Replica Ferrari 430 Suderia
Replica Ferrari 430 Suderia
Author
Discussion

ZeusF

377 posts

154 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
I don't see this as a fail, I think its fab.
I wouldn't buy it but its a work of art for the creator who has obviously put huge effort into building it.

Some people can't afford the real thing so a fake is the only option, just like a watch or bag for the ladies smile

TskM

7 posts

152 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
ZeusF said:
I don't see this as a fail, I think its fab.
I wouldn't buy it but its a work of art for the creator who has obviously put huge effort into building it.

Some people can't afford the real thing so a fake is the only option, just like a watch or bag for the ladies smile
Agreed, wouldn't personally buy it myself either but can appreciate the work gone into it and it being the next best alternative for some. Saw it trying to blend in the gumball supercar meet last month

SteelySteve

350 posts

195 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
Coming back from Spa last year in my (genuine) Challenge Stradale we decided to come back via ferry, we were walking away from the car and overheard a kid and his dad as they walked past the car...

Kid - "Wow that looks good is it a real one or a replica?"

Dad - "That's definately a replica"

My mate has a 430 Spider and was informed by a kid that it wasn't really a 430, it was in fact an MR2

That is the issue with pesky replicas!

Edited by SteelySteve on Tuesday 25th March 14:39

TskM

7 posts

152 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
SteelySteve said:
Coming back from Spa last year in my (genuine) Challenge Stradale we decided to come back via ferry, we were walking away from the car and overheard a kid and his dad as they walked past the car...

Kid - "Wow that looks good is it a real one or a replica?"

Dad - "That's definately a replica"

My mate has a 430 Spider and was informed by a kid that it wasn't really a 430, it was in fact an MR2

That is the issue with pesky replicas!

Edited by SteelySteve on Tuesday 25th March 14:39
Haha oh dear! In my opinion, replicas are quite easy to differentiate from the real deal unless you have no or limited knowledge about cars. Interested to know opinions on buying a replica vs building a replica yourself?

Edited by TskM on Tuesday 25th March 14:55

jimmyslr

824 posts

304 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
Looks pretty good to me. I'm in the market for the real thing right now and have driven a couple in the last few weeks and, at a quick glance, the guy has done a good job. He's a car nut, I'm a car not. Not a fail, just another way of expressing his love for the hobby!

PS Any Scud owners with one in discrete colours (grey, black, blue... and yes I know V8 Ferraris should be red!), with stripe/stereo/LED wheel/dark interior who are thinking of exiting then let me know

Schnellmann

1,893 posts

235 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
To be fair, from a distance that looks quite like a Scud (up close the interior or lack of engine in the back would be a give away).

There is someone in Cambridge that drives around in a 355 rep (based I think on an MR2 - I haven't seen it up close).

What is annoying to me, is that I catch it out of the corner of my eye, turn to admire it...then realise I have been fooled.

ZeusF

377 posts

154 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
Ive heard people call my car replica, quite often in fact but thats been the same for many cars I've owned.
Im not bothered, its part of ownership.

lamboman100

1,445 posts

152 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
Replicas are great for the poor. Premium looks at bargain prices.

Not so good for the rich or semi-rich. They devalue brands and diminish the rarity value.

crostonian

2,427 posts

203 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
Instead of going down the replica route I wonder if anyone has bought a CAT C/D Ferrari or Lambo with engine damage and then installed a more prosaic engine and drivetrain therefore giving the looks but not the running costs - the reason pedalled by most replica to justify their creations.

ZeusF

377 posts

154 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
crostonian said:
Instead of going down the replica route I wonder if anyone has bought a CAT C/D Ferrari or Lambo with engine damage and then installed a more prosaic engine and drivetrain therefore giving the looks but not the running costs - the reason pedalled by most replica to justify their creations.
I destroyed my ferrari, I hit a tree and rolled down a hill with every panel beat to shiat and its back on the road looking like a brand new low mileage fezza.
Its amazing what they can do !

Pioneer

1,351 posts

162 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
lamboman100 said:
Not so good for the rich or semi-rich. They devalue brands and diminish the rarity value.
Aren't they illegal in some countries? I thought if it had the manufacturer's badge and was pretending to be the real thing it could be confiscated - same as fake bags, electronics etc.

KTR

362 posts

201 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
There are worst things on that site:

http://www.supercarscene.com/lord-aleems-garage/

Juber

569 posts

169 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
KTR said:
There are worst things on that site:

http://www.supercarscene.com/lord-aleems-garage/
So cringe - "Lord" is this a self made noble mark?

Lovely selection of cars though!!

ZeusF

377 posts

154 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
TBH I "think" its just a kid doing what he loves.
Ive said it before, we often forget what we were like as kids and now the way the kids express themselves is through the internet so a different world as such.

Im not sure the title is genuine though smile

DMT84

124 posts

188 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
I'm good with spotting cars but even I crossed the road a few months ago and didnt spot a yellow scuderia replica until I was right on top of it. I had to take my hat off to the workmanship.

I find that 360s are ageing so badly now that they all look like replicas.

rosino

1,403 posts

203 months

Wednesday 26th March 2014
quotequote all
Pioneer said:
lamboman100 said:
Not so good for the rich or semi-rich. They devalue brands and diminish the rarity value.
Aren't they illegal in some countries? I thought if it had the manufacturer's badge and was pretending to be the real thing it could be confiscated - same as fake bags, electronics etc.
In Italy it is completely illegal and equivalent to counterfeiting a luxury watch/handbag etc etc. Item would be confiscated and you would get a BIG fine..

And rightly so

Pioneer

1,351 posts

162 months

Wednesday 26th March 2014
quotequote all
rosino said:
In Italy it is completely illegal and equivalent to counterfeiting a luxury watch/handbag etc etc. Item would be confiscated and you would get a BIG fine..

And rightly so
Makes sense. Can't see why it would be any different over here. I wonder what would happen if McLaren replicas started appearing?

GSP

1,965 posts

235 months

Wednesday 26th March 2014
quotequote all
It looks good, but it does devalue the brand in my opinion.

95% of people are not car nuts, and probably could not tell the difference between a real 355 or Countach and the fake equivelents... so when ever one of the 95% sees a 355 or Countach, and to some extent the more modern 360/430/Murcielago... they are left wondering if they are looking at the real deal or a replica.

It's a shame.

MalcQV

243 posts

265 months

Monday 12th May 2014
quotequote all
One of the things I struggle with when out in my car is the looks and comments you sometimes get. Mostly they're good but on occasion they're most certainly bad.
I'd be a little more embarrassed if my 'Ferrari' was actually a replica.
Ultimately the people who buy them, like me, love cars and as such there is credibility there. I didn't always think that way.
A couple of years ago at a Classic car show, Italian marques (included anything Italian) were opposite the Replica Italian cars, maybe done deliberately, they perhaps wanted a war to break out biggrin? Anyway I was talking to an owner of a replica F355 (MR2). He said he got a lot of fulfillment out of making the car as real as he was capable. Then his mate came up and said we should have a race.
That chap was a complete dick.