F430 F1 v manual
Author
Discussion

gbrownlow

Original Poster:

4,843 posts

201 months

Saturday 5th February 2011
quotequote all
Whats the general consensus on the way to go ?

Test drove F1 for first time today and thought it was very good and much better than 360 but still not sure if I like it as much as my manual F355. Felt like something was missing but then would I get use to that in time.

Changes up seemed a little jerky ( whichever mode ) but maybe I wasn't revving it hard enough or timing it right. Downshifts I couldn't fault, went in straight away with no jerk.

I know F1 is the latest new fangle technology and most F430's seem to have it but is manual a no no and more difficult to sell on later. The little gear stick seems a little old hat now.

Your experince and opinions would be appreciated as Im still undecided on this issue as well as the spyder v coupe situation.

I know I want a F430 but as I hope to keep it for a while I have to make the right decision first time with this sort of money

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 5th February 2011
quotequote all
Sorry off topic but did you test drive it in Swindon?

renmure

4,952 posts

255 months

Saturday 5th February 2011
quotequote all
My thoughts are fairly simplistic.
I think F355s should be manual (mine was), 360s can really be either (manual again for me), and 430s should be F1.
Guess thats because my mental image of a 355 has the open chrome gate manual box and that the 430 is in the "flappy paddle" age so should have the F1 box.

Lambo FirstBlood

1,001 posts

210 months

Saturday 5th February 2011
quotequote all
renmure said:
My thoughts are fairly simplistic.
I think F355s should be manual (mine was), 360s can really be either (manual again for me), and 430s should be F1.
Guess thats because my mental image of a 355 has the open chrome gate manual box and that the 430 is in the "flappy paddle" age so should have the F1 box.
+1 on all of the above.

Slightly off topic but I feel the same about the V12 cars.
550 should be manual, 575 could be either and F1 for the 599.




RevHappy

1,850 posts

193 months

Saturday 5th February 2011
quotequote all
On the 360 I'd still take a stick. For the 430, f1 every time, drive a few more, they do differ and clutch ware seems to make a difference. The modes should feel very different on the up shift, down is alway good with the blip.

gbrownlow

Original Poster:

4,843 posts

201 months

Saturday 5th February 2011
quotequote all
Was only a 20 min drive on a few different types of road in Exeter so probably need more drive time to evaluate the F1 box and like you say compare it with others.
My company car is diesel so not so use to revving it up to 9,000 rpm.

Where in the rev range is best to change for a smooth take up. At low revs it felt jerky but higher up it felt like I was racing the thing.

Whilst the change downs were seamless I hardly noticed the blip unless it was a big drop. Is the auto blip that noticeable.

This was a Ferrari approved car with low miles and FFSH so it should be a good example and not a dog

RevHappy

1,850 posts

193 months

Saturday 5th February 2011
quotequote all
I drove three in a week to keep the concept fresh in my mind, all main dealer cars don't worry about the miles too low is bad news in my book. The 430 is a race car with a soft interior but can be driven normally if you want. Those rev's are there to be used, it's a different car over 4k rpm. If its safe to do so and the car is nice and warm you should get needle straight up on a test drive, smile and keep it above 4k to keep the exhaust open and singing.

lambo_xx

2,199 posts

228 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
gbrownlow said:
Whats the general consensus on the way to go ?

Test drove F1 for first time today and thought it was very good and much better than 360 but still not sure if I like it as much as my manual F355. Felt like something was missing but then would I get use to that in time.

Changes up seemed a little jerky ( whichever mode ) but maybe I wasn't revving it hard enough or timing it right. Downshifts I couldn't fault, went in straight away with no jerk.

I know F1 is the latest new fangle technology and most F430's seem to have it but is manual a no no and more difficult to sell on later. The little gear stick seems a little old hat now.

Your experince and opinions would be appreciated as Im still undecided on this issue as well as the spyder v coupe situation.

I know I want a F430 but as I hope to keep it for a while I have to make the right decision first time with this sort of money
My 355 is a manual and I wouldn't change it for anything. For me the car is a little old school and having the open metal gate is part of that. My 430 on the other hand is F1. I think it really suits the car and I don't regret going F1. I've never driven a manual 430 so can't comment what it's like but my advice would be to buy whichever you prefer. Arguably manual 430s will be worth a little bit less but then you’ll pay less for one. Also, there are a smaller number of manual cars available and there’s always going to be someone who wants a manual. Regarding the F1 up changes, if you lift your foot slightly off the accelerator, when you pull the paddle, that makes it smooth.

Hope that helps and good luck with your choice.


andy355

1,347 posts

269 months

Sunday 6th February 2011
quotequote all
i prefer f1 to manual. it is however redundant technology and quite retarded when it comes to some things - like hills, reversing, traffic. etc but also rewarding, they still need some technique even the 430 version

how does the box on the cali, 458 feel like after f1? does it still give the same feeling that you are actually changing gear or does it feel like paddles on an auto box like on a merc

roygarth

2,674 posts

279 months

Tuesday 8th February 2011
quotequote all
Ferrari say that the 430 will be their last ever model available in manual. So I would expect to see values moving up to 288GTO/F40/F50/Enzo levels in the not to distant future smile

lambo_xx

2,199 posts

228 months

Tuesday 8th February 2011
quotequote all
roygarth said:
Ferrari say that the 430 will be their last ever model available in manual. So I would expect to see values moving up to 288GTO/F40/F50/Enzo levels in the not to distant future smile
California and 599 are both available in manual.

russdunkin

65 posts

223 months

Tuesday 8th February 2011
quotequote all
When I was buying my F430, initially I was in the "F1 will remove some of the joy of driving, it's got to be manual" camp. Then I started reading all the threads and it became clear most people who've owned at F430 with F1 were saying they liked it. In the first few days of owning the car, to be honest I wasn't sure if I'd made the right decision. It felt a bit playstation and crawling in traffic was a bit of a pain. I could certainly understand why people didn't like it after a test drive. But a few days it "clicked". Fast foward thousands of miles later and there would be no going back for me now. The F430's F1 is excellent. I'd recommend any potential buyer who's unsure go for it - it's well worth the premium.

MaxAndRuby

6,792 posts

263 months

Tuesday 8th February 2011
quotequote all
roygarth said:
Ferrari say that the 430 will be their last ever model available in manual. So I would expect to see values moving up to 288GTO/F40/F50/Enzo levels in the not to distant future smile
yeswink

UH-Matt

2,173 posts

271 months

Tuesday 8th February 2011
quotequote all
I assume its a joke saying F430 will be up at F40/50 etc levels eventually...

Number of units produced would ensure that won't ever be the case.

gbrownlow

Original Poster:

4,843 posts

201 months

Tuesday 8th February 2011
quotequote all
Seems 75% of cars are F1 and those that have them are very pleased with it, giving the technology the thumbs up over the manual.

The jury is still out with me after a 2nd drive today. Maybe I'm still clinging onto the old school way of thinking which is very unlike me when it comes to cars but the F1 driving certainly hasn't clicked yet despite trying to convince myself thats the way I should be going.
If people are now suggesting rarer manuals are going to hold their value better that may sway me to stick with the old and safe gear stick which is also kinder on the clutch.

Do I stick with what I know or embrace the technology because it is so much better when I get used to not using my leg and arm ?

markst

247 posts

196 months

Wednesday 9th February 2011
quotequote all
i have to say i have the same problem.....driven the F1 and whilst it was not as bad as i feared , i still felt it took some of the joy away from driving....

...so if anybody knows of a manual 430 spider in rosso corsa available please let me know !!

but would i actually buy an F1......well the anser is yes....but only if i cannot get a manual....lol

cgt2

7,500 posts

219 months

Wednesday 9th February 2011
quotequote all
Go with what you feel is right. When I was buying a 575 I wanted a manual with Handling Pack. Everyone warned me manuals were unsaleable. I drove the F1 and it removed too much driver interaction, didnt do it for me. Bought a manual, loved it, drove it lots and had two like minded people in a desperate race to buy it when I decided to sell. Manuals are now very sought after and tend to sell quickly in that particular model.

Just because on paper the F1 is better (though now an already outmoded concept with the twin clutch 458 box) does not mean it will give you the pleasure a manual will. As mentioned above, as time goes on the manual Ferraris will become more sought after for their pure driver involvement while I think F1 will be an anachronism. Who today would buy a Sportomatic early 911 over a manual?

Beaver

1,056 posts

315 months

Wednesday 9th February 2011
quotequote all
I kept away from F1 on my 3 F cars, same with a Gallardo. Had DSG in a GT-R and really liked it, to a point.

Now have a manual Boxster Spyder but drove an F430 F1 yesterday and because I'm comparing it to the GT-R's DSG set up (which I also have in my Mk1 TT) I really enjoyed it.

I've driven my friend's 360 F1 a few times and didn't like it at all, but the F430 transmission seems to to do it for me.

Just need to stop listening to my head and go with my heart to change cars.

g3off

6 posts

257 months

Thursday 10th February 2011
quotequote all
Opinion will always be divided as can be seen by the number of F430 manuals around. I drove a manual 360 for a few years and loved it, though if I was honest I could shift gears faster in my Focus. I followed this with a 360CS my first flappy paddle F1 experience and hated it; after a manual it didn't feel like real driving, the whole experience felt wrong ..... that was until I got used to it when I realised spanking it had never been so much fun (the CS was and still is my favourite ever car). I've now had a 430 Scuderia for a couple of years and even if a manual was an option I wouldn't even consider it. Your bound to have a good time which ever way you go, but if I were you I'd give the F1 box a chance.

tuscaneer

7,992 posts

256 months

Thursday 10th February 2011
quotequote all
little bit off topic but what would be considered average mileage on a five year old manual f430 ??