Rubbing Brake Discs - Brake Disc Skimming?
Discussion
There are a few minor niggles with my 05 Monaro CV8 that are on my to do list. The first was annoyingly noticeable today whilst cruising around with the windows down. It sounds as if the pads are rubbing very slightly on the front discs. It's not a harsh sound, although it is very slightly metallic. It increases in frequency with road speed, so its clearly something (presumably the disc and pad) rubbing with each revolution. It's interfering with my enjoyment of the exhaust burble, so needs sorted ASAP.
Yes, I know, fitting a louder exhaust might be one answer (!) but I'll need to get this sorted anyway. Hate to think of any unnecessary friction harming precious fuel consumption. It recently passed an MOT so I don't think the discs can be warped or anything major like that, and although I am generally gentle on the brakes, I haven't noticed any vibration.
I was wondering about getting the discs skimmed in an attempt to cure the problem. Has anyone experienced anything similar, and has anyone solved it with disc skimming?
Yes, I know, fitting a louder exhaust might be one answer (!) but I'll need to get this sorted anyway. Hate to think of any unnecessary friction harming precious fuel consumption. It recently passed an MOT so I don't think the discs can be warped or anything major like that, and although I am generally gentle on the brakes, I haven't noticed any vibration.
I was wondering about getting the discs skimmed in an attempt to cure the problem. Has anyone experienced anything similar, and has anyone solved it with disc skimming?
It's more than likely either hardened brakepad deposits on the discs or a slightly raised profile on the pad itself.
If some hard 'enthusiastic' braking to standstill doesn't cure it, take the pads out and get a file to them.
I had a similar a problem for weeks but after a few sessions this weekend of 160+ to 30ish it seems to have gone.
If some hard 'enthusiastic' braking to standstill doesn't cure it, take the pads out and get a file to them.
I had a similar a problem for weeks but after a few sessions this weekend of 160+ to 30ish it seems to have gone.
Always do the simple and cheapest things first!!.. have the callipers/pads serviced (easy to do yourself)...get everything cleaned up with brake cleaner and lube'd up with something like this... http://www.opieoils.co.uk/p-999-fuchs-renolit-red-...
Make sure callipers are sliding ok and pads are seated and located well.
It is highly unlikely the discs will need skimming, any issues there and you would feel vibration under braking!....it is quite normal to hear a very slight rubbing of the brake pad surface against the disc, the discs are floating and there is no mechanical mechanism to pull the pads away from the disc, they just sit there, awaiting the next application of the two pistons against the back of the inner pad.
Make sure callipers are sliding ok and pads are seated and located well.
It is highly unlikely the discs will need skimming, any issues there and you would feel vibration under braking!....it is quite normal to hear a very slight rubbing of the brake pad surface against the disc, the discs are floating and there is no mechanical mechanism to pull the pads away from the disc, they just sit there, awaiting the next application of the two pistons against the back of the inner pad.
As other people have said, sounds like the brakes need a clean up. Get the caliper off and pads out. Then use a wire brush to clean out areas of brake pad deposits. You may need to use a metal file in some places too, to get back to a smooth finish. Then use some copper grease or similar when you re-assemble the brakes, taking car to get it on the areas where the pads are supposed to float, like the "hammer heads" on the ends of the pads. Of course avoid contaminating the pad friction material and the disc.
I had similar issues with my brakes and i also suspected one caliper was sticking slightly. So at the weekend I stripped the brakes down, cleaned all the brake dust out, tidied up the pads, made sure the pistons were free to move and reassembled with a dab of copper grease on the parts that slide.
Brakes now feel much better and i'm fairly sure there's less noise coming from the front wheels. Only took about an hour so well worth a try if you have the tools. I'll be doing the same with the rear end when i get chance as the handshake definitely needs adjusting too!
Brakes now feel much better and i'm fairly sure there's less noise coming from the front wheels. Only took about an hour so well worth a try if you have the tools. I'll be doing the same with the rear end when i get chance as the handshake definitely needs adjusting too!
Thanks guys, all good advice. I hadn't appreciated that there is no mechanical force that keeps the pads off the disc. However, the fact it is a rhythmic sound rather than a continuous rubbing suggests to me that there has to be either warping, corrosion, or deposits of some kind that result in greater contact at a certain point with every rotation of the disc.
Stripping my brakes may be slightly beyond my tools and mechanical skills. I've done it on a mountain bike with disc brakes and rubbed down the pads, but would be a bit scared about screwing with the brakes on the Ro.
I might try and find a suitable stretch of road and do some heavy brake testing, but if that doesn't work, and skimming is cheap (I'd heard around £30/40), that seems to me to be worth a try and cheaper than new pads, which might be the next option. Monaro5.7, I've sent you an email re the place you know does it.
There's a website on line (I'm not sure if I'm allowed to mention the name here) that is all about brake disc skimming and which appears to be set up by the company that makes the lathes. It has a map with garages around the UK, but the Edinburgh ones appear to be two Skoda main dealers and a citroen C8 specialist(?!).
Stripping my brakes may be slightly beyond my tools and mechanical skills. I've done it on a mountain bike with disc brakes and rubbed down the pads, but would be a bit scared about screwing with the brakes on the Ro.
I might try and find a suitable stretch of road and do some heavy brake testing, but if that doesn't work, and skimming is cheap (I'd heard around £30/40), that seems to me to be worth a try and cheaper than new pads, which might be the next option. Monaro5.7, I've sent you an email re the place you know does it.
There's a website on line (I'm not sure if I'm allowed to mention the name here) that is all about brake disc skimming and which appears to be set up by the company that makes the lathes. It has a map with garages around the UK, but the Edinburgh ones appear to be two Skoda main dealers and a citroen C8 specialist(?!).
Lil'RedGTO said:
the fact it is a rhythmic sound rather than a continuous rubbing suggests to me that there has to be either warping, corrosion, or deposits of some kind that result in greater contact at a certain point with every rotation of the disc.
The other thing it could be, is on the outside edge of the disc, you sometimes get a lip develop and corrosion can form here. When flakes form they can protrude from this outer circumference of the disc and then rub on the calliper as they pass through. A good way to sort this is to use a chisel held so its side is against the top of the calliper, and the tip in contact with the disc. Rotate the disc by hand and the chisel will scrape the outer circumference of the disc and clear the corrosion.Update: Took the car for a proper cross country run today on the twisties in the Scottish Borders and, hey presto, brake disc rubbing noise gone! Must just have been deposits on the disc after all. Note to self: use the car in anger a bit more often. I'd almost forgotten what a pleasure it is to make proper progress on a quiet A road.
Glad you are all sorted (for the time being!!)
I fitted some new Mintex pads just before the trip to Le Mans, they were a big improvement over the old three quarter worn EBC's that were on.. but while in France i developed a violent brake judder at speed!...I have removed the discs and they are being skimmed and having the outer lip removed.... I had noticed the new pad material was slightly deeper and was being worn away by the raised lip on the outer edge of discs!...Hopefully this will sort my problem, seems CV8 Brakes are prone to having issues!
I fitted some new Mintex pads just before the trip to Le Mans, they were a big improvement over the old three quarter worn EBC's that were on.. but while in France i developed a violent brake judder at speed!...I have removed the discs and they are being skimmed and having the outer lip removed.... I had noticed the new pad material was slightly deeper and was being worn away by the raised lip on the outer edge of discs!...Hopefully this will sort my problem, seems CV8 Brakes are prone to having issues!
fildigger said:
Glad you are all sorted (for the time being!!)
I fitted some new Mintex pads just before the trip to Le Mans, they were a big improvement over the old three quarter worn EBC's that were on.. but while in France i developed a violent brake judder at speed!...I have removed the discs and they are being skimmed and having the outer lip removed.... I had noticed the new pad material was slightly deeper and was being worn away by the raised lip on the outer edge of discs!...Hopefully this will sort my problem, seems CV8 Brakes are prone to having issues!
Hi Phil. hope your well matey, you should look out for some later VXR discs and calipers on ebay or on here, they will make the car soooo much better, done the same to my CV8 big improvement and very easy to do. I fitted some new Mintex pads just before the trip to Le Mans, they were a big improvement over the old three quarter worn EBC's that were on.. but while in France i developed a violent brake judder at speed!...I have removed the discs and they are being skimmed and having the outer lip removed.... I had noticed the new pad material was slightly deeper and was being worn away by the raised lip on the outer edge of discs!...Hopefully this will sort my problem, seems CV8 Brakes are prone to having issues!
Let us know how you get on. I did find a guy with one of these brake lathes which skim the discs while they are on the car (on a ramp), for which he only charges £50 per axle, but hopefully won't need to use him now (for a while at least). Noted that wider new pads and brake disc lips don't mix very well - good to know!
fildigger said:
It is highly unlikely the discs will need skimming, any issues there and you would feel vibration under braking!....it is quite normal to hear a very slight rubbing of the brake pad surface against the disc, the discs are floating and there is no mechanical mechanism to pull the pads away from the disc, they just sit there, awaiting the next application of the two pistons against the back of the inner pad.
If you hear the pads rubbing in a rhythmic way, then its HIGHLY likely your disc is out of alignment on the hub, and the pads are gradually wearing out areas of the disc leading to disc thickness variation... which is the main cause of brake judder.... which can only be fixed properly by skimming a disc IN SITU on the hub. Simple physics and mechanics.See the Pro Cut or Skim my discs websites for the reasoning behind this. Also plenty of web sites from pro racers and rally guys say exactly the same thing.
Gassing Station | HSV & Monaro | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



