Ownership Costs
Author
Discussion

Mabbx

Original Poster:

204 posts

240 months

Thursday 13th March 2014
quotequote all
Hi all,

One of my bugs (as I am sure you also) is the ongoing costs for a super/high performace car. Again, as I am sure as all of you, I dredded taking my cars to be serviced, tyres etc, to then be handed an astonomical bill for the service and then recomendations that needed doing. Easy answer is, if you can't afford to maintain the car, don't buy one. I can afford it, but when having the car for the weekend only (3K max mileage per annum) is it easy to start justifying getting rid of the car. My question is: what is the most cost effective super/high peformance car to up-keep, maintain. I appreciate that taking to an independant is usually cheaper (if the independant has a good repuatation) I suppose to narrow it down, servicing - how frequent, and costs, clutches, any other quick wear. My budget is around £50K and the cars in question are:

Audi R8 - V8
Ferrari 612
Ferrari 360
Ferrari 456
Ferrari 308 GTB
Nissan GTR
Porsche 997 C2S
Porsche 996 Turbo
Porsche 997 Turbo
Lambo Gallardo (out of budget but intersted in costs)
any others ?

Any experiences or tales much appreciated

Thanks

runner911

631 posts

274 months

Thursday 13th March 2014
quotequote all
I've had the pleasure of owning three 911's, two Aston Martins, a Lamborghini Gallardo, and an Audi R8.

When it came to servicing/parts/repairs, the Lamborghini was in different league as regards cost, i.e. ridiculously expensive.

The cheapest has been the Audi R8.

johnnyreggae

3,175 posts

191 months

Thursday 13th March 2014
quotequote all
Having read your November replies it has to be said that many folk buy a 4 seater thinking they can take the family out but it rarely seems to work that way as there's just too much to do and whatever you might want to take the car to your family may not enjoy

In event terms they just will be better with a Ferrari - thats why its an exclusive brand

Which means 308 or 360 - and that then will be affected by your personal preferences (not that there are any 308s for sale any more but you get my drift) - either way budget a few grand a year for everything

lamboman100

1,445 posts

152 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
The Audi, Porsches and Nissan on that list are the cheapest to run. But they are also the most boring or the least prestigious. As with most things, you get what you pay for etc.

AmoCS

1,205 posts

250 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
Read this buyers guide for the Ferrari 360.

http://www.challengestradale.co.uk/cs10.htm

JoyZipper

291 posts

215 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
johnnyreggae said:
Having read your November replies it has to be said that many folk buy a 4 seater thinking they can take the family out but it rarely seems to work
I sold my Testarossa when the family came along and bought a 456 as the TR wasn't being used and I do use the 456 for the four of us. Buying a set of baby seats specifically for the car is a good idea as the hassle involved with swapping them from one car to another isn't worth it.

Running a V12 Ferrari isn't going to be cheap. I was lucky with the Testarossa and in my 2/3 years of ownership I probably spent under £1000 per year on servicing (this included an engine out belt service). It did have a hefty £9.5 k spent on it the year before I bought it though.

I have just spent £5.4k on my 456. That was a sharp intake of breath. This was for belts, annual, gearbox service and a few other things that were required to make the car perfect mechanically. Having said that I would not expect to spend over £ 1000 annually going forward.

You may well be able to run a V12 Ferrari on an average of £ 1000 a year, but you need a slush fund just in case anything required attention.

The upside is that owning a V12 Ferrari is (like totally) awesome.

voicey

2,494 posts

218 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
If you're looking at a 360 or F430 then you could take a look at a buyers guide I've been working on. It's a bit of a work in progress but there's a bit of info on the common issues with these cars:

Aldous Voice Ferrari Buying Guide

sa_20v

4,114 posts

262 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
My two cents, Gallardo servicing can be reduced via negotiation, using non-Lamborghini parts (for example, Ford Focus wipers rather than paying £100 per wiper), not paying for unnecessary work the service manager suggests or even makes up (see thread about six year old cars - the issues there are the tip of the iceberg...) and using a specialist for anything but the stamp. The things that worry me over anything else on the Gallardo are engine, gearbox or e-gear failures - these are all ridiculously expensive.

As for other supercars I've had first hand experience of, the Morgan Aeromax, Aero 8, SS and Coupe are all very cheap to run. Engines are BMW, brakes are AP etc - special cars which don't suffer much depreciation and don't have stupidly high service costs - quick round a track too but only if you enjoy oversteer! biggrin

There are some really sensible buys out there right now - cars with low running costs and almost no depreciation. It's not a supercar but the Exige S2 NA is matching inflation and has cost me peanuts the last year. With interest rates so low it's a nice 'fun' place to put some cash in the short term.

Mabbx

Original Poster:

204 posts

240 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the replys so far, believe me, they have been very usefull - keep them coming as this is building up a great picture. I am convinced that a Ferrari is the way forward still, but the £5k service bill would definatly put me in a downward spiral with the car. The Morgan is a very intersting idea. Me and the father-in law went to the factory last year, and as both engineers we found it very intersting and the craftmenship is great to see. I have looked at the Aero 8 but the market seems to be scarce - I will investigate further. Any Porsche comments ???!!

mr_tony

6,351 posts

300 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
I'm on my 4 th Morgan Aero (an Aeromax ) it is undoubtedly the most pain free exotic you can get. Cast iron residuals and sub 1k service and consumables annually.

Its not going to win performance contests against a 430 etc, but its still properly fast, and drives like a big go kart..

I still hanker for a 612 or FF these days so I can take the family with me though...

sjc

16,509 posts

301 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
johnnyreggae said:
Having read your November replies it has to be said that many folk buy a 4 seater thinking they can take the family out but it rarely seems to work that way as there's just too much to do and whatever you might want to take the car to your family may not enjoy
Very true,that's the very reason I'm thinking of selling the Granturismo.
And OP, add a Noble M400 to your list and treat yoruslef to a test drive.

Alpinestars

13,954 posts

275 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
The Porsches will be the cheapest to run, especially the C2. The service comes around every 2 years with the mileage you will do. I've not had an R8 but I think servicing on those can also extend to 2 years.

An older F car could be looked after by an indi, so could also be relatively cheap, but not if anything goes wrong.

The GTR is not as cheap to run as you might think. Servicing is every 6 months unless you get one of the recent cars.

sjc

16,509 posts

301 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
Alpinestars said:

The GTR is not as cheap to run as you might think. Servicing is every 6 months unless you get one of the recent cars.
In fairness his budget would geta yearly service GTR, and in any case once out of warranty the early cars tend to have one biggie a year with the likes of Litchfield, who also do a very comprehensive warranty for the GTR subject to imspection.

DevonPaul

1,761 posts

168 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
mr_tony said:
I'm on my 4 th Morgan Aero (an Aeromax ) it is undoubtedly the most pain free exotic you can get. Cast iron residuals and sub 1k service and consumables annually.

Its not going to win performance contests against a 430 etc, but its still properly fast, and drives like a big go kart..

I still hanker for a 612 or FF these days so I can take the family with me though...
We looked at an Aero. The seats were extremely, erm, "Snug and supportive". So much so that I could squeeze in with my 32 inch waist, but my wife was not quite so fortunate.

Still, the savings on chocolate since then have gone a good way towards the Maserati service costs.

Mabbx

Original Poster:

204 posts

240 months

Sunday 16th March 2014
quotequote all
sjc said:
johnnyreggae said:
Having read your November replies it has to be said that many folk buy a 4 seater thinking they can take the family out but it rarely seems to work that way as there's just too much to do and whatever you might want to take the car to your family may not enjoy
Very true,that's the very reason I'm thinking of selling the Granturismo.
And OP, add a Noble M400 to your list and treat yoruslef to a test drive.
Not sure on the M400, but just had a look in the classifieds and may give them a look. I have 2 small children and my wife and son (6 year old into karting) are petrol heads, I am sure my daughter will learn to like (2)!!. As we do have quite simular intrests when we have a day out - motor racing, car events etc, the car would/could be a family car at the weekends which would get the useage up. When it was just me and the wife, we went out everywere in the TVR's, Porsche's at the weekend, now we have kids I am just worried of when I will actually use it, if it only has two seats ?

Mabbx

Original Poster:

204 posts

240 months

Sunday 16th March 2014
quotequote all
DevonPaul said:
mr_tony said:
I'm on my 4 th Morgan Aero (an Aeromax ) it is undoubtedly the most pain free exotic you can get. Cast iron residuals and sub 1k service and consumables annually.

Its not going to win performance contests against a 430 etc, but its still properly fast, and drives like a big go kart..

I still hanker for a 612 or FF these days so I can take the family with me though...
We looked at an Aero. The seats were extremely, erm, "Snug and supportive". So much so that I could squeeze in with my 32 inch waist, but my wife was not quite so fortunate.

Still, the savings on chocolate since then have gone a good way towards the Maserati service costs.
Just to iron this one out, I am of to look at a series 1 Aero 8 tomorrow as it is local - you never know !! I like the exclusivity of them, V8, BMW engine, british built, maintenance costs, residuals, but not sure it is the car I am hankering for ?? If I put slightly less money into a weekend car, and it does not cost me as much run per annum, does not loose so much over the ownership, it may be the way to go ? Will let you know tomorrow.

StickBreitling

78 posts

157 months

Sunday 16th March 2014
quotequote all
I had an early example of a 612 bought as a Ferrari approved model. The first year was low cost wise. 1500 quid for the annual service. The second year, I experienced wear and tear to parts of the front suspension - ball joints and tie rods. This added up to about 3K of bills. Add to that the regular 1500 quid service. Had a piece of gravel punch a hole in the aircon unit requiring another 1K to fix. Then new set of tyres - the 612 can chew through a set every two years.

Treat the switches with kid gloves. The mirror control switch can be easy to break and will set you back 600 quid for a replacement. Window switches will cost a grand to replace.

As always, one with a good history should reduce the bills somewhat. A superb car and rare sight on the roads.

mr_tony

6,351 posts

300 months

Monday 17th March 2014
quotequote all
Mabbx - good luck in your search.

S1 is basically a thinly disguised race car. Its the rawest. Great drive but a tight cockpit .

S4 is the best Aero - 4.8l v8 and most sorted handling balance a d interior.

Aeromax is the one to buy for cast iron residuals given its profile and collect ability.

New coupe is a great car too. Supersports with targa roof is ok, but I prefer either a full convertible or a coupe to lift out panels...

The experts on these reside on the talkmorgan.co.uk forums ...

Edited by mr_tony on Monday 17th March 19:44

Behemoth

2,105 posts

162 months

Monday 17th March 2014
quotequote all
A good 308 will end up being about £1000 annually to run with a specialist. Some years will be more than 1k, some a lot less. If you do any of the work yourself, you'll be saving £££.

It's a great car for the engineering orientated. It's simple and mechanical and last of the old skool.

As has been said, though, finding any for sale is a challenge. Finding one with recent bills and showing signs of good overall care is even more challenging.

spikeyhead

20,656 posts

228 months

Tuesday 18th March 2014
quotequote all
An annual service for an Atom at a local Honda dealer was £150 last year. Mine is three years old, has had plenty of time on the track and there is still very little wear on the original pads.

Just don't try and drive it for five hours in the pouring rain and expect to feel fresh and lively at the end of it.