scud may actually appreciate in value a little which helps justify it more.
Agree with both comments above. If you are in a standard F430 justifying £70,000 or twice the price to upgrade is an awful lot of money for what probably amounts to a 10% difference. I seriously thought about it when the cost to change was £40,000 and didn't do it.

If you were coming from another car I think psychologically its easier to swallow.

When I changed from my 2009 F430F1 spider to the LP570-4 Performante I remember a comment from a Gallardo owner saying he couldn't justify the extra to get into an LP model.

At least if you change model or brand you feel you have upgraded

Alpinestars

13,954 posts

275 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
It's always difficult to justify things in £ and $. Is a CS worth over 100k more than a 360?

It's a much better car in my view. 70k better? Given it is likely to appreciate and the 430 isn't, it's not a difficult one to justify.

isaldiri

25,281 posts

199 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Dblue said:
Yup, have to agree with this. The Scuderia is fabulous but its not worth anything like the premium on a nice 430 IMHO. Real man maths stuff to justify that.
Course its arguable the Scud may actually appreciate in value a little which helps justify it more.
Think i have to agree with alpinestars here. The scud is much better imo, would definitely be very tempted to make the change if I was the op even at that price differential. Not an easy one to justify I admit even with liberal use of man maths...

ZeusF

377 posts

154 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
The gearshift change is a big difference but remember that this only requires a software upgrade to fix.

There are of course other differences but not £70k worth.

UH-Matt

2,173 posts

271 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
I also agree the gap in price doesn't quite make this worthwhile.

I very very nearly did it, and I do love the Scud, but I just couldn't justify it to myself when you are then so close to 458 or MP4-12C money!

Ended up putting my sensible cap on and moving from the 430 back to an LP560 which has satisfied my craving for nearly a year, but now I am itching for a 458 again.

We all have a disease unfortunately, so if you need to scratch the Scud itch then go for it, or be less boring and try something totally different wink

Russell996

494 posts

160 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
ZeusF said:
The gearshift change is a big difference but remember that this only requires a software upgrade to fix.
You cannot upgrade to a Scud gearshift with a software fix! (you are thinking of 360 upgrade to CS spec)

voicey

2,494 posts

218 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Russell996 said:
ZeusF said:
The gearshift change is a big difference but remember that this only requires a software upgrade to fix.
You cannot upgrade to a Scud gearshift with a software fix! (you are thinking of 360 upgrade to CS spec)
Agreed, the gearbox internals are different.

Alpinestars

13,954 posts

275 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Can someone list the 100k differences between a 360 and CS please. It's missing the point somewhat.

UH-Matt

2,173 posts

271 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Alpinestars said:
Can someone list the 100k differences between a 360 and CS please. It's missing the point somewhat.
The CS is more iconic than the Scud will ever be. I also think the gap between the 360 and the CS is a million miles compared to 430 to Scud.

sone

4,612 posts

269 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Went from CS to Scud myself, previous to that standard 430. Out of the three I'd take the CS to be honest and that's not based on cost.
Scud great car but I felt you had to be really getting a move on to get that Ferrari noise so I found myself pushing harder perhaps when I shouldn't. CS was a blast even at low speeds a much prettier car that the 430/Scud in my opinion.
So I digress, is the move from 430 to Scud worthwhile I'd say yes much better car to drive and after all you'll get most of your money back when you come to sell it so as long as you can afford the initial outlay and you buy the right car!.

ZeusF

377 posts

154 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Russell996 said:
ZeusF said:
The gearshift change is a big difference but remember that this only requires a software upgrade to fix.
You cannot upgrade to a Scud gearshift with a software fix! (you are thinking of 360 upgrade to CS spec)
My quote was in reference to fixing the lag of the shift and you can fix that with a software upgrade.
The f430 runs 62% shift with a safety factor allowance of 84% giving huge gains in shift speed.

voicey

2,494 posts

218 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
ZeusF said:
My quote was in reference to fixing the lag of the shift and you can fix that with a software upgrade.
The f430 runs 62% shift with a safety factor allowance of 84% giving huge gains in shift speed.
Are you saying that you can safely get the shift time of a stock 430 down to that of a Scud with a simple software update?

hazy

1,174 posts

299 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Definately worth it, even simple maths support the change. An F430 will depreciate, a scud will appreciate, the only limiting factor is if you can afford the extra money in the first place, if you can do it, Scud will be free motoring over the next 5 years.

dudlow

196 posts

254 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
The Scud is theatre every time you get in, strap up, and drive it. You just don't get that with a standard 430.
It depends how much that is worth to you.

Russell996

494 posts

160 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
ZeusF said:
My quote was in reference to fixing the lag of the shift and you can fix that with a software upgrade.
The f430 runs 62% shift with a safety factor allowance of 84% giving huge gains in shift speed.
Can you explain?