Mid Engine AWD, Front Gearbox?
Mid Engine AWD, Front Gearbox?
Author
Discussion

43655

Original Poster:

54 posts

183 months

Tuesday 1st August 2017
quotequote all
I know this has been covered before but has anyone successfully done it or seen it done running the transaxle in front of the engine?
All that I can think of is the Audi R8 & Lambos which use the Oerlikon Graziano gearbox, but the stock gearing is crap sadly for a relatively low-revving engine.

A little background, tube chassis build, Lexus 4.3 V8 (future twin turbo) so Porsche trans would have been the go-to but they're both rare and expensive.
Doing this the gearbox choice is broader and cheaper, although I admit i know little about running a transfer case and separate diff (as far as suitable choice goes, for a road/track car with potentially over 600whp)



Despite being somewhat heavier, the mass of the drivetrain would be considerably better centered (bear in mind a standard transaxle has some 90% of its mass behind the axle!)

I figure it could be configured as a RWD only setup initially, then add on a diff, propshaft and front diff.

for this out of curiosity...

stevieturbo

17,970 posts

271 months

Tuesday 1st August 2017
quotequote all
Other than the drivetrain wanting to drive the car in reverse with that layout, it would work.

You'd need to flip the F/R diffs to get forward drive in all normal gears.

if that's the layout you want, even Porsche drivetrain wouldnt be suitable.

Emanresu

311 posts

113 months

Tuesday 1st August 2017
quotequote all
Couldn't you just flip everything backwards then use an engine the turns backwards, s2000 for example?

43655

Original Poster:

54 posts

183 months

Tuesday 1st August 2017
quotequote all
Could easilly be changed by inverting the diffs or yeah swapping front rear although I have no ideas yet in which I'd use.

Porsche box gets used all the time, the gearbox is both upside down and the wrong way around, giving 4/5/6 forward gears etc as normal. The trouble is a good one is £7k+. Most transaxles are either too weak, the wrong way up (driveshafts under the input shaft which would put the engine undesirably high) or just crazy money.
BMW gearboxes are getting popular for UZ-FE conversions for being cheap and strong, and they're surprisingly compact too, which led me to start considering this layout again

anonymous-user

78 months

Tuesday 1st August 2017
quotequote all
The off road boys have been doing this for donkeys! Way back in the early 90's we were building buggies with rear mounted RV8s, pointing forwards, running a saloon car box, and a short prop to the xfer case under the front bulkhead, and a prop all the way back to the rear diff, using axles with the centres cut out and flipped.

The issue in a small car is always that the big bell housing is right where the occupants butts need to be, rather than where their feet are, which forces a wide apart seating layout.

Andy Burtons PugCossy had similar layout, as did the metro 6R4 of course:


Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

279 months

Wednesday 2nd August 2017
quotequote all
Emanresu said:
Couldn't you just flip everything backwards then use an engine the turns backwards, s2000 for example?
The S2000 engine doesn't turn backwards.

chuntington101

5,733 posts

260 months

Thursday 3rd August 2017
quotequote all
Are there any cheaper gearboxes like the GTRs that would incorporate a gearbox, transfer case and front diff in a single unit? Would make the install a little easier regarding the passenger area.

stevieturbo

17,970 posts

271 months

Thursday 3rd August 2017
quotequote all
chuntington101 said:
Are there any cheaper gearboxes like the GTRs that would incorporate a gearbox, transfer case and front diff in a single unit? Would make the install a little easier regarding the passenger area.
GTR's do not do that

chuntington101

5,733 posts

260 months

Friday 4th August 2017
quotequote all
stevieturbo said:
chuntington101 said:
Are there any cheaper gearboxes like the GTRs that would incorporate a gearbox, transfer case and front diff in a single unit? Would make the install a little easier regarding the passenger area.
GTR's do not do that
The new ones do it the other way around. Engine front and gearbox, centre diff, etc. in the rear.

It you ran it in the opposite orientation It would still require the gearbox to be in the way but would be where a normal gearbox would be on a front engined RWD car.



stevieturbo

17,970 posts

271 months

Friday 4th August 2017
quotequote all
chuntington101 said:
The new ones do it the other way around. Engine front and gearbox, centre diff, etc. in the rear.

It you ran it in the opposite orientation It would still require the gearbox to be in the way but would be where a normal gearbox would be on a front engined RWD car.
New GTR's run a rear transaxle type arrangement. But they still require a front diff. They are also inherently RWD with a clutch pack to send drive to the front. So not really a centre diff in the usual sense.

To try and reverse one of those would be a lot of work.

Older GTR's are much like his drawing, old Fords etc etc

prof

19 posts

290 months

Thursday 17th August 2017
quotequote all

Toltec

7,179 posts

247 months

Friday 3rd August 2018
quotequote all
Yes, holy thread reboot batman.

Weird idea, if you took a transverse engine and gear box and turned it longitudinally could you feed the output shafts to additional differentials at the front and rear?


generationx

8,887 posts

129 months

Friday 3rd August 2018
quotequote all
Toltec said:
Yes, holy thread reboot batman.

Weird idea, if you took a transverse engine and gear box and turned it longitudinally could you feed the output shafts to additional differentials at the front and rear?
This is sort of the concept of what the Peugeot 205-T16 did - basically a mid/rear mounted transverse 4-cylinder engine with an adapted transaxle-type gearbox also mounted transversely which used its "left" and "right" differential outputs to go to the front and rear differentials (if I recall correctly).

Group B had a few interesting ideas, the Ford RS200 was mid/rear longtitudinal engine driving a gearbox at the front of the car which then drove back to the rear differential. The theory was it was good for weight distribution.

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

279 months

Friday 3rd August 2018
quotequote all
Toltec said:
Yes, holy thread reboot batman.

Weird idea, if you took a transverse engine and gear box and turned it longitudinally could you feed the output shafts to additional differentials at the front and rear?
Yes, if you wanted to build a rock crawler you could do exactly that. With two lots of final drive reductions it won't be so good for anything fast, unless you can find front and rear diffs with 1:1 ratios.

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

150 months

Friday 3rd August 2018
quotequote all
Toltec said:
Weird idea, if you took a transverse engine and gear box and turned it longitudinally could you feed the output shafts to additional differentials at the front and rear?
Lohr FL500 - French military vehicle. In production and service in the 70s.

2cv engine and box, turned 90deg. One driveshaft going for'ard, one aft'ard.




They're quite a lot of fun to drive. There's a centre difflock - belts off each output shaft to a layshaft, which is then pulled taut to "lock"...

Edited by TooMany2cvs on Friday 3rd August 15:51

Toltec

7,179 posts

247 months

Friday 3rd August 2018
quotequote all
Mr2Mike said:
Toltec said:
Yes, holy thread reboot batman.

Weird idea, if you took a transverse engine and gear box and turned it longitudinally could you feed the output shafts to additional differentials at the front and rear?
Yes, if you wanted to build a rock crawler you could do exactly that. With two lots of final drive reductions it won't be so good for anything fast, unless you can find front and rear diffs with 1:1 ratios.
Ha, I knew there would be a problem somewhere, I suppose you could try to get the ratio in the gearbox diff as numerically low as possible too.

anonymous-user

78 months

Monday 6th August 2018
quotequote all
TooMany2cvs said:
There's a centre difflock - belts off each output shaft to a layshaft, which is then pulled taut to "lock"...
that's ^^^ a really clever, brilliantly simple, solution to getting a locking centre diff !

Stiggolas

360 posts

171 months

Tuesday 7th August 2018
quotequote all
You have no idea how much I want one of those...